Swirling Purpose & Performance with Jay Tandan (Ben & Jerry’s) artwork

Swirling Purpose & Performance How Ben & Jerry's Turns Activism Into Measurable Action

Jay Tandan, Global Digital Lead, Ben & Jerry’s

· 38 min

Summary

Jay Tandan, Global Digital Lead at Ben & Jerry's, said the company measures its activism by whether the causes it champions make progress, rather than by reach or by whether people like the brand, and said that advocacy work is also good for business.

Ben & Jerry's drove over 200,000 policy actions globally in the previous year by engaging its fans on those issues.

Watch the episode

Questions answered

How should a brand measure the success of its activism?

Ben & Jerry's measures success on its social mission by whether the issues and causes it champions are making progress, said Jay Tandan, the company's Global Digital Lead, because the mission exists to drive social change rather than to make people like the brand. Ben & Jerry's aligns every campaign with movement leaders and partners who know the issues better than it does, then sets a specific objective for each piece of content: awareness, education or a coordinated action. Each objective returns different data signals, which hold the team accountable and help it improve over time. Ben & Jerry's drove over 200,000 policy actions globally in the previous year by engaging its fans on these issues.

Which metrics show real engagement better than reach and views?

Email click-through rate, engaged time on site and video retention say more than reach and video views, Tandan said. At Ben & Jerry's, email click-through was about 10 times better than all social at getting people to the site, and engaged time shows whether people are actually scrolling and reading rather than leaving a tab open. On TikTok, retention can tell more than the view count on the thumbnail. The main challenge has been separating signal from noise, work done in partnership with LooseGrip, because trend-driven videos can earn large view counts without moving any issue forward.

The team still shares big reach totals to celebrate a year, but does not optimize on them. Jay would rather see a steady rise in the number of videos hitting a target metric than two videos that reached 15 million people for reasons nobody can explain, because steady growth shows what is working and can be repeated. In his view, chasing big numbers means missing what is really happening, especially as new platforms change what works from one year to the next.

Is brand activism good for business?

At Ben & Jerry's it is, Jay said: over a year, its advocacy posts were on balance more potent on social than its product posts, and a product post that follows a high-visibility advocacy moment can perform better than usual. The team first noticed this halo effect by chance, and now also uses the momentum to post a follow-up on the same issue. The finding helps the team message up through the organization that advocacy is good for business, which puts it on the offensive instead of defending the work's right to exist.

For Ben & Jerry's, advocacy work is also more measurable end to end than product sales, since much of its ice cream is sold in grocery stores where it cannot be tracked online. A campaign in St. Louis with ArchCity Defenders, which pressed the city's board of aldermen to rethink spending on a jail that mostly held people awaiting trial who could not post bail, used creative, copy and audience testing whose rigor was then taken to product marketing.

How much of a brand's content should be about its values?

Ben & Jerry's keeps a loose split of roughly one third advocacy content and two thirds product and general brand content, even though advocacy takes more work to produce. When there has been pressure to do more of it because it performs well, the answer has been that Ben & Jerry's does not do advocacy for the business benefit. Jay said the work is potent because it is thoughtful and aligned with what social justice movements need, and because it is shaped by activism managers who all come from the nonprofit world. That authenticity and credibility cannot be manufactured, he said, though the advocacy and marketing sides can compete at times.

How do you build a culture of measurement across marketing and activism teams?

Ben & Jerry's runs one content process for ice cream and advocacy content, measured the same way and reported on the same cadence, so everybody is along for the same ride. The culture was already there, because people in the company believe in the mission. Tools like UTM tags are easier to explain to the activism managers in its six biggest countries with a side-by-side of what a post report can say with and without them, which turns a one-line note about reach into a full story. Data is fertile ground for telling stories, and the message to the whole company is that the two sides are stronger together and can inform each other.

Key takeaways

  • Ben & Jerry's defines success on its social mission as whether it won or lost on the issues it champions with movement partners, not whether the work makes people like the brand.
  • Ben & Jerry's drove over 200,000 policy actions across the globe in the previous year by engaging its fans on the issues it campaigns on.
  • Ben & Jerry's matches each piece of content to one objective (awareness, education or action) and reads different signals for each, whether the subject is an ice cream flavor or a policy campaign.
  • Email click-through rate was about 10 times better than all social for getting people to the Ben & Jerry's site, and the team looks at engaged time on site and video retention rather than time on site and video views.
  • Ben & Jerry's runs one content process for ice cream and advocacy posts, with the same measurement and reporting cadence. Roughly one third of its content is advocacy and two thirds is product and general brand content.
  • At Ben & Jerry's, product posts published after a high-visibility advocacy moment sometimes perform better, a halo effect that helps the team show internally that advocacy is good for business.
  • Performance marketing rigor developed on advocacy campaigns, such as the St. Louis campaign with ArchCity Defenders, was carried over to product marketing, since much of Ben & Jerry's ice cream is sold in grocery stores where sales cannot be tracked online.

Quotes

Ben & Jerry's across the globe last year drove over 200,000 policy actions through engaging our fans on these topics. I think that's really awesome and quantifiable.

Jay Tandan

We've noticed that on balance, the stuff we post about our advocacy is more potent than our product stuff.

Jay Tandan

Oftentimes people find themselves in a defensive position with this type of work... For us, it's even the opposite. We're on the offensive. This is good for business, and more people should be doing that.

Jay Tandan

Everybody wants to ooh and ahh over the millions of people reach, but it's like, well, if you were trying to get people to the site to do something, wow, email actually was 10 times better than everything else.

Jay Tandan

Frequently asked questions

Should a brand measure activism content differently from product content?

Ben & Jerry's measures them the same way, because marketing a product and marketing an idea both come down to driving awareness, education or a conversion such as buying something or taking an action. Both go through one content process with the same measurement and reporting cadence.

How can a company make sure its activism is not greenwashing?

