The Halo Effect: How Values Drive Value artwork

The Halo Effect: How Values Drive Value The Halo Effect: How Brand Values Lift Commercial Results

Hosted by Neil Callanan

· 9 min

Summary

In this Measured Impact compilation, Season 1 guests described the halo effect, which Chris Miller, SVP of Sustainability and Advocacy at Aspen One, defined as values driving value: advocacy work that lifts a brand's commercial results.

Jay Tandan, formerly Global Digital Lead at Ben & Jerry's, said the brand's advocacy posts were more potent than its product posts over a year of social performance, and that a high-visibility advocacy post tends to lift the post that follows it.

Questions answered

What is the halo effect of brand activism?

The halo effect is the case that values drive value, as Chris Miller, SVP of Sustainability and Advocacy at Aspen One, defined it: associating a product or service with an authentic point of view on the world boosts both. Neil Callanan noted that Chris pushed the LooseGrip team to investigate the effect. Chris's example, as the episode notes summarize it, was Ben & Jerry's putting several million dollars into low-propensity voter turnout in Georgia, work with nothing to do with ice cream that outperformed an ice cream ad on short-term sales ROI. He said a campaign designed to sell ice cream would have failed on both fronts.

Does advocacy content perform better than product content on social media?

On balance, it did at Ben & Jerry's: Jay Tandan, formerly Global Digital Lead there, said that over a year of social performance the brand's advocacy posts were more potent than its product posts, though not as a rule. After a high-visibility advocacy moment, the algorithm tends to boost the next post. The team tested both following an advocacy post with a product post and following it with another post about the same issue, knowing the follow-up would have algorithmic legs. This also helped the team double down on its advocacy initiatives.

Can a brand's values show up in its sales and on its balance sheet?

They can: Brewgooder and Peak Design each described a commercial return from their values. As the episode notes summarize it, when Brewgooder co-founders Alan Mahon and James Hughes stopped staying quiet and launched Sun & Stone with Palestinian brewery Taybeh, the brand saw its highest online sales ever and inbound interest from 16 countries, from a decision they were not sure they would survive commercially. Peter Dering, founder and CEO of Peak Design, described the balance-sheet version: goodwill, built over 16 years, and people in airports who talk at length about their Peak Design bag and the brand. He could not say precisely how much of that comes from standing up for what Peak Design believes in and funding environmental causes, but said it is not nothing.

Key takeaways

  • Chris Miller defined the halo effect as values driving value: associating a product or service with an authentic point of view on the world lifts both.
  • According to the episode notes, Ben & Jerry's put several million dollars into low-propensity voter turnout in Georgia, and that work outperformed an ice cream ad on short-term sales ROI.
  • Chris Miller said that if the get-out-the-vote campaign had been designed to sell ice cream, it would have failed on both fronts.
  • Over a year of social performance, Ben & Jerry's advocacy posts were on balance more potent than its product posts, and a strong advocacy post leaves algorithmic reach for the next post.
  • Brewgooder's Sun & Stone collaboration with Palestinian brewery Taybeh brought its highest online sales ever and inbound interest from 16 countries, from a decision its founders were not sure they would survive commercially.
  • Peak Design's version of the halo effect shows up on its balance sheet as goodwill, built over 16 years.

Quotes

It is making the case that values drive value, that by associating your product or service with an authentic point of view on the world, you boost both things.

Chris Miller

We've noticed that on balance, the stuff we post about our advocacy is more potent than our product stuff.

Jay Tandan

The line item that shows up on an actual balance sheet is called goodwill. And that is what we have been developing over the past 16 years.

Peter Dering

I can't tell you precisely what component of that is our willingness to stand up for what we believe in and our willingness to put a good amount of our money toward environmental causes, but it ain't nothing.

Peter Dering

Frequently asked questions

Should an advocacy campaign be designed to sell products?

Not in Chris Miller's view: if Ben & Jerry's had designed its get-out-the-vote campaign to sell ice cream, it would have failed on both fronts.

What should a brand post after an advocacy post performs well?

Ben & Jerry's tested both following a high-traction advocacy post with a product post and following it with another post on the same issue. Because the algorithm tends to boost the post after a high-visibility advocacy moment, a follow-up on the issue has algorithmic legs, which helped the team double down on its advocacy.

Can a brand measure how much of its goodwill comes from its values?

Not precisely: Peter Dering said he could not say how much of Peak Design's goodwill comes from standing up for what it believes in and funding environmental causes, but that it is not nothing. Goodwill also reflects things like employee retention and how people feel about the company.

Who is featured in The Halo Effect compilation?

The Halo Effect features Season 1 guests Chris Miller (SVP of Sustainability and Advocacy at Aspen One), Jay Tandan (former Global Digital Lead at Ben & Jerry's, now at Protect Our Winters), Brewgooder co-founders Alan Mahon and James Hughes, and Peter Dering (founder and CEO of Peak Design).

About this episode

Values drive value. That's the claim at the center of this compilation, and these conversations from Season 1 put numbers behind it. The “Halo Effect” is something our team spent real time trying to prove: how advocacy work lifts everything around it, including the commercial stuff it has nothing to do with.

Chris Miller was a big part of pushing us to investigate it, and he opens the episode with what Ben & Jerry's saw when it put several million dollars into low-propensity voter turnout in Georgia. Work with nothing to do with ice cream, outperforming an ice cream ad on short-term sales ROI. His read on why: if they'd designed the campaign to sell ice cream, it would have failed at both.

Jay Tandan explains the same effect at the post level, where advocacy content reliably outperforms product content and leaves algorithmic reach behind it that the next post inherits.

Alan Mahon and James Hughes describe what happened when Brewgooder stopped staying quiet and launched Sun & Stone with Palestinian brewery Taybeh—highest online sales they'd ever seen, inbound from 16 countries, and a decision they weren't sure they'd survive commercially.

Peter Dering closes it out with the version that shows up on an actual balance sheet: goodwill, built over 16 years, and the people who stop him in airports to talk about a backpack.

Featured in this episode

Transcript

Read the full transcript

Neil Callanan

Hey, it's Neil. Welcome back to the Measured Impact Pod. One of the best parts about doing this show is asking a bunch of smart people the same question and hearing how differently the answers are, the challenges, the obstacles that they face, the inspiration that drives them to do the things that they do. So we've been pulling these episodes together to use as a compilation episode just like this one. I find these episodes really interesting when we put all these answers side by side. I think you'll hear them differently than you will the first time around. And if you haven't, this is a great place to start. Let's dive in. You were a big part of advocating for investigating and pushing our team identify the concept of a halo effect. So tell me What you define a halo effect as for brand like Aspen and, or Ben and Jerry's and what does it mean for you when you walk into a meeting and you have that kind of data.

Chris Miller

I mean, it is making the case that values drive value, that by associating your product or service with an authentic point of view on the world, you boost both things. Everything's lifted. The data that we had access to at Ben & Jerry's showed during the, was it the 20 2022 midterms, or maybe it was the '24 general election, the work that we did doing voter turnout in Georgia, which had nothing to do with ice cream, was targeted at a specific low propensity voter, hitting them with messages from our partners that had been designed specifically to ⁓ increase propensity to participate in the election. So these were issues around things like common sense gun reform, access to reproductive health services, et cetera. Those paid advertisements significantly outperformed from a short-term sales growth ROI perspective an ice cream advertisement. It's a double whammy. Correct. Correct. And I

Neil Callanan

Yeah. So they're doing both. They are literally performing better on the front end and giving you a prospect of having long-term growth over time.

Chris Miller

And I get like, you know, it takes a little bit of, trust that, you know, I mean, we put, several million dollars into that work focused in Georgia. You know, and it takes a little bit of courage to say, okay, I'm not gonna run the $3 million cookie dough campaign. We're gonna go focus on turning out young, low propensity voters in Georgia. And that in doing that, there is this incredible side benefit, which is it sells even more ice cream. But if we

Neil Callanan

Yeah.

Chris Miller

had designed the get out the vote campaign to sell ice cream, it would have failed on both fronts.

Jay Tandan

So we've noticed that on balance, the stuff we post about our advocacy is more potent than our product stuff. That's not always the rule, but on balance over the course of a year when you look at social performance. it's only expected that, you know, when we post stuff after a high visibility moment that the algorithm's gonna juice that a little bit. And so we've tested both the approach of unintentionally posting a product thing after an advocacy thing, or if we had an advocacy thing that got a lot of traction, all right, what's the next thing we want them to know about that issue? We'll post that organically next, even though it's not gonna perfectly reach the same group of people, we know algorithmically that will have legs. And so it can also help us sort of double down on our advocacy initiatives as well.

Alan Mahon

Yeah, and I think it came from a moment where James and I sort of, you know you get a lot of people who say, don't touch this issue. Don't touch it. Don't do it. Don't go anywhere near it. There's too many risks. And I think at a certain level as human beings, like, James and I looked at each other and said, if we don't do this, like we're bullshitters. we're totally like we're not who we say we are to other people, like our brand is not that if we had stayed silent and we stayed silent for a long, long, long, long, time. You know, that's an eternity when you know you have this, this project that you're working on. And just to put it out there in the world. All we did was launch a beer, a collaboration beer. The headline of it is, that's what it really was. But it went all around the world. It went to the States, it went to Australia. People kind of understood that what we were doing was much more of a statement of solidarity. And I think that's really how we treated it. And we almost had built a brand that was willing to, but also capable of carrying that collaboration, that humanitarian spirit of collaboration. And I think that's what, if I'm reflecting, most proud of, right, that we were also trusted by those guys to do that program, that collaboration with them and on their behalf at a really, really delicate time, which exposes them to more scrutiny in a very, very difficult situation. because they're in the Middle East and their whole thing since 1