Summary
On Can Marketing Save the Planet?, LooseGrip founder Neil Callanan told hosts Michelle Carvill and Gemma Butler that values-led brands should hold their impact work on brand to the same standard as their sales, because the two usually help each other.
The Grasp Your Impact Framework gives every piece of content an objective such as discover, engage or convert and agrees a few metrics for each before any results come in.
Agreeing up front what success looks like keeps a team from rescuing a missed goal with impressive numbers it never set out to move.
Questions answered
Why do purpose-driven brands struggle to measure their impact?
The bigger obstacle is cultural, said Neil Callanan, founder of LooseGrip: many values-led brands look down on measuring impact the way they measure sales. He used to blame data complexity and tagging infrastructure, but now thinks that saying changing the world cannot be put into a number is often easier than admitting you do not know the answer. Others chase a perfect dashboard or report that does not exist. Activism and nonprofit teams are also less willing than performance marketers to look at what did not work, which makes it harder for them to learn and improve.
Trust in data has two parts: the accuracy of the numbers, a technical problem, and trust between the people reporting the numbers and the people receiving them. One sign a team trusts the process is that someone is a little excited to tell their boss that a channel does not work, because the team can stop spending energy on it. Much of the mistrust comes from people being unwilling to look at a result that is not the answer they wanted.
How do you prove the business case for purpose work to a board?
Boards respond to evidence that purpose work sells: more sales, more email subscribers, more returning visitors, or comments from people who bought something because of a stance. Neil argued that purpose and profit are not in competition. Younger consumers, from millennials to Gen Z, make buying decisions partly on how they feel about a company, and in LooseGrip's work the two have usually helped each other. When a team cannot tell the board exactly what impact it is having, it often stops talking about the numbers at all, because it feels it lacks the ammunition to follow through.
The scarcity brands assume in their audience's attention is usually not real. Algorithms show each post to a fraction of followers, perhaps 10%, and tend to send heavy and light content to the people most interested in each. A month of 30 posts on one issue might reach a given follower about three times, which makes a sustained campaign far less aggressive than it looks on a content calendar.
How should a values-led brand decide what to measure?
Every piece of content, from every email to every social post, should first get an objective, and the team should agree a few metrics for each objective before results come in. In LooseGrip's Grasp Your Impact Framework workshops, the team reviews past content to work out what each piece was meant to do, then narrows the objectives to two or three. A classic set is discover (reaching more people), engage (the quality and depth of attention) and convert (a measurable action). Buying a product and signing a petition both fit convert, so the same metrics work for commercial and activism content.
Teams then split into groups, list ten candidate metrics for each objective, sell their ideas to each other and cut the list to three. That agreement is what protects against glamour metrics: if a donation campaign misses its target, no one can fall back on a billion impressions, because the team already decided impressions did not count. The framework is built for insight rather than reporting. Tagging each post by objective shows which formats, platforms and channels work best for each goal, so the next campaign starts at fifty percent instead of zero.
How do you measure values work that will never match core product sales?
Value that work differently instead of judging it on standard e-commerce metrics. An outdoor gear brand that LooseGrip worked with, which sells tents costing around $800, had environmental-stewardship products that would always look small next to its high-ticket gear. LooseGrip helped it define 'non-adventure purchases', such as a recycled T-shirt tied to a climate pledge, and weight them more heavily, with possible key metrics such as first-time buyers of non-adventure gear or customers who add one to an adventure purchase. A metric does not need a Bayesian model to be useful, as long as it supports action.
Neil said most brands measure either everything or nothing, and neither helps. A Lego box with instructions for one car is easier to build from than 50,000 loose pieces, even though the loose pieces could make a hundred cars. In the same way, the less you measure, the more effectively you can measure it, and a dashboard pulling 50 metrics into one place would need constant maintenance and still not be helpful.
Where should a marketer start measuring purpose work?
Start by getting off the computer for a day. With sticky notes and colleagues in a room, map the ideal journey, such as someone new to a cause arriving on the website and later donating, then decide what you would measure if you could measure anything. Trying to fix measurement while staring at a dashboard is like deciding what kind of ship you need while staring at a sinking one. Look for metrics that are directional and actionable rather than perfect, and deliver data close to decisions, for example the day before quarterly content planning.