Ben & Jerry's holds itself to a high standard of measuring whether it is really delivering, Jay Tandan said, partly because as a for-profit company it does not want to only appear to be doing the work. It aligns every campaign with movement leaders and partners who know the issues better than the brand does.

Why is a viral post a poor guide for content decisions?

A video that reaches millions because it happened to catch a trending audio gives Ben & Jerry's nothing to act on, since it is impossible to tell why it worked. Tracking whether the number of videos hitting a target metric grows over time shows what can be repeated.

Who is Jay Tandan?

Jay Tandan is Global Digital Lead at Ben & Jerry's, where he runs the global digital team covering digital marketing, e-commerce, social and web. He started at the company as a scooper at its flagship shop in Vermont during college and has been there about 16 years.

How many policy actions did Ben & Jerry's drive?

Ben & Jerry's drove over 200,000 policy actions across the globe in the previous year by engaging its fans on the issues it campaigns on.

About the guest

Jay Tandan was Global Digital Lead at Ben & Jerry's when this episode was recorded. He started with the company as a college scooper in Vermont and spent 16 years there, leading its digital marketing, e-commerce and social strategy. He is now at Protect Our Winters.

About this episode

In this episode, Neil sits down with Jay Tandan, the Global Digital Lead at Ben & Jerry’s. Jay’s journey with the iconic ice cream brand began as a college "scooper" in Vermont and evolved into a 16-year career leading the company’s digital marketing, e-commerce, and social strategy.

The conversation dives deep into how Ben & Jerry’s balances its "triple bottom line"—prioritizing social mission and progressive activism alongside product sales. Jay explains why the company identifies as a "social justice company that happens to make ice cream" and how his team uses digital channels to drive real-world policy change.

Transcript

Read the full transcript

Neil Callanan 00:02

All right. Welcome everybody today. I am joined by long time Ben and Jerry's, team member, digital lead and my buddy, Jay Tandan, Jay leads all things digital for Ben and Jerry's including marketing, DCOM, social, and web Jay. Thanks for joining us,

Jay Tandan 00:19

Good to be here.

Neil Callanan 00:21

So I like to start off with an easy one. Who are you? Where do you live? And who do you work for?

Jay Tandan 00:27

Jay Tandan, live in Vermont, home of Ben and Jerry's, also home of a record snowfall year, which is very lovely. Yeah, and yeah, I work for Ben and Jerry's, run the global digital team, been doing that for a few years, but about 16 years at the company all in, so it's been a good ride.

Neil Callanan 00:38

Cheers.

Neil Callanan 00:53

So how, what led you to that, to the role you're at today? How did you get hooked up with Ben & Jerry's? How'd you start?

Jay Tandan 01:00

the history books go back to my college job. I started in college as a scooper at the flagship shop in Vermont and thought the company was cool and wanted to know more about what it was all about and started scooping. And, the rest is kind of history, but, you know, pinged around within the company, mostly in marketing, mostly in digital. And I've sort of netted to the role that I'm in now. but fun fact, my first

full-time job was answering phones, just doing that game of not enough cookie dough in my pint or, you know, we don't like what you said about, you know, some activism topics. So I heard it all from people.

Neil Callanan 01:42

Uh, well then I have to ask before I get into the nerdy data questions, what is the hardest part about being an ice cream scooper at a Ben & Jerry's or any ice cream shop, I guess, generally.

Jay Tandan 01:56

It's all so good, honestly. People are so happy to be there. Everyone's smiling. It's usually, you know, you're out with a group of friends or family, you know, there aren't that many bad things. Every once in a while, you get somebody upset about something that is not that important and you let it...

Neil Callanan 02:11

Your scooping arm gets substantially stronger than your offhand. So talk to me about what Ben and Jerry's does and how you guys think about yourselves in the world.

Jay Tandan 02:14

Yeah, exactly. You're one sided.

Jay Tandan 02:28

Yeah.

Most people know that Ben & Jerry's is kind of more than just an ice cream company. The co-founders sort of were the originators of this idea of a three-part mission or a triple bottom line. You know, they're cited in all the business textbooks and the MBA classes, the MBA classes that I didn't take, unfortunately. um But this idea that it's about more than just turning a profit, more than just selling the ice cream. And so that has permeated for

the over four decades that the company's been in business. And I think it's still truly embraced and championed by the people in the company. And so when it comes to our own, when it comes to how we think about our work, everybody owns a bit of the social mission. And I think particularly in the digital space and in my role with my team, we sort of control or kind of have the keys to a lot of the public facing channels that people, that's how people see the brand in the world.

And so it's a super important part of our work is to bring our advocacy work to life, bring our social mission to life, because it's core to who we are as Ben & Jerry's. And so we've had people in the company at times say, we're a social justice company that happens to make ice cream. And so think that's a good summary of where Ben & Jerry's is at.

Neil Callanan 03:48

So when you, when you started with the team, what, was your expectation about how that would kind of manifest itself, what that would look like and how is that kind of maybe misplaced in terms of the reality of like, I'm going to go work for these social justice warriors and change the world. And, how does that actually manifest itself or differently than you expected it would, when you got onto the job.

Jay Tandan 04:16

Yeah. Funnily enough, and I'll go back in my, you know, the Rolodex of memories of Ben and Jerry's, but one was when I first moved from being outside of the shop into the corporate headquarters, the global headquarters are here in Vermont. And I kind of expected to find, it can't be as good as it looks from the outside, right? People can't really believe this stuff as much as they do. And maybe it was being a, you know, just out of college kid, like skeptical of for-profit companies, but I think.

I was really pleasantly surprised the amount people care. And it's like, people really give a shit about the mission and are like, that's why they're there. And so I think to the question of sort of what was that experience like, I think that was my first standout memory. I think as it relates to more of my contemporary experience, it's a similar theme and thread, which is the idea that the people in the company truly embody all three parts. I think you see a lot of for-profit entities where...

either their social mission or their corporate social responsibility is sort of separated from the rest of the day-to-day working teams or organization. And that couldn't be further from the truth at Ben and Jerry's, right? Everybody wants a piece of the social mission. In fact, it's the opposite where you kind of have to say, hey, this stuff happens over here. This other work happens over there.

