Summary
On The New Mainstream Podcast with Mario Carrasco of ThinkNow, LooseGrip founder Neil Callanan argued that a brand's activism can be measured with the same tools as its product marketing, and that purpose and profit can grow together.
The main method is the halo effect: checking whether a strong advocacy post or newsletter item lifts the reach and sales of the product content that follows it.
This shows that activism can be one of the most measurable things a brand does once its effect on the surrounding content is tracked.
Questions answered
How can a brand tell whether its activism is authentic or virtue signaling?
The test is to ask how, said Neil Callanan, founder of LooseGrip: a brand that says it supports a community or a cause should be able to explain how it acts on that support, and if it has no answer, it is virtue signaling. The how looks different for every brand. It might be education, financial support, activism and advocacy, or policy change. A brand without one is only saying the words because a heritage day or awareness month has come around. When a brand does have a how, LooseGrip can measure whether it is working better or worse than it did the month before.
Neil also separates activism created for marketing's sake, which he called probably not good and a virtue-signaling risk, from the marketing of activism, which helps brands that already have a mission tell its story in a measurable way so they can see how it affects their bottom line. Internally, LooseGrip talks about mission-driven brands. Marketing can drive a mission but cannot choose it. Leadership has to choose it, and if the whole thing is a marketing idea, it is the wrong thing.
How do you measure mission content and product marketing with the same framework?
LooseGrip sorts everything a brand puts out, from email and events to social and web, into two or three shared objectives, such as discover or engage and action, so mission content and product content are measured with the same tools at the same time. Getting someone to buy ice cream is similar to getting them to sign a voting rights petition, because both end in a defined action, while awareness content is judged on reach whether it announces a product or a cause. An engagement starts with a survey sent to everyone who touches marketing, from leadership to the person making social visuals, followed by a workshop.
In the workshop, the team lists every way it could measure success for an objective, about 50 metrics, then narrows them to ten, then three, and ideally one or two. An action objective might come down to revenue generated in Google Analytics, traced back to individual posts and emails, and an education objective to video consumption, time on page and subscriber retention. Purpose teams and product teams often talk less than people assume and measure success in different ways. Getting them on the same page creates a flywheel of doing more of what works, and Neil's working hypothesis is that the only way to get there is to have everyone help decide the framework.
Does taking a public stand hurt a brand's sales?
A brand can find out by measuring the halo effect: beyond how an advocacy post performs on its own objective, check whether the unrelated product post that follows it reaches more people and sells more. Not every brand should jump into every conversation. The same test works for newsletters. Does including an activism item before a product launch change open rates and click-through rates, and do people who clicked to sign a petition go on to buy something? Much of this is trackable today if a brand builds the mechanism to track it, and the people most active in a brand's mission are often its best customers.
Neil argued that boldness is a muscle. Brands willing to take a stance on hard issues find it easier to be bold in everyday marketing, such as a TikTok video that does not get watered down in legal review. Host Mario Carrasco described a ThinkNow research campaign about Los Angeles whose launch email drew strong open rates and report downloads along with some negative replies. The agency ThinkNow used at the time wanted to stop, and Mario kept going. Neil said owning a business means choosing whom to serve, and a clear stance makes people self-select.
Can purpose and profit grow together?
Purpose and profit can grow together, and purpose has become a business differentiator because almost every product or service now has a cheaper version made somewhere else. Brand equity has to rest on something more, such as employing people in a hometown or an association that makes customers excited to wear the product. When brands grow, their potential to advance their mission usually grows too, and the tendency to over-intellectualize doing good is part of where the pushback comes from. Mission-driven brands face pressure from both sides: critics tell them to stop talking and just sell, while committed supporters tell them to stop selling.
The same logic applies to services firms facing AI. Someone can always do data analytics or market research for less, so caring about change, and working with brands that care, is what sets a firm apart. The best brands are ones people feel connected to, and customers believe in a brand's commitments when it has lived them over decades. When brands do good, their profits help them do more good.
Do mission-driven companies attract better employees?
