Breaking the Cocoa Mold with Belinda Borck (Tony’s Chocolonely) artwork

Breaking the Cocoa Mold How Tony's Chocolonely Turns Supply Chain KPIs Into Human Stories

Belinda Borck, Global External Affairs and Reporting Lead, Tony’s Chocolonely

· 38 min

Summary

Belinda Borck, Global External Affairs and Reporting Lead at Tony's Chocolonely and Tony's Open Chain, explained how Tony's measures its fight against exploitation in cocoa and publishes the hardest findings in an independently assured annual impact report.

Tony's reported finding 1,702 cases of child labor in its supply chain and treated the count as a good sign that its monitoring systems were working.

Tony's case shows that publishing the toughest number can be the strongest proof that the work is real.

Watch the episode

Questions answered

Should a brand publish the bad news in its impact data?

Publishing bad news shows the monitoring works, said Belinda Borck, Global External Affairs and Reporting Lead at Tony's Chocolonely. Tony's treated its report of 1,702 cases of child labor in its supply chain as a good sign, because it meant its monitoring systems were working. A big UK newspaper then put the story on its Easter cover with a headline saying an ethical chocolate brand had found child labor in its supply chain, and used the rounded figure of 1,700 in the text. The rounding upset Borck most, because the paper did not use the actual numbers. The sustainability reporting and marketing teams sat together and were fully prepared to answer that Tony's finds child labor, and this is what it does about it. Tony's came away seeing radical transparency as an engine for its story and impact model.

Openness is part of Tony's cycle of knowing about an issue, acting on it and spreading the approach to others, even to other industries such as coffee. If no one talks about a problem, there is no awareness, no one asks questions, and no one feels obliged to act. The Tony's Open Chain impact report tracks child labor, the lack of a living income and deforestation as the main issues in cocoa, and reports both the child labor cases found and the progress on remediating them.

Is supply chain traceability enough to prove impact?

Knowing where cocoa comes from only shows whether there are issues, so Tony's Chocolonely pairs traceability with four more sourcing principles that act on what it finds. Tony's started traceability in 2012, when it was told a segregated, traceable cocoa flow could not be done for the industry, and EU deforestation regulation now requires plot tracking for cocoa entering the EU. The other principles are paying a higher price that enables a living income, working through strong cooperatives with boots on the ground, improving quality and productivity while keeping farms out of protected areas, and committing to at least five years with each cooperative.

The long-term commitment is the crux of the model, because none of these changes happen overnight or in a single season. Tony's works with over 40,000 farmers, too many for one-on-one relationships, which is why it works through cooperatives. The model keeps adjusting as the company learns. When cooperatives said they wanted to pay farmers more but also needed money to run their systems as businesses, Tony's started paying a cooperative management fee on top of the living income reference price. It learns at least one lesson like that every year.

How do you measure awareness of the issues a brand campaigns on?

A change in public discourse is the more telling signal, in Belinda's view, though Tony's Chocolonely also tracks brand and issue awareness KPIs in its reporting, backed by focus groups and stakeholder engagement. In 2012 Tony's was told traceability was impossible, and EU regulation now requires it. A living income for cocoa farmers is now widely discussed. Raising awareness is the first of Tony's three pillars, followed by leading by example and inspiring others to act. Tony's also watches the questions it starts getting and how it is challenged, which showed the team it had talked more about human rights than about the environment and led it to communicate the full range of issues it works on.

How do you make impact data relatable to a wide audience?

Start from experiences people share, such as parents everywhere wanting the best for their children. Tony's talks about children's rights and going to school rather than a child labor narrative, and about a child's right to play rather than human rights due diligence. Belinda leads the team that produces the Tony's Open Chain impact report. Its KPIs are dry on their own, so the report also explains what sits behind the count of remediated cases: one child may need a birth certificate to be registered for school, while a village where 15 children are out of school might need a community school or a school canteen.

The latest report added day-in-the-life stories, including a cooperative president and a community facilitator, one of the cooperative employees who visit every household to talk about child labor and agree on remediation. Tony's does not hunt for stories; long-term relationships through its teams in Ghana and Côte d'Ivoire show who wants to be platformed. Tony's playful brand is an intentional way to make a serious story accessible, because detailed sustainability language would lose most people.

How do you make an impact report credible?

Every KPI in the Tony's Open Chain impact report carries third-party limited assurance, and limited text assurance means selected claims must be proven separately, much like footnoting a university essay. Each KPI is owned by a specialist, such as a traceability or forest specialist, and documented in KPI manuals. The report follows the cocoa season and financial year, 1 October to 30 September. Pre-assurance starts around June with walkthroughs of every KPI, and full assurance starts in September, when a third-party auditor checks the data while the team writes the narrative from October to December.

The report is published online at the end of January or start of February, in English and French so that cooperatives and teams in Côte d'Ivoire can read everything that concerns them. It summarizes the year's progress while putting it in the context of progress over time. Looking ahead, Borck wants to explore impact valuation and an integrated P&L, expressing social and environmental return in the language businesses already use, and she named Natura as the leader.