Neil Callanan 05:28

It's the opposite where you kind of have to say, hey, this stuff happened over here and this other word happened over here. Yeah. So in that vein, how do you guys think about success, right? Like when you're sitting down for your digital team meetings or you're hanging out with the executive team.

What does success look like and how do you think about that at a high level?

Jay Tandan 05:53

for us success is did we win or lose? And when I say we, I mean, what are the issues and causes that we're looking to champion and support? And are we making progress on those things at the end of the day? And I think that is emblematic of the fact that this is for us, our social mission is not just a thing that we do to make people like us. It's a thing that we do to drive progressive social change in the world. And so I guess when we sit down and when we think about measuring impact,

Neil Callanan 05:58

you

Jay Tandan 06:24

we hold ourselves to a really high standard, not just because that's what we are setting out to do, but also because as a for-profit company, we want to hold ourselves to a really high standard of, are we really delivering or are we greenwashing or are we, right? Like, are we just gonna appear to be doing this because it could benefit us? And I think that has been one of the things that's really kept us honest and made us so laser focused on measuring impact and ensuring that every dollar we put into

issue advocacy is working as hard as possible.

Neil Callanan 07:16

Wait so it's coming my

Jay Tandan 07:16

I can hear it it's slightly annoying.

Neil Callanan 07:33

nothing. But let me see here. So my speaker and my headset are both set to my headset. So that shouldn't be that right. I mean, I can turn on the echo canceling, but didn't we determine that's less good to

Jay Tandan 07:35

Maybe it's me.

Jay Tandan 07:53

Mm.

Jay Tandan 07:57

L

Neil Callanan 07:57

Let me see here.

Neil Callanan 08:05

You

Jay Tandan 08:06

see no styrofoam for us, so that's a win.

yeah, fair.

Jay Tandan 08:15

There you go. Home of Jersey Mikes.

Neil Callanan 08:20

Alright, let me turn this on for a sec. wait, no. It says I can't because my headset is plugged in. So yes, it won't even let me turn it on. I can turn down my output volume a little bit, Like my mic level maybe. Does that maybe work better?

Jay Tandan 08:31

Hmm.

Jay Tandan 08:40

I'm just gonna start talking to see if, yeah, I can still hear it personally.

Yeah.

Neil Callanan 08:48

It's weird, because I have my fucking headset on. Let me turn on...

volume.

Neil Callanan 09:01

So, but why is...

I can't even like adjust my volume, that's my iMac speaker, hold on a sec. Let me try something here.

Neil Callanan 09:15

sorry, I say something.

Jay Tandan 09:21

Thanks

Neil Callanan 09:23

So it's weird.

Jay Tandan 09:29

yes.

Neil Callanan 09:30

It's ridiculous.

Jay Tandan 09:31

That seems ridiculous that that even was a thing.

Jay Tandan 09:38

Seriously.

Jay Tandan 09:51

yes, guys.

Yeah. Yeah, we were all black, all black, Abran.

Neil Callanan 10:15

Yeah, I can't really even adjust anything when we're in it. So I feel like it's like, because we're in it, that's why it's not letting me change anything. But I also like literally can't change my volume on this. I don't know what the thing is. Like my iMac volume is on zero right now.

Neil Callanan 10:34

Let me try this. All right, let's try that. Can you, is that any better?

Jay Tandan 10:39

let me just talk for a little bit and see. Yeah, I mean, it might be, I don't necessarily hear it anymore. Yeah, it's gone.

Jay Tandan 10:53

okay.

Jay Tandan 10:59

I see, okay.

Neil Callanan 11:01

All right, I think we're good, right?

Jay Tandan 11:03

Cool, and I think I did a decent job answering those questions, but I was also slightly distracted by the feedback, so if it was fine, then okay. Yeah.

Jay Tandan 11:18

Hey, I'd fight through but no, I probably wouldn't mention it if it didn't go away. The middle of an answer.

Neil Callanan 11:25

Thanks,

Jay Tandan 11:26

All right, thanks.

Neil Callanan 11:28

All right. So we were, when you talk about sort of greenwashing and, you know, the idea of how to sort of check your own, intention and the things that you guys are doing, what, what mechanisms do you guys use to just sort of ensure you're prevented from your own virtue of signaling and how do you guys check each other on making sure that the things you put out are in line? there, is there, you know,

specific things that you try to do or try not to do that kind of keep you in on the right path there.

Jay Tandan 12:06

Yeah, the first sort of asterisk I put on all of this before digging into maybe some more of the sort of measurement side is we align everything that we're doing with movement leaders and partners who know more about a lot of the issues that we're working on than we do. And so we don't claim to be the experts, but we always want to be aligned with and supporting the experts and making sure that strategically what they want to do is what we go out and do. And so the reason that matters is because there can be

a variety of different objectives when doing communications. Sometimes you have goals that are just purely based on, you know, taking the recent example of the endangerment finding, which was kind of rolled back by the EPA. The endangerment finding was a cornerstone regulation that allowed the EPA to regulate carbon emissions. We just needed people to know about that. And so a post where you just need to get the word out and create some buzz, I mean, that piece of content is going to look really different than

something where, hey, maybe in a month's time there will be a coordinated action where progressive climate groups say we need to put pressure on X or Y and now it's gonna be focused on an action. And so the type of content we do to drive people down the kind of funnel to take an action, again, is gonna look very different than just an awareness play. Or if we're trying to get somebody to really understand or be educated on the inner workings of the EPA and their policies, I don't know if we would go that heady with it, but.

that would be a different piece of content and that would look different. I movement aligned and then based on what is our specific objective, what are we trying to get people to do? And then there are gonna be different signals and data signals that we'll get back in that journey that again, hold us accountable to driving the right types of impact, but also help us optimize and improve that over time.