In LooseGrip's experience the best brands have the best teams, and Neil does not think that is an accident. Someone who gets a job at a company that publicly cares has usually worked hard to get it, so they are more likely to care about the work and be good at it. At companies whose service is commoditized, by contrast, the caliber of the people he deals with day to day tends to be lower. LooseGrip did not plan for this when it narrowed its focus to mission-driven brands, but now sees it with clients and podcast guests.
Lush is one example. Its advocacy campaigner Seth Laxman, a Measured Impact guest, trains frontline retail employees on the issues the company supports and on how to start conversations about them with shoppers. Retail is a hard job, and giving staff a cause to identify with attracts the best people in retail, improves retention and builds pride in the work. That pride can lead to selling more.
Key takeaways
- Activism marketing, meaning activism created for marketing's sake, risks virtue signaling. The marketing of activism helps brands that already have a mission tell its story in a measurable way.
- Marketing can drive a mission but cannot choose it. Leadership has to choose the mission, and if the whole thing is a marketing idea, it is the wrong thing.
- The authenticity test is to ask how. A brand that says it supports a community on a heritage day should be able to say how, whether through education, financial support, advocacy or policy change.
- A LooseGrip engagement starts with a survey of everyone who touches marketing, then a workshop that narrows about 50 possible metrics to ten, then three, and ideally one or two, grouped into two or three objectives such as discover or engage and action.
- Getting someone to buy a product is similar to getting them to sign a voting rights petition, because both end in a defined action, so the same tools can measure mission content and product content at the same time.
- LooseGrip looks for a halo effect: whether a strong advocacy post lifts the reach and sales of the next, unrelated post, and whether a newsletter with an activism item before a product launch changes open rates, click-through rates and purchases.
- Brands willing to be bold about their mission find it easier to be bold in everyday marketing, such as a TikTok video that does not get watered down in legal review.
Quotes
I think it's marketing of activism rather than activism marketing, right?
Marketing can drive the mission, but it can't choose ... the mission. Leadership has to choose the mission.
The brands who are willing to be bold when it comes to mission have a whole lot less of a hard time being bold in their day-to-day marketing.
You're getting pressure actually from both sides, not only to say less, but also to sell less.
Frequently asked questions
What is the difference between activism marketing and the marketing of activism?
Activism marketing is activism created for marketing's sake, which Neil Callanan called probably not good and a virtue-signaling risk. The marketing of activism helps brands that already have a mission tell its story in a measurable way so they can see how it affects the business.
Who should choose a brand's mission?
Leadership has to choose a brand's mission. Marketing can drive the mission but cannot choose it, and if the whole thing is a marketing idea, it is the wrong thing.
What is the halo effect of advocacy content?
The halo effect is the measurable lift a well-done advocacy or activism message gives to the content that follows it, such as more reach or sales on the next product post, or different open and click-through rates in a newsletter.
How does LooseGrip start a measurement engagement?
LooseGrip sends a survey to everyone who touches marketing, then runs a workshop that narrows possible metrics from about 50 to three or fewer, grouped under two or three shared objectives for all content.
What did Neil Callanan and Mario Carrasco discuss on The New Mainstream Podcast?
Neil Callanan, founder of LooseGrip, joined Mario Carrasco, co-founder of ThinkNow, to discuss mission-driven brands, how to tell authentic activism from virtue signaling, the halo effect of advocacy content and whether purpose and profit can grow together.
About this episode
In preparation for Season 2, we're sharing conversations where host Neil Callanan takes the guest chair.
This bonus episode comes from The New Mainstream Podcast with Mario Carrasco, Co-Founder of ThinkNow. Brands are under real pressure to say where they stand on social, political, and environmental issues, and the ground keeps moving underneath them. Consumer behavior has shifted, and so has what people expect from the companies they buy from.
Neil and Mario get into what that means for purpose-driven brands trying to stay credible in a polarized moment, and how advocacy work holds up when the cultural context won't sit still.
Links & Resources
- The New Mainstream Podcast: http://www.newmainstreampodcast.com
- ThinkNow: https://thinknow.com
- Mario Carrasco's LinkedIn: https://www.linkedin.com/in/marioxcarrasco
- LooseGrip: https://loosegrip.net
- Neil's LinkedIn: https://www.linkedin.com/in/neilcallanan/
• • The Grasp Your Impact Framework: https://measuredimpactpodcast.com/grasp/