Key takeaways

  • Tony's Chocolonely describes itself as an impact company that makes chocolate, not the other way around; chocolate sales are central to the business but are a means to its impact goals.
  • Tony's started supply chain traceability in 2012, when it was told this could not be done; EU deforestation regulation now requires plot tracking for cocoa entering the EU.
  • Tony's five sourcing principles cover traceable cocoa, a higher price that enables a living income, strong cooperatives, quality and productivity, and long-term commitments of at least five years with each cooperative.
  • Tony's reported finding 1,702 cases of child labor in its supply chain and treated that as a good sign that its systems were working. Its sustainability reporting and marketing teams were prepared when a big UK newspaper put the story on its Easter cover and cited 1,700 cases.
  • Instead of 'human rights due diligence', Tony's talks about children's rights, going to school and a child's right to play: framing that parents anywhere can relate to.
  • The Tony's Open Chain impact report has third-party limited assurance on all KPIs plus limited text assurance, and is published in English and French so cooperatives in Côte d'Ivoire can read it.
  • Data changed the model: when cooperatives said they needed money to run the sourcing systems, Tony's added a cooperative management fee on top of the living income reference price.

Quotes

We see ourselves as an impact company that makes chocolate, not the other way around

Belinda Borck

In that year we had reported on a thousand seven hundred and two cases of child labor that we had found in our supply chain. And that in itself is a good sign because that means our systems are working

Belinda Borck

The text mentioned 1,700 cases. Which was the part that upset me the most, because at least, like use our actual numbers. So what happened to the two cases that they suddenly cut out?

Belinda Borck

This realization that our radical transparency actually is such a good engine for us to position our story and to position our impact model. It was a huge learning.

Belinda Borck

Frequently asked questions

How should a brand prepare for negative press about its impact data?

Tony's Chocolonely prepares an FAQ with preset answers on the complexities and risks of a story before going public with it, written by marketing with input from the sustainability team. When a UK newspaper ran an Easter cover story on the child labor cases Tony's had found, its sustainability reporting and marketing teams were ready to explain what it was doing about them.

How do you measure whether an impact report worked?

Tony's Chocolonely looks at how much its Tony's Open Chain impact report is read over time, since older pages keep being referenced, and at who picks it up. NGOs and civil society organizations read the chapters that concern them, and the reporting team does proactive outreach to them.

Do consumers have to care about the mission for an ethical brand to work?

Belinda Borck of Tony's Chocolonely questioned whether change always has to come from consumers. Tony's invests heavily in its impact model, so anyone buying a bar is buying from an impact company, and it is fine if some shoppers start because the wrapper looks good on the shelf.

What is Tony's Open Chain?

Tony's Open Chain is the collaborative initiative launched by Tony's Chocolonely to end exploitation in the cocoa sector. When the first mission ally joined in the 2018/19 season, Tony's chose to share its sourcing approach instead of being precious about it, so other companies can source cocoa through the same framework. It now works with over 22 global corporate mission allies.

Why did a Dutch journalist sue himself over chocolate?

In 2005, one of the journalists behind Tony's sued himself for knowingly eating chocolate made with child and forced labor. The case was dropped because no supply chain traceability existed to link the bar to where its cocoa was grown, and that gap became the starting point for Tony's Chocolonely.

About the guest

Belinda Borck is Global External Affairs and Reporting Lead at Tony's Chocolonely and Tony's Open Chain, the initiative through which other companies source cocoa under Tony's sourcing principles. She has worked at Tony's for more than six years, including as Public Policy Coordinator. Before Tony's she worked across politics, international relations, journalism and digital marketing. She is based in Amsterdam and holds a degree in History and International Relations.

About this episode

In this episode, host Neil Callanan is joined by Belinda Borck, the Global External Affairs and Reporting Lead at Tony's Chocolonely and Tony's Open Chain. Belinda shares the brand's 2005 origin story, when a Dutch journalist sued himself to expose child labor and tracking failures in the chocolate industry. Moving from a "lonely fight" to an industry-wide collaborative engine, she explains how they open-source their ethical framework, helping over 22 corporate allies eliminate exploitation across the cocoa sector.

Neil and Belinda dive into the mechanics of turning dry supply chain KPIs into relatable human stories. Belinda also breaks down their five core sourcing principles, opening up about the real value of traceability, sticking to five-year commitments, and embracing radical transparency even when it brings tough headlines. It’s a candid look at how a profit-driven business can scale industry-wide change, shake up old market practices, and actually move the needle on global sustainability legislation.

Transcript

Read the full transcript

Neil Callanan

today on Measured Impact, we're joined by Belinda Borck, external affairs and reporting lead at Tony's Chocolonely and Open Chain. The collaborative initiative launched by Tony's to eradicate exploitation in the cocoa sector. Instead of guarding their supply chain as a corporate secret, Tony's Open Chain has open sourced it, inviting direct competitors and retail giants by cocoa through their ethical framework. Today, they serve as the impact engine for over 22 global corporate mission allies. And Belinda's work sits directly at the intersection of rigorous supply chain management and human storytelling, asking how business can scale industry-wide change without losing operational efficiency and accountability. Belinda, welcome.

Belinda Borck

Thanks for having me.

Neil Callanan

So first I'll start with an easy one. Who are you? Where do you live? And what does Tony's do?

Belinda Borck

those are easy one. Which one of those was easy? well basically, my name, as you already mentioned, is Belinda and I've worked for Tony's now for a little over six and a half years. I am usually based in Amsterdam, where also Tony's Chocolonely was originally started. So we started as a Dutch initiative of a bunch of journalists who were investigating the cocoa supply chain or the chocolate industry more generally speaking, and they realized things are not going well.

Neil Callanan

Yeah.

Belinda Borck

And they started with a media stunt. So one of the journalists actually sued himself. He was the one without kids, so they decided if the lawsuit was gonna go through he could go to prison, it was fine. And then they had a proper trial, so the journalists really did what journalists do best. They did amazing PR around all of this in the Netherlands back in two thousand and five. however, the lawsuit could not go ahead because ultimately there was no way to connect the chocolate bar that's Join van der Koeken, you already get a hint at the name of Tony's there, was eating on camera and had basically said, I have knowingly consumed product made from child and forced labor. Sue me, take me to prison. But there was no way to connect the cocoa and where the cocoa is grown to this chocolate bar because there simply wasn't any supply chain traceability. So the lawsuit itself was dropped, the charges were dropped, Chain never had to go to prison. However, The idea was born and Tony's or Tone's lonely fight in the chocolate industry. So Tony's Chocolate was started in the Netherlands in 2005. That's also still where our headquarters are. And yeah, from there on we expanded quite significantly. And so for the past twenty plus years now, we've expanded into an office in London as well. We have an office in New York as well. One in Hamburg and of course we also have one in Abidjan and also one in Accra, so Ghana and Côte d'Ivoire, the two countries where we source the cocoa from.

Neil Callanan

Talk a little bit about you. Your background seems to have crossed into politics and journalism and social reporting. What drew you to the mission at Tony's?

Belinda Borck

I think ultimately so I did my masters in the Netherlands already. So in the Netherlands nearly now ten years ago, it was next to impossible to escape Tony's chocolandy. And I think what I was drawn to at the time was this idea that we can use business as a force for good. So the idea that also, for example, stands behind B Corp that we can really work with the mechanisms that we already have in place to do something better, to make the world a better place. Because Ultimately, we don't need to reinvent the wheel. We have the frameworks available and we do have the kind of capitalist motivators all around it, right? So they there are these money-making machines, these companies that do exist. And if they existed with a core of goods, we could make the world a better place with the structures that we currently have. I think that was one of the main factors that drew me to Tony's. Because actually beforehand I had completed an internship in Parliament in the UK. So I'd seen the politics and that side of things. And while that's absolutely wonderful as well, it just it it's a different game, right? So for me there was there was a bit of of that call towards a company that is inherently trying to do things differently while also still very much being a profit driven organization as well.

Neil Callanan

Yeah, it's a really cool, model and you can sort of see, you've had a chance to dabble both in the political side and then almost the, you know, nonprofit journalism side where the motivations are different and things move at a different pace and there's a different kind of, culture to it. Also, I very much get the, the desire, you mentioned Tony's is a lonely fight against inequality. how has that changed and evolved over time? Right. So it seems like from the beginning, there was clearly a values mission driven this had purpose from before, products were even generated, but what's changed over the last 20 years or even maybe just the last six for you guys about how you think about the model for having an impact.