Neil Callanan 13:55

So I guess one of the things I didn't hear you reference was how that ties to posts about ice cream. And so how do you guys think about the two existing together? If you're choosing an objective for your values posts, does that live in a different world from your ice cream forward content, your branded content? How do they play together?

Jay Tandan 14:21

I think it's a symbiotic relationship and that's what makes the messages that we push as Ben and Jerry so special is that we can talk to people in a lot of different ways, but at the end of the day, marketing a product versus marketing an idea are essentially the same things. It's like, do we want you to just sort of know about it? Do we want you to immerse yourselves more deeply and be more deeply kind of educated about it? Or do we want you to do a thing, like buy a thing or take an action? And so...

this sort of idea of like driving awareness, driving education or driving conversion apply to both our, you know, our product stuff as much as our value stuff. And interestingly, I think a lot of the rigor and acumen at the company, particularly on like performance marketing actually started from our advocacy work because we're not a D to C brand, right? We don't have, you know, online sales at any significant scale through owned properties. And so,

we actually like learn a lot from what we're testing and trying in the advocacy world and actually referring that back to how we do product marketing. which I think is a cool cool experience. So yeah, they're very much hand in hand. And I think we've even seen instances where because we have the platform that we have as it relates to our advocacy and our values, we get a lot of traction on social for that. And we're doing it in meaningful ways that again, are movement aligned and very thoughtful.

But we've actually seen that they actually can help. It actually floats the product marketing sometimes at times too. So we can see instances where if a product, a piece of product communications comes after maybe a high visibility advocacy moment where we're driving action on a policy or a legislation, a piece of legislation, the posts that we do after that, even if they're ice cream, can sometimes actually do better, which is.

a very interesting revelation and honestly certainly helps us message up through the organization to say, look, not only is the work that we're doing on advocacy really moving the needle and measurable and helping find policy wins or what have you, it's good for business. And I think oftentimes people find themselves in a defensive position with this type of work within the for-profit space where you're sort of just defending this stuff to exist at all, this idea of

Jay Tandan 16:45

purpose or, you know, as we say, you know, progressive advocacy. Whereas for us, it's even the opposite. We're on the offensive. We're like, this is this is good for business and more people should be doing that. And so, again, yeah, the product stuff and the ice cream stuff mixed with the advocacy really works. you know, Ben's favorite phrase is he always says the spoonful of sugar. And so, you know, it's almost like the inverse now where it's like the advocacy helps the ice cream go down. I don't know.

Neil Callanan 17:11

Yeah. So when you guys are like, it sounds like you have a pretty sophisticated infrastructure and ecosystem of just like culture of measurement, right? I guess my question is kind of a little bit high level, which is I think a lot of brands struggle with measurement. And the assumption is often that the struggle on the measurement side is within the kind of the nuts and bolts, the data that

tracking the blocking and tackling of actually doing it. But it sounds to me like you guys are saying that some of it's cultural, like building a culture of performance marketers, like you said. Help me understand for you guys, where does the challenge lie? What makes it hard? Obviously, you guys are committed to measuring impact, both on the value side and on selling ice cream. Is it the?

Jay Tandan 18:08

Mm-hmm.

Neil Callanan 18:09

Is the data, hard part? is the culture, the hard part? is the buy-in the hard part? where, where, where do you rank the challenges that go into something like that?

Jay Tandan 18:19

I think the culture piece is there, right? The anecdote I mentioned as it relates to people in the organization really believing in this stuff, that that is there, that foundation is firm, people want to kind of do the right thing, so to speak. For us, it's at least historically was a bit of signal versus noise. so what within the vast kind of array of data that exists in the digital space, how do you make sense of it? And so

We've put a lot of time in, you know, in partnership with LooseGrip to, yeah, finding the signal within the noise, because there are so many data points you could look at. There are, you know, the massive vanity metrics that you could look at, which really are oftentimes red herrings and really focusing on moving the needle and driving the impact. you know, I'll give an example where there have been instances where we've sort of co-opted a trend on social, like TikTok trend.

call it, and sort of infused our brand voice into it, which means infusing ice cream and sometimes infusing messages around our values. Those perform really well. Those are oftentimes just that they perform, they're almost performative. And so, again, with us being wanting to be really clear around what does perform well mean in what context, something just getting a lot of video views doesn't necessarily add up to

progress on the issues that we want to see progress on. And so if we were just to look at video views, we'd say, those kind of trendy videos, like those do great. And like, let's just do those all memes all the time. And that's not our job. Our job is to move the needle on the social justice issues that we're working on in concert with our partners. And so that has been the challenge. But I think it's one that we've stepped into and made some sense of in a way that we've been able to refine the kind of model over time. And I think

Neil Callanan 19:55

Yeah, just do more memes. All memes all the time.

Jay Tandan 20:16

Ben and Jerry's Across the Globe last year drove over 200,000 policy actions through engaging our fans on these topics. think that's really awesome and quantifiable.

Neil Callanan 20:28

So I'm interested in you guys clearly look at all this stuff with a lot of intention and you're setting these objectives.

What's the biggest challenge when you're trying to sort of bring the adoption of this kind of thing, right? So I guess what I'm asking is more of like, how do you operationalize this? You guys obviously have different languages and different teams, and there's probably a hundred agencies that you work with on different projects and different things. how do you, it's one thing to say as our team of five marketers on some startup D2C brand, we have this specific way we do things and everybody can kind of inherently know it.

I guess when you guys get to the scale that you guys are at, how do you socialize or operationalize this like ethos of even like intention and deciding to look and see what things perform? Like that's an assumption. think we find a lot of brands just like, it's an assumption that it seems so obvious, like, of course you would measure what works the best. it actually doesn't always work like that. Right. So how do you guys think about making that real?

Jay Tandan 21:21

So.

Jay Tandan 21:27

Thanks.

Neil Callanan 21:43

Besides just you, the people who kind of are leading that, who, how do you get the people to buy in on your teams or agencies or your partners in a way that is sustainable?

Jay Tandan 21:43

Thank you.