For brands starting to talk about what they stand for, a virtue-signal check helps: ask how. A company that claims to support women's rights or workplace diversity should be able to say how that shows up, and if it cannot, saying nothing is usually better. It also helps to pick an issue or two where the brand can see impact, rather than trying to cover everything.
Key takeaways
- Neil Callanan said many values-led brands look down on measuring impact the way they measure sales, and that saying an impact cannot be measured often covers for not knowing the answer.
- The Grasp Your Impact Framework gives every email, social post and public message an objective. A classic LooseGrip set is discover (reach more people), engage (quality and depth of attention) and convert (a measurable action such as a purchase, petition signature or donation).
- In Grasp workshops, teams list ten candidate metrics per objective, then cut to three. Agreeing up front stops a team from rescuing a missed donation target by pointing to a billion impressions.
- Algorithms may show a post to about 10% of followers, so 30 posts on one issue in a month might reach a given follower about three times, not thirty.
- For an outdoor gear brand selling tents around $800, LooseGrip helped define 'non-adventure purchases', such as a recycled T-shirt tied to a climate pledge, and weight them more heavily so stewardship content was not judged against high-ticket gear sales.
- AI lets teams apply a new framework retroactively, for example classifying five years of content across five channels to find what the best-performing discover posts had in common, as long as the AI is told to double-check its math.
- To start, get off the computer for a day, map ideal journeys on sticky notes, choose metrics that are directional and actionable rather than perfect, and deliver data just before decisions, such as the day before content planning.
Quotes
There is no perfect dashboard, there's no perfect report.
You build the framework so that then you can say, what can we learn from this information that will allow us to do better the next time
The less you measure, the more effectively you can measure.
You have to treat the robots like they are small children who might lie to you
Frequently asked questions
What are glamour metrics?
Glamour metrics are big, impressive-looking numbers such as impressions, page views or likes that do not show whether content met its objective. Agreeing metrics up front means a team cannot fall back on these numbers when a campaign misses its goal.
How can AI help measure impact content?
AI can apply a measurement framework retroactively, classifying years of past content by objective and finding what the best performers had in common, such as text length, time of day or whether a person was in the image. AI agents must be told to double-check their math.
Should a brand respond quickly to news about social issues?
Only when it has a long record of advocacy that has earned it the right, Neil Callanan advised. A brand without one should pick a cause it can commit to over time and still feel good about a year from now, and otherwise stay away.
What is the Grasp Your Impact Framework?
The Grasp Your Impact Framework is LooseGrip's approach to measuring values-led marketing. It assigns every piece of content an objective, often discover, engage or convert, agrees a small set of metrics for each objective before anyone opens a dashboard, and uses the results to decide what content to make next.
What did Neil Callanan discuss on Can Marketing Save the Planet?
Neil Callanan, founder of LooseGrip, joined hosts Michelle Carvill and Gemma Butler to discuss why purpose-driven brands struggle to measure their impact, how the Grasp Your Impact Framework sets objectives and metrics, how AI can analyze past content, and how brands can avoid virtue signaling.
About this episode
In preparation for Season 2, we're sharing conversations where host Neil Callanan takes the guest chair. This one's from Can Marketing Save the Planet? Where Neil makes the case that values-led brands hold their impact work to a lower standard than their sales numbers—and that purpose and performance feed each other rather than compete.
He walks through the Grasp Your Impact Framework, which sorts content goals into discover, engage, and convert before anyone opens a dashboard (and away from misleading glamour metrics.)
Links & Resources
- Can Marketing Save the Planet? (Original episode): https://www.canmarketingsavetheplanet.com/podcasts/episode-123-data-driven-insights-for-purpose-driven-marketing-neil-callanan-loose-grip
- LooseGrip: https://loosegrip.net
- Michelle Carvill's LinkedIn: https://www.linkedin.com/in/michellecarvill/
- Gemma Butler's LinkedIn: https://www.linkedin.com/in/butlergemma/
- Neil's LinkedIn: https://www.linkedin.com/in/neilcallanan/
- The Grasp Your Impact Framework: https://measuredimpactpodcast.com/grasp/
- The GRASP Your Impact Podcast: https://measuredimpactpodcast.com/episodes/