Belinda Borck

I think on the one hand everything has changed and on the other hand the core has always stayed the same. so I think those are ultimately the two sides to that answer. So what we've always done, as you were saying, even before the company was started, was raising awareness around the issues, right? So we see that as our first pillar and really the starting point of what we also still very much do, right? So we talk about child labor, forced labour, deforestation, lack of a living income, all of the issues that do exist in COCO. Are for us something that we don't shy away from. What has evolved over time is this quite quirky, funky brand and the beautiful colours that it comes in. And that developed from 2005 onwards. For yeah, I would say the following decade. A lot was done not only on the marketing side, so on the looks of it and kind of the the way that the Tony story is also being told and the way that the graphics work. But definitely also on the sustainability side. So so over the years, what we have developed is an impact model, because we've we see ourselves as an impact company that makes chocolate, not the other way around, which definitely means that the chocolate sales are central to what we are trying to achieve, but they're a means to an end. So they're always towards the goal to make impact. And the impact model that stands behind the chocolate bar itself has evolved by, for example, Back in 2012, we started having supply chain traceability, something that was very vital because that was the major point in the lawsuit as to why that couldn't go ahead, right? So to actually be able to trace back the cocoa to cooperatives, to farms, and be able to have a segregated supply chain flow. Back in 2012, we were told this is absolutely insane and something that cannot be done for the industry. Nowadays we're looking at deforestation regulation that is requiring exactly that. Plot tracking for every type of cocoa that comes into the EU. So we've seen a development over time moving on from 2012, we've developed our five sourcing principles that ultimately are a comprehensive and kind of systemic approach to the issues that exist in cocoa, but that are also trying to look at different angles. Because it might happen that the moment that you know where your cocoa comes from, who Who it is produced by, but also where it is produced, you've actually not yet done anything, right? So so far, you've only found out whether or not there are issues. But now the next step is to actually do something about those issues. So one of those steps is then to say, well, the cocoa price itself is clearly not high enough. So we need to pay a higher price for cocoa that enables a living income. In addition to that, we also realize at this point we work with over 40,000 farmers. That cannot be a one-on-one relationship. So we work via strong cooperatives as well. So we work via a co-op model where we implement via these cooperatives who are ultimately the ones with the boots also on the ground. On top of that, quality and productivity, out of question that that is needed, and that we need to make sure that the cocoa comes from the existing plots and that cocoa farms do not encroach into protected areas, as well as improving things like biodiversity and working on agroforestry measures. But all of these measures. Can be implemented and might also have already come up in different kinds of sustainability programs already. The really crucial factor is none of this will happen overnight. So the long term commitments, so the fact that we work for a minimum of five years with cooperatives and implement everything with this view of we don't expect radical changes and everything to have improved by the next season, is one of the crooks that we've developed and where we've realized. That really does make a difference because you give a chance for positive development. And that has happened over time. And I would say over in 2015 to 2018, we then had really our approach also also settled with small tweaks along the way, right? So we're still far from perfect and we're finding out loads of things along the way. But as we are learning, we're adapting this now fundamental approach of these five sourcing principles, which is why we've then felt confident to say, look. We know it's working for us, we know it's working for Tony's chocolandly. And I would say that the next big turning point then was in 2018, 19, so that season, when we had our first mission ally join, where we've again we've taken the steps. So if our first pillar is we lead by the first pillar is we raise awareness, our second pillar is we lead by example, so we show the five sourcing principles, we then said, well, we need a certain type of hydraulic effect to actually make this happen in the industry. So that is where we inspire others to act and where we've then said, This is actually not something that we want to be precious about. This is something that we want to share with everyone and this is how we believe we can change the industry. So we've just invited everyone to join us.

Neil Callanan

Great. I, selfishly, am very interested in how you guys think about that first, step, was raising awareness. So, for you guys as a, as a team, how do you measure awareness? How do you think about knowing, the quality or the quantity of, of that awareness?

Belinda Borck

Yeah, so I think it comes down to different things. So on the one hand, of course there there are things like for example in our reporting, we do have brand and issue awareness KPIs, right? So we we could go down the boring route right now and we could talk about focus group and stakeholder engagement, but I'm not going to do that. but I I feel like I need to mention it. so we definitely also do that. But I think the more interesting part is there is a bit of a change in discourse. And I will again use that link to in 2012 we were told that traceability wasn't possible. But that has happened over time. And I think what we've seen for loads of other topics, like for example, the topic of a living income for cocoa farmers, that ultimately is now very much something that is being discussed, right? So basically the public discourse is changing over time. And that's what we want to contribute to, and that's what we also want to shape, ultimately speaking. So the issue awareness on the one hand, of course, with the industry itself, but also the awareness of how cocoa, for example, is grown with a general consumer because Whom are we kidding? Most, maybe nearly all of us, are eating chocolate. So we should know a lot more about the ingredient that basically guides this product and to just raise awareness around the issues in it and to see how people respond to it and ultimately what kind of questions you also start getting and how you're being challenged on certain things. I feel like that's also something where you can really see a step up in awareness and where also sometimes we realize that we've we've talked about. maybe the human rights side of things more than we've talked about the environmental side, right? So that's also a step change that we've seen over time, where we've actually realized, we can also talk about that broad range of topics that we do have in scope and make sure that all of this lands with the wider public.

Neil Callanan

we talked to a lot of, brands like yours where, know, we, hear that the consumers often want to make ethical purchases and they want to, speak with their, wallets. but then there's still a large tendency to buy based on price. Cause like you said, you you guys are a profit driven, business, who happens to lead with impact. How do you think about turning that awareness into willingness to, change the purchase behavior?

Belinda Borck

Yeah, yeah, I think definitely a fundamental and really good question. I think I would nearly want to take a step back and first challenge the question as to whether or not it always needs to lie with the consumers. so we are definitely a profit driven business. But as we are also leading with impact, we are also majorly investing in our impact model. I would say that it is a fundamental part of who we are, right? So Tony's Chocolate in itself is, as I was saying, an impact company. So by purchasing a chocolate bar, you are purchasing a chocolate bar not from a chocolate company, but from an impact company. So that makes it inherently important. So I would say yes, there is that element to it. Is it okay if there's also consumers that kind of start by getting excited because the wrapper looks good on shelf? Yes, absolutely.

Neil Callanan

yeah, you guys have a very, bubbly, ephemeral brand that sort of has a natural, playfulness and fun to it. I'm curious how you think about, a natural sort of balance with the more serious side that you're also talking about? it's contrasting, right? The seriousness of the issues and the impact that you're trying to have versus the kind of fun of both the product, but also just the branding and the colors and the fonts and it's very playful. is that intentional?

Belinda Borck

again, really good question. And I must say I'm already smiling because I'm imagining anyone from our impact marketing side listening to that because they know what kind of a painer in the ass I can be when it comes to fact checking something or slightly wanting to reframe something because they have used what we call tonified language. Exactly, yeah.

Neil Callanan

And now somebody is asking you what you think about the fonts and how playful it is. So, welcome impact marketing folks. We, we're happy to be on your side.

Belinda Borck

Exactly, I was gonna say this one goes out to Diara. no, but ultimately I do believe that while it is a difficult balance to strike and it's not always straightforward and it's not always the most easy thing to do, it's a hundred percent necessary because ultimately if we were to get lost in difficult lingo and if we basically create this nearly like academic layer, because that actually then fundamentally describes in Specific detail exactly what we are doing from a sustainability point of view, we lose the majority of people. So it is 100% intentional to simplify and make Tony's story more accessible because that's ultimately what we want to achieve, right? So we don't want to raise awareness with the chosen few that actually understand certain really difficult terms, or in my case, I use way too many abbreviations, one of their main pain points. But Rather to find a way to create an an approachable narrative that then can be heard by the masses and therefore also consumed and understood by the masses is one hundred percent what we're aiming for.

Neil Callanan

Okay. So let me double click on the storytelling a little bit. clearly part of your ability to impact us to connect, with an audience about the impact that you're having or seeking to have or changes in the industry So talk about what works well for you guys when it comes to. telling that story and when that's done most effectively. And that could be wherever you want to take it.

Belinda Borck

I think a lot of the relatable storytelling and creating a narrative that does make sense also needs to come from a place where people understand based on a real life example for themselves. So, for example, there's no questions that parents, wherever they are in the world, want the best for their children. So instead of talking about a child labor narrative, we talk about children's rights. The moment that we talk about going to school, that's something that all parents can relate to that have children that already go to school. So this kind of the connection to something that can hook into your own daily life and that you can relate to, I think is an absolute fundamental that we're trying to create. One thing that I like to use quite a lot is when we talk about children that also when they're a bit older, so 14, 15, 16, if they go to the farm and they Help their parents after school with light work because they learn their parents' trade and they start understanding how their parents make money. I tend to, on the one hand, it's good for everyone to understand what their parents are doing. On the other hand, I was also told as a kid to empty the dishwasher and to not end up being a spoiled little brat. So I think there is some similarities there that we can tease out where. We're ultimately all the same, right? So and I think if we get that narrative right and if we get that connection there, we start communicating not only about facts and we start talking about a deeper kind of emotional level where we start to understand issues instead of just using labels that mean nothing to anyone, like human rights due diligence. That's not something that will ever trigger any emotions deep down in your heart. But the moment that we talk about a child's right to play. That's already a bit of a different tweak to it.

Neil Callanan

I love that answer. It's a really cool approach. I'm curious, can you kind of pull the curtain back a little bit what are the mechanics of that for you guys? How does that actually look team versus marketing team. How do you guys actually collaborate to make that happen?

Belinda Borck

So in the team that I lead for Tony's Open Chain, we are responsible for the Tony's Open Chain Impact Report and one side of that is definitely the dry KPIs of of tracking what is happening and which type of progress we are making.

Neil Callanan

Did you just label the dry KPIs? That's a burn to marketers. Wow. That's good. I like it.

Belinda Borck

It I mean, it is true, right? So it does come down to exactly that. but what what that also means is that instead of only looking at numbers, and again I'll keep up the human rights due diligence and children's right to play example here, because what we could also be looking at is how many child labour cases were remediated last year. That number in itself, again, of course we will report on it because we will also report on the child labour cases that we have found. And we want to report on the progress that we are making on this matter. But on the other hand, we are also reporting on how did remediation actually work? What what is it about a case that means that a child labor case is solved? And then it becomes already a lot more individual, a lot more personal, and also a lot more tangible. So if I were now to tell you that remediation of cases actually doesn't always look the same. So there's different levels of it. So on the one hand, there might be An individual solution. So it might be related to one child in a very particular case needing a birth certificate and therefore they're not going to school because they've never been registered, they're not caught in the system currently. But on the other hand, we might find in a village that 15 children are not going to school. And that might be because the school's too far away. So at some point you also start asking yourself, does it make sense to have a maybe little community school in that place? For other cases, or a huge factor for us has been if children don't stay at school through lunch break because there isn't a school canteen. So school canteens might be a community solution as well. But all of this already colours in that number of remediated cases that we do report on. So that's definitely one part of it to create a narrative around the KPI report that we do have in place. In addition to that, and kind of taking this a step further, what we've done in the last report as well. is we've cre created a couple of a day in the life of stories. So on the one hand we have a cooperative president and kind of basically what does his daily life look like. But again to stay with the same example of the remediators cases from before we also put in a lot of pictures and the storytelling of one of the community facilitators. Those are the people that are employed by the cooperative that visit each and every single household to have conversations about child labor and to see whether child labor exists there. And ultimately if a case of child labor is found, to also have a conversation with the household members about what the best remediation activity would be. So again, it's about the next level of emotional storytelling where we really use an example of someone who does the work day in, day out and doesn't only talk about the work they do, but also what kind of person they are and how they stand behind us.

Neil Callanan

Yeah, you sort of bringing a tangible humaneness to the issue. that's not a number. curious what are the mechanisms to find those stories? how do the boots on the ground folks who are having these interactions, how do they identify like, man, this is a story that will really articulate the impact we're trying to have. How does that flag? How do you guys think about identifying? where those narratives are most powerful when you find them.

Belinda Borck

I think so first of all, because we have a Tony's open chain team in Ghana and we have a Tony's open chain team also in Cote d'Ivoire. so sitting in Amsterdam we have a direct connection and you know loads of also online meetings. So we already have the direct connection in country, but then on top of that, the direct connection again fostered by those teams in country to the cooperatives means that we have a very direct personal link. that is also created over the long term, which gives the chance to also see who, for example, would want to tell their story. So we have a couple of cooperative managers and presidents that are either, for example, there's one who's very poetic. So he he tends to make these wonderful big statements that you can always use as quotes. But that's just also his style. So that's also not something that we've ever looked for. But the moment that you sit in a meeting with him, you will definitely realize that He has a very poetic way about him. So then we obviously seek him out for something like that. While there's others who are also quite keen to be platformed and do not shy away from an audience. So they might then also be actually pulled into whether that is panel discussions or other types of interviews. So it's not necessarily seeking out the stories, but kind of seeing opportunities based on also what people want, because it would never be something where we go out. hunting for something that we then force upon someone. So it's more what naturally happens in an ecosystem that we do have in place via the twenty two cooperatives that we currently work with.

Neil Callanan

it seems like you guys are tracking a lot, both quantitatively and on the sort of qualitative side of just keeping your pulse on, how these cooperatives are operating and what the impact is that you're having with all that numerical data. whether that's the stuff you guys use in your impact report or behind the scenes things that the public maybe might not see. can you give me an example of a time where a piece of data or a finding that was metric driven changed how you guys approached something. where you learned something from a piece of data that said, we were actually, that was a different output than we expected or a different outcome than we expected.

Belinda Borck

I would say we have at least one of those learnings every single year. there's always something where we realize along the way. But I'll give you two examples. So on the one hand, as I was mentioning, we have a sourcing principle that looks at paying more for cocoa. and if we talk about a living income, a living income is a quite complex concept in itself, right? So it's related to prosperity, to resilience, and how a household can maybe also handle financial shocks. So there's loads of elements that come into that that go just beyond the price of cocoa. But what we've also realized is based on the pricing that we do have in place, which is the normal farm gate price that everyone kind of has to pay. add additional premiums that then add up to what is called the living income reference price is that cooperatives were saying that they would love to pay out even more to also the farmers, but they also need to run their systems. So what we saw over time is that there's an additional need for financing for the cooperatives to actually run the systems and run the sourcing principles for them as a business. So we started paying a cooperative management fee In addition to the living income reference price that ends up with a cocoa and permetric ton for the farmers. So these kind of tweaks along the way are a very straightforward example of how we constantly evolve our model, how we're constantly learning, and how we always see, yeah, change is necessary, right? So no one knows everything. The conditions are constantly changing. Let's not get started on climate change right now. but those are definitely learnings that we can take in and where we also have a flexibility to kind of add things to the approach and kind of reflect on how certain things should be working. Another example, again also linked to the cases of child labor that we had reported on. In that year we had reported on a thousand seven hundred and two cases of child labor that we had found in our supply chain. And that in itself is a good sign because that means our systems are working and child labor is very Present, However, we then made it on to the cover of a big UK newspaper for Easter. And the clickbaity headline was ethical chocolate brand finds 1700 cases or has child labor in their supply chain. And then the text mentioned 1700 cases. Which which was the part that upset me the most because at least, like use our actual numbers. So what happened to the two cases that they suddenly cut out. But ultimately, what this came down to was the sustainability reporting team and the marketing team sat together and we could not have been more prepared for the answer to this because yes, we're finding child labor and this is what we're doing about it. So this realization that our radical transparency

Neil Callanan

Yeah.

Belinda Borck

actually is such a good engine for us to position our story and to position our impact model. It was a huge learning. So that was great.

Neil Callanan

you guys clearly aren't scared to go out and talk about the impact, positive or negative. but it's hard, right? Like show up on a UK paper with a bad headline and there's, a tendency, especially in business to sort of. shy away from that. So how do you guys think about preparing for the case? what conversations do you have internally ahead of time or, or how do you think about knowing that sometimes awareness of an issue is going to come with a potential lens that is not always the most positive for you guys.

Belinda Borck

there's definitely always a preparation of FAQ prior to going public with with anything where we do already address complexities and risks that come with any story that we do tell. So there will be preset also bullet point answers that then can be formulated into proper text and copy, simply because we need to outline these these parts as well. So there there is a lot of preparation that is also happening on on the marketing side. And that also happens with the input from the sustainability team And I would say aside from kind of having done this type of pre work, I think it's also about looking at it from a direction of we want to tell the story because ultimately that completes our cycle. So we the cycle is As I was saying, so if we look at the three pillars, so it is about knowing about an issue, then in our case, then doing something about the issue and then making sure that that kind of spreads further. And again, that's also something, right? So if this spreads into other industries, great, right? So whether that's applied to coffee or tomatoes, whatever it can be, so that kind of hydraulic effect ultimately then leads to actual change. So not shying away from talking about something is how we can ultimately do good. Because the moment we don't talk about it, we don't have the awareness and then there's no questions being asked and so no one feels obligated to do anything.

Neil Callanan

Yeah. Well, and I think what it sounds like for you guys, is that the Sort of ethos of how the company was started impacts that still today, right? Like if you're starting with, know, arrest me, then, you know, you can kind of keep some of that, attitude towards, no, we're going to talk about what's real. And sometimes that's great. Sometimes maybe that has potential to make us look, not as spotless as others might want to be. I'm curious how you guys think about your, impact reports specifically for chain. tell us what that looks like, what does it consist of and how often do you do it?

Belinda Borck

we do it annually, so it's a it's a wonderful exercise that yeah quite comprehensively for my team looks at our cocoa supply chain and we have a wide range of KPIs that track different aspects of the sourcing principles.

Neil Callanan

Dry, dry KPIs as well as one that's very dry, boring KPIs.

Belinda Borck

Well, use are boring, I said dry. so but it comes down to it comes down to a bit of both of those. But ultimately, indeed we have a reporting specialist who looks after the assurance process of that as well, because indeed it's not just us tracking that, but we have third party limited assurance on all of the KPIs as well. And in addition to that, we also do get limited text assurance. That means that some claims or some sentences from our report will be pulled out and we need to prove them separately.

Neil Callanan

you

Belinda Borck

Can imagine that a little bit like if you ever wrote any essays at at uni and you had to footnote certain things that weren't your own, that's basically limited text assurance in short. So that's part of our impact reporting exercise. And ultimately the report itself and the way it stands really is a summary of the progress of the last year while contextualizing what type of progress we have made over time as well. So it is trying to look at the issues in COCO that do exist. how we go about our model at scale and then tracking on, as I was saying, child labour, the lack of a living income and deforestation as kind of the main issues that do exist in cocoa.

Neil Callanan

And just, practically is that launched once a year as a PDF? How does the world engage with the content?

Belinda Borck

so we are actually about to enter pre-assurance. So it is ultimately about a six month exercise, but it's not always equally heavy throughout the year. So the cocoa season starts in October and ends in September, roughly. So that means also our financial year runs this way and our annual report obviously aligns with our financial year. So we report from first of October to thirtieth of September. And then yeah, we enter pre-assurance roughly in June now. So that means we have the first kind of walkthroughs of all of the KPIs. There's loads of KPI manuals that stand behind this specific KPI owners. So those will be the specialists that work on specific things. For example, there's a traceability specialist, there is a forest specialist, so they own a set of these KPIs and that now need to be looked after. And we can already establish a couple of trends and look at what the current status is as the year is still running. By September, we then enter into proper assurance. So that is when we actually submit our progress of the year and have our third-party auditor assure it. While they also check the data, we start writing the narrative around these KPIs as well. So that takes roughly from October to December. And then we publish once a year, usually at the end of January or at the beginning of February. And we we publish online, so we have a PDF version or a kind of a PDF reader I should say. And we publish in English and in French because French is the language spoken in Coutivoire and we want to make sure that our cooperatives and also the teams there can fully read and understand everything that we report on as it concerns them directly.

Neil Callanan

Okay, so put your marketers hat on for a minute. What is a metric that you use to gauge that the report itself was successful? does it matter if fits read by a lot of people? Do you care how deep people's understanding is? How do you guys think about the specific metrics and the more consumption side of the report?

Belinda Borck

I think obviously on the one hand it is how much it is being read, but I think that also counts over time. So because we will have different pieces in different reports where we will dive into a specific thing, but we won't cover that again the following year because it might be season specific and whether or not because you can also link to specific pages that get still referenced in the future. So it's not a one year exercise and then that report is entirely retired. So I think that's one part of it. And then on the other hand, there's definitely also an element of who picks it up, who kind of has a look at it. So we do know that loads of NGOs and CSOs, so civil society organizations also have their eyes on us and they will certainly read specific chapters that maybe concern them most. And I must say that we also do proactive outreach in that way that we that we will also send that through. And on the Tony's Chocolonely side. I believe they also but I can't speak in too much detail to that, they also send packages out with a lighter printed version of the report, so with just some of the headline stories and a couple of chocolate bars also to specific audiences.

Neil Callanan

it's a really neat way to approach it. And, I imagine you can get people to open something up if it comes with a chocolate bar. So that's, uh, that's pretty neat. let's jump into a bit of a quick fire, where I'll hit on a few questions. And if you just give me a quick fire response, we'll go from there. So today, um, What brand or organization do you personally look up to?

Belinda Borck

I would say one of the next steps that I would like to take for us and where we've done the first little bits of it is to look into impact valuation in integrated PMLs. So to really look at the societal value add and then obviously also break it down in kind of environmental return of investment, social return of investment. So that entire world of actually using the language that is very much much spoken in corporates and that is kind of the business driver in itself, but apply that to sustainability and therefore normalize our narratives a lot more. And Natura is leading the way on that. So they have an amazing integrated PNL already. So that is definitely life goals of what they are already achieving there. I think there's other brands and we sometimes also unofficially we have a little bit of a group where we get together Natura is also part of it but a lot of other names like Patagonia and Oatli for example where we come together and we all have a little bit of a different approach of how to go about change in our industry. So there's a lot of cross learning that can happen. but ultimately what that definitely comes down to is the a lot of companies that are B Corp certified are doing great work and I think we can all learn a lot from each other and the way that we might have a slightly tweaked view of our industry and therefore of our approaches and what we can take from each other.

Neil Callanan

Yeah, it seems like, you know, the ability to kind of hear how others are approaching is still valuable, even in totally different, industries it also sounds like you're really looking to get some more jargon for the marketing team, some more corporate, acronyms and things that you can weave into everything. So I'm sure they'll be thrilled about that. What do you wish you could measure?

Belinda Borck

Yeah. I think one aspect that we are starting to scratch the surface of is the farmer well being side of things because I think there will always be proxies for that and there will never be a complete picture and there will always be loads of correlations. So how much of our work is contributing to farmer well being I think is a crux that's is great to understand and wonderful to dig in deeper.

Neil Callanan

What book or podcast do you find yourself recommending most to other folks on your team?

Belinda Borck

Interesting. So I do recommend a lot of books. I do read quite a lot of novels.

Neil Callanan

It doesn't have to be professional, by the way. It can be any

Belinda Borck

say which one am I gonna go for? So one that I've definitely recommended before because I think she's a very inspiring author overall and I really loved it is Poison Wood Bible. it's a beautiful book. so I can highly recommend that one. by Barbara Kingsover. but then another one book that I've just started that I'm very excited about is And I now need to remember the proper name of it, is it's written by the founder of the Poetry Pharmacy and the CEO of Lush. And so I I have a feeling that it'll be really exciting because they are combining business and poetry and they're looking at basically what creative mindsets that usually come with being a poet. should be integrated into business and how the business world can learn a lot from the more magical world of poetry. So I'm very excited about that. I'm recommending that without having finished it, but I'm looking forward to finishing it.

Neil Callanan

right, now for our last and most important question. If I were coming to Amsterdam, or really anywhere, where would you send me to get the best sandwich?

Belinda Borck

the best sandwich. Small World just off Harlemastrats is by far the best. And then they have a vegetarian option is a pumpkin one and then there's one that has a turkey melt. Amazing.

Neil Callanan

where can people go to follow more of the work that you guys are doing at Tony's Open Chain and to connect on these issues.

Belinda Borck

we have a quite active and also informative website. We have a lot of our policies up there as well. So in addition to the reports, we actually push out a lot of the work that we do in quite a lot of detail as well. So where we're just trying to for example, talk about our deforestation risk protocol. So definitely go visit our website and there's also a way to reach out via the website and we're always happy to answer any further questions.

Neil Callanan

Awesome. Belinda Brooke is the global external affairs and reporting lead for Tony's charcoal only and it's industry and led initiative Tony's open chain. Belinda joins us from Tuscany, I believe where she's hanging out with her in-laws. Thanks so much for joining us.

Belinda Borck

Thank you for having me.

Get your sandwich

Picked by Belinda Borck

Turkey melt, or the pumpkin sandwich for vegetarians

Small World

Binnen Oranjestraat 14, just off Haarlemmerstraat, Amsterdam, Netherlands