Jay Tandan 21:54

That's a great question because I've been fortunate that I think, at least for the past many years, we've been in an environment internally and with lot of our core agency partners where that's table stakes. I think taking a simple example of trying to explain to or partner with, because sometimes they totally get it, but an activism manager. So we have activism managers in six countries, our six biggest kind of countries that we're in.

trying to be like, here's why UTM tags are really important, right? And it's just like, it's this string of random characters and nobody knows what it means. That's tough, but I think you tell the story, right? If you show a side by side of, here's what we can see from insights on a post performance without those things versus here's what we can see with those things. You go from, here's the one line explainer of it reached this many people to, I could tell you a whole story basically about what happened all because of those pieces of data. So I think as much as data is perceived by some as,

It's the fertile ground from which you can tell stories and kind of help people make sense of the world. And so I think that's the kind of path that we have taken. I know that's something that LooseGrip embodies as well, that I think is really powerful.

Neil Callanan 23:06

Yeah, it seems like with you guys.

There's some level of consistency, too. It's like repetition of the message doesn't change that much over time. You guys might jump onto different styles and formats and be changing things at the micro level. But my sense is, especially talking with folks on your team, like the core message of your purpose doesn't change that much. And how you're going to think about measuring that remains pretty consistent.

Jay Tandan 23:38

Yeah, I think it's funny. We'll give an example of Cherry Garcia through the ages, right? I can show you a Facebook post from 2009 of Cherry Garcia, and then I can show you a TikTok we did last week and then the eight iterations of social in between, right? Like here's the tweet version, here's the Instagram version, here was the Snapchat version. And yeah, the message does remain the same, but the way it shows up is how we evolve ourselves while remaining true to the brand, right? It's still Cherry Garcia.

or it's still fish food, right? That are these like cultural things that have relevance to people. But we then have to translate the brand.

Neil Callanan 24:15

This is the The millennial slash Gen Z version of people being like, there was newspaper ads, and then there was radio, and then we had television. It's that same thing, but you have a core web-based infrastructure 15 years ago, and the social channels have changed. But the way you guys approach it seems to be pretty consistent.

Jay Tandan 24:37

Yeah. Yeah. And I think over my 16 years at the company, not all of that time had been in marketing, but I think we've really had the opportunity to take an incredibly powerful brand and translate it for the digital era. Because, you know, even talking with the co-founders, they'll be like, we can't even believe the scale at which we're able to have impact for the social mission through digital. And that's been a really nice experience to have, but it has required, how do you stay true to who you are while social environments and social norms are changing all around you?

Neil Callanan 24:58

Yeah.

Jay Tandan 25:07

Again, you have to kind of have marketeers who believe in brand stewardship and believe in what the brand's about, which we're fortunate to have a really powerful kind of external sort of embodiment of the brand. But then you need to look at the data of what's working. So how do you like marry up the, almost the art and the science, I guess.

Neil Callanan 25:27

So when you guys are

Neil Callanan 25:32

measuring for the sake of driving change, a decision-making a action to do something, to change or inform you or your teams or your agency's behaviors. Give me a feel on what's thing that you measure that you feel like is really informative or directionally influential as you guys think about decisions that you're going to make about what your next

content's going to look like, or web project's going to be, or platform you're going to try, or whatever. Give me an example of a metric you're just psyched to look at that when it comes up on that next report. What's the thing, the one that you're like, that one always makes me feel like I'm smarter, or I know something more than knew before.

Jay Tandan 26:06

Mm-hmm.

Jay Tandan 26:20

Yeah, mean, one that has a good wow factor that I think a lot of people in digital marketing understand is click through rate for email versus all social, right? Everybody wants to ooh and ahh over the millions of people reach, but it's like, well, if you were trying to get people to the site to do something, wow, email actually was 10 times better than everything else. I think that that's one that we try and keep an eye on to keep everybody in check because it's easy to be in the like social black hole. But like there are other ones that are

more creative that we've used over time, like instead of just looking at time on site, look at engaged time on site, right? Are you actively scrolling or people actively scrolling through and consuming the content on site, meaning they're actually reading it? Or did they just leave a tab open and it sat there and that inflates your time on site number? And so I think you have to even kind of go deeper than maybe some of the out of the box metrics and look a little deeper around true engagement. And I think video views versus

time spent viewing is a good example of that as well. So particularly with the native analytics and TikTok, it's like video views, sure, that's the number that, you know, as the publisher, you can see right there on the thumbnail before you even click into your analytics, you can see that. But then when you actually jump in and get a little deeper and you start to look at retention, that can be the more telling stuff. And so I always get excited to look at those more so than what I see day to day just flipping through the app, you know.

kind of normally. you got to peel a layer deeper. And I think when you do is, but that's how you find the real story.

Neil Callanan 27:54

Yeah, I mean, we see a lot where it's really hard to not just get so excited about these giant TikTok numbers, especially all these algorithmic platforms. And then sometimes you'll go and you're like, watch time was 1 and 1/4 seconds, which was just past our title's card of the whatever the thing was that you're trying to get across. think it can be kind of a, it's hard, right? It's a hard thing to not look for the best information, best metric, and then turn that into the

to the narrative of your story, right?

Jay Tandan 28:26

Yeah, and I mean, we'll take the big numbers home to the bank all the time too. But that's not what we're going to optimize performance based on. We'll love to showcase total reach for the year or something and just get a big number and everybody can feel good about that. And pats on the back happen or whatever. But really we know, we all know as a culture within the team, that's not how we optimize. That's not how we get better. That's how we can say, did pretty good overall, but we really want to dig deeper as it relates to how to innovate.

When a new platform presents itself in the way that TikTok did, but you know, the long line of things before that, Snapchat before that, Instagram before that, you really do have to innovate what you're doing and what worked the prior year won't work the next year. And I think if you're just chasing the big numbers, you're gonna miss the meat of what's happening. So that's the challenge is like staying future thinking.

Neil Callanan 29:23

Yeah, it's hard to not look at that specific number set and go, man, that number's so big. I want to talk about that big number. my sense is, for you guys, when you're looking for ways to learn and make decisions, it's not always from the post that has the biggest numbers. I guess the challenge is, when you are so likely to have virality and algorithmic success like you guys are,

can be a little bit of a black box as to what success is if it's all just about the big number, Because like, we've got a quadrillion views because TikTok happened to like us on that one day or whatever, right? And is American TikTok's algorithm different now or whatever, right? There's like a lot of unknowns. But it feels like you guys are able to try to steer away from that a little bit, at least to go, yeah, but what can we know from

that data? or better data that will help us inform how to do better, more of the stuff that works and less of the stuff that doesn't work?

Jay Tandan 30:27

Yeah, I mean, I think that's true. And I think we'll still look at the trend line on something like, like, I'd rather know, are the number of videos that we're doing that are getting X amount of whatever the target metric is, are those growing over time versus, hey, we had two videos that reached 15 million people, right? Like one of those shows steady growth, the other is, yeah, we happened to hit the trending audio just right. And whatever, for some reason or another, this worked and we basically, it's impossible to tell why.

Cause like those kinds of things like, I don't know what to do with that as a, you know, as a communications person or a marketer or what have you. Whereas, hey, we're slowly testing and iterating and finding things that work and taking up over time. That's, that brings me more satisfaction. And I think that shows more sustainability over time for, for the brand and for the message. And at the end of the day, for the impact we're able to have through our advocacy work.

Neil Callanan 31:20

Yeah. So a while ago, you were talking about sort of sequential posts from, you know, a values post followed by maybe a totally unrelated post. Give me a little bit more detail about why you guys even thought to go down that route. Like, I feel like that's a pretty clever question to even ask yourself, sorry, your partners, whoever. How are you guys trying to...

I think what happens, like you said, is a lot of brands, especially who are activism values or sustainability forward, they kind of treat everything in these silos. And it sounds like you guys are intentionally trying to like remove those silos all the time, including understanding how one impacts the other.

what lead led you down the path to try to even figure that problem out? Because I feel like it's pretty unique in terms of an approach.

Jay Tandan 32:14

The highest level, we're Ben and Jerry's and we're multifaceted. And you can't pull apart the this versus that it's just like this is who Ben and Jerry's is as a company.

Neil Callanan 32:23

Yeah, there's not like a Ben and Jerry's ice cream Facebook page and I've been in Jerry's values Facebook page, right? They're there.

Jay Tandan 32:26

Yeah. And we've talked about that. Hey, should we have a... And we're always like, no, that's not the point, right? We're here to do both. that's what makes it great. That's what makes it great to work for Ben & Jerry's. But as far as that idea of like, if you post one thing first around our values and then you post something about a product after and maybe there's a halo effect toward the product piece, just through dumb luck, honestly. Like we didn't...

have that hunch necessarily, but I think people now know, people who are like working in the social spaces, it's like, if you have something perform really well, the next thing you post is probably gonna do a little better. And so we've noticed that on balance, the stuff we post about our advocacy is more potent than our product stuff. That's not always the rule, but on balance over the course of a year when you look at social performance. it's only expected that, you know, when we post stuff after a high visibility moment that

the algorithm's gonna juice that a little bit. And so we've tested with different, both the approach of unintentionally posting a product thing after an advocacy thing, or if we had an advocacy thing that got a lot of traction, all right, what's the next thing we want them to know about that issue? We'll post that organically next, even though it's not gonna perfectly reach the same group of people, we know algorithmically that will have legs. And so it can also help us sort of double down on our advocacy initiatives as well.

Neil Callanan 33:55

So I guess my question that falls into that is, all right, so if your values content, if your activism content, if if it generally performs better than your flavors content or better in whatever you just decide to determine the success is going to be, whether that's just the peer reach or the impact of the actions taken, how do you guys think about maintaining a balance and not, you know, I think there's a tendency for

brands when they see success, it's really hard to guard against just like, okay, well, let's just do that every time all the time, just like that. Cause that thing worked better. Let's do more of that, more of that, more of that. And a lot of ways it sounds like you guys have the opposite problem that most might expect, which is like, you have a big appetite for values content for activism content, for social content. But how do you make sure there's still the right mix of like, some people just want to know about the ice cream, right? And some people just want to like be fans of good ice cream.

And how do you make sure you can still speak to them and keep a cadence that feels balanced in some way?

Jay Tandan 34:53

pizza.

Jay Tandan 34:59

Yeah, we have essentially a loose split between our sort of like producty fun, you know, General Ben and Jerry's versus our advocacy stuff. And so we try and hit that sort of percentage split. It's, you know, something like one third of what we do is our advocacy and the other two thirds is not, is not the advocacy stuff.

But I think from a capacity, it's a lot more work to do the advocacy side of things. And so we're certainly putting in lot of effort there. think there have been times where, know, Ben & Jerry's has been owned by a parent company since 2001. And so there have been times where throughout the history of the company, there's been pressure to like, oh, people really like that, ramp it up, you know, do more of that. Because they're like, it's good for business. And I think what we always have to keep people in check is we don't do it because of that.

Neil Callanan 35:44

Yeah.

Jay Tandan 35:51

like sure there may be some benefits that the business gets, but we do it because we want to be strategically aligned with what people in these different social justice movements are doing and what they want us to do, what's helpful. And you can't manufacture that. You can't manufacture that authenticity. You can't manufacture it being really credible work. so, yeah, there would be, depending on your seat in the organization, there may be a perspective of, you know, how do you really ramp that up and have that be 70 % of what we're doing if that's

doing so well or whatever. And we always have to be like, no, that's the reason it's so potent is because it's really thoughtful. And, you know, we were blessed. We have activism managers who all of them come out of the nonprofit world and they have partnerships with different NGOs and movement groups. And it's all really informed by what's needed to advance these issues, not, hey, that worked on social, let's do more of it. And so I think that's a constant battle as somebody who's both

for myself, like heavily engaged and passionate about the advocacy side, but also part of the marketing organization. Cause those can be, you know, competing at times.

Neil Callanan 37:00

And so when those are, I guess one of the questions I have is when you have these disparate stakeholders, right. And I assume it's probably not as clean as I'm making it sound, but like, you know, you, if you hire activism managers who have previously worked at NGOs, right. That's pretty obvious what they're going to be passionate about and what they're going to be advocating for within the company and what they want you to do more of and where they want you to put their energy. And on the other side, you have folks who are maybe brand marketers or

flavor advocates, flavor gurus, whatever you guys want to call them. You have people who are really excited about the product and the quality of the product and the new releases and the kind of things, right? How do you make sure those groups can learn from each other in terms of performance and can kind of see that like, you're putting the same, I don't know, measurement ethos to both evenly. Cause I feel like in a lot of ways,

You guys are saying, we were going to measure this justice as thoroughly as we measure how many pints got sold related to this promotion or whatever. And in a lot of ways, I feel like the brand brands who are really active in the social space, oftentimes sort of. They're almost like it's like a.

It's almost too low brow to think about measuring the success, right? Like it's sort of like, no, no, no, we're changing the world. So how could we measure that? Right. But it seems like you guys are really committed to doing both, but I got to assume that getting people on the same page about.

measurement is a challenge. how do you, it's a poorly worded, long-winded question, but how do you think about sort of building alignment between teams who maybe have pretty disparate passions and objectives and goals for what their role is?

Jay Tandan 38:52

think one thing we've always been certain to do is to the best of our ability, we don't separate out the content development process for ice cream stuff over here with this set of people and advocacy stuff over here with that set of people. It's one process. The way we measure it the same is the same. The cadence on which we report out on it is the same. And so everybody's along for the same ride. And I think that is really important because sometimes there can be the perception that there would be tension between

marketers and the advocacy team. But I think the beauty of and Jerry's and coming back to the culture of Ben and Jerry's is everybody is super invested. And so I think that is super important to say this is one process, one Ben and Jerry's process. And sometimes it may lean heavily this way, the pendulum may swing that way, but we're all collectively pushing the Ben and Jerry's experience, not a product experience or a advocacy experience. And I think there's also very interesting learnings. And I started to allude to this

with the performance marketing stuff earlier, like there are learnings that come out of the rigor that we apply to the advocacy side where it is more end-to-end measurable, all like in digital environments, that the product side we just don't have, right? A lot of Ben & Jerry's is still sold in a grocery store and it's not online and we can't track that. And so the learnings, like we did a lot of work in St. Louis where there was this jail, the jail mostly held people.

pre-trial, so they hadn't been convicted of anything, they just couldn't post bail. So they were essentially like in jail because they didn't have money to pay bail. So 90 % of the people there, was disproportionately people of color. so we did a, partnered with a group called ArchCity Defenders and we were campaigning there and we were campaigning on essentially pressuring the board of aldermen there in St. Louis to think differently about their budgets, right? They spend a lot of money on this jail, not so much on other services.

we ended up doing a lot of work around performance marketing, creative variations, copy optimization, audience optimization, that frankly was the degree of rigor that could then be taken to the product side. so I think, and I'm sure there are tons of examples that go vice versa, where we have learnings on the product side that actually help the advocacy side too. And so I think the narrative to the collective Ben and Jerry's group is these things are actually stronger together.

Jay Tandan 41:20

and they can inform each other in really different ways. And I think people have kind of signed up for that and they see that value too, which is awesome.

Neil Callanan 41:28

Yeah, yeah, it's seemingly pretty symbiotic in the way that you guys think about it. Okay, I'm going to hit you with some quick fires. Number one, what is one thing you wish you could measure that is likely not measurable?

Jay Tandan 41:52

See, this is why I'm a digital guy. I'm like, everything's pretty measurable. But I don't know. mean, one of the things that we don't really know from a, this is like super granular, but you're asking, carousel swipes. I wish there was more information about carousel swipes because it's really hard to know. It's a great content type.

Neil Callanan 41:54

Hahaha!

Jay Tandan 42:20

But think that we've often had questions of like, how long, how do you know what's working the best? Do people trudge through and they're reading stuff because they kind of feel like they just want to get to the end or should it be shorter? So that's like a super granular one, but would be like really valuable, right? Instead of us pouring over, you know, eight tiles of carousels and all the copy and all those sites that we need to source when we have statistics in there and all that stuff, like a lot of work goes into that. And if that can be, you know, three swipes, not eight.

That would be useful and something we've sort of like grappled with over time because sometimes in the advocacy world you want to be verbose, a little verbose to a detriment. I think that to a detriment sometimes.

Neil Callanan 43:01

Yeah, what you guys really want to find out is people want 30 slide carousels and they would like to hear all the things you have to say. Hear that Instagram, give us some metrics, man. What brand or movement do you look up to kind of in this ethos of the space that how you think about Ben & Jerry's or organizations that you're excited about? Who do you guys kind of look up to when you're thinking about this blend of activism and purpose and profit?

Jay Tandan 43:11

Yeah

Jay Tandan 43:34

I mean, there aren't a ton of brands that really fully embrace issue advocacy in the same way, but I think the two that stand out to me are Patagonia. I think they, yeah, yeah, who are they? Fully live their values, very thoughtful, and do some degree of advocacy. And the other would be Lush Cosmetics.

Neil Callanan 43:47

Never heard of them.

Jay Tandan 44:02

also very progressive, have a lot of great advocacy campaigns in the kind of true sense of the word. But to be honest, I actually think the, if I'm thinking about what inspires me, like those are companies that kind of are at this intersection of like, you know, a triple bottom line or whatever you want call it call it. It's some of these local organizers, like the St. Louis example that I gave, like this woman in Naz who was incarcerated in that jail and then like,

came out the other side and was like, I'm gonna just go out and get after it and like get this done. And like that jail has been closed and demolished. And those people who just have the grit, like we talk about grit a lot of just like, you just got to crank through or like when stuff happens in the world around us, we have all these marketing plans and annual plans and all this stuff. And sometimes you just need to like put the pen to paper. What do we need to do? What do we need to say? And how to just get after it. And I think local organizers and local groups are

strapped for resources often and really have to just have the like gritty attitude and they do and I think I've talked with people other people within Ben and Jerry's of like when you get somebody kind of has the grit it's like yeah all right you know and

Neil Callanan 45:16

That leads into my next question, is when you are, you these jobs are hard, right? Your job is hard. My job is hard. Everybody's job is hard, right? And so the question I like to hear on how do you approach like, man, you're on month three without a real break and there's been lots of issues that are seemingly incredibly pressing at any given time and launches and all the things. Like, how do you go about just filling your tank up to like keep that grit

front and center? keep the energy levels up. What works for you in terms of building that as a resource.

Jay Tandan 45:52

This is a personal answer. The nice thing at Ben and Jerry's is like, well, there's always the ice cream stuff. That's light and whatever. No, I do. like I literally do the polar opposite thing of my day to day job. If my day to day job is what it is, which is like professional emailer sitting at a computer all day. I'm a rock climber. So I like go out into the woods by myself. I'm like sitting there with a rock and like some chalk on my hands. And I'm just like pulling really hard on.

Neil Callanan 45:55

That's what we're here for, personal answers.

Neil Callanan 46:02

Hahaha.

Jay Tandan 46:21

on these rocks and like for no purpose other than to get to the top, which gets me nothing in life really. But it's just the polar opposite of the spectrum. It's very tranquil and very physical. And I don't know, that kind of helped me balance out living in the digital world and the data and all that stuff. And so it's like a nice, yeah, balancing effect, I guess. Yeah.

Neil Callanan 46:41

Yeah. Yeah. The literal opposite of sending an email in some way. which Which is just awesome. when you, are talking with other folks, in, your space or otherwise, doesn't even necessarily have to be tied to marketing. what podcasts do you recommend to most others? Like which one are you talking about to people and you're, are you annoying your wife with or whatever? Like, listen to this thing I heard. Like, is there a, a series or episode or a style that you're often recommending to others?

Jay Tandan 47:10

I mean, I'm in on the news stuff, because for all the aforementioned reasons around advocacy and all of that, I'm passionate about it. And so I'm trying to stay up on the latest. So any of the likely suspect daily news stuff is good for me.

Neil Callanan 47:26

And I'd remiss if I didn't ask.

Do you think a year from now or two years from now, we'll be talking more about AI or less about AI when it comes to this space?

Jay Tandan 47:44

more for sure. I can expand on that but this is rapid fire so I'll leave it at that.

Neil Callanan 47:49

Yeah, we'll save that for the AI podcast. All right, final question, but maybe the most important. If I was coming to Vermont, where would you send me or the listeners to get a really good sandwich?

Jay Tandan 47:53

Yeah

Jay Tandan 48:07

Sandwich. That'd be really important. Well, actually, I have a place that works for breakfast or lunch.

Neil Callanan 48:13

That's even better.

Jay Tandan 48:14

Henry Street Deli in Burlington. you have. I mean, the breakfast sandwiches are amazing. I think that's the superior option there, honestly, but also like massive sandwich, pretty cheap if you want like a, you more like a lunchy sandwich. You know, just a little corner store. It's like in the heart of like college downtown. So it's like got that kind of vibe to it, a little rough around the edges, but incredible.

Neil Callanan 48:17

I've been. Yeah.

I've only had the breakfast sandwich, so I can't,

Jay Tandan 48:44

Sandwiches, for sure.

Neil Callanan 48:45

And what's your go-to order if you're a lunch sandwich?

Jay Tandan 48:49

I mean, I'm probably going like, oh, a lunch sandwich?

Breakfast sandwich is definitely like bacon, I can cheese kind of thing, but I don't know. I'm like a classic, just like turkey provolone or turkey cheddar, you know, something like simple like that. I like a basic sandwich. No oil. I had nothing against the Italian, you know, sandwich fans out there, but like the oil thing has just never done it for me.

Neil Callanan 49:12

It does it for me, but I respect your right to your own opinion, even if it's wrong.

Jay Tandan 49:14

I

Well, I don't know how Henry Street's Italian is, but I'm sure it's good.

Neil Callanan 49:22

Awesome. Well, Jay, this has been super helpful. I'm so excited to hear about everything you guys have going on and sounds like you guys are really living it out, which is, which is awesome. And, uh, it's exciting to sit on the outside and sort of see you guys really invest into both from the flavors performance and the, uh, and the values performance. It's a, it's pretty clear you guys live and breathe it, which is, uh, not always the case. So thank you so much for joining us and giving us a little bit of time.

Jay Tandan 49:52

Thanks for having me.

Neil Callanan 49:53

We will throw a couple links in the show notes to the organizations that Jay mentioned. And if you want to follow Jay, where would they find you?

Jay Tandan 50:03

man, LinkedIn, guess. Well, here's my theory. Here's my theory. As somebody who's in social for a living, I actually try and spend less time on my own social because it clouds my understanding of the reality. And so I actually try and stick to looking at, you know, the numbers for our own world and less my own. You don't want to be the N of one guy, you know, like, yeah.

Neil Callanan 50:05

on a rock in the woods.

Neil Callanan 50:31

That's true. Yeah, I saw this thing and it did really good on my personal page. So we should apply that to the brand. Well, you can find more about Ben and Jerry's on their social channels. Jay and I both would love you to subscribe to their email because that's where you get the good stuff and that's what performs best, as he said. And we'll drop some links in the notes. Thanks again, man. Appreciate you.

Jay Tandan 50:37

Exactly, that's trouble.

Jay Tandan 50:52

Thank you. See you.

Get your sandwich

Picked by Jay Tandan

Bacon, egg and cheese breakfast sandwich

Henry Street Deli

11 Henry Street, Old North End, Burlington, VT

For lunch: turkey with provolone or cheddar, no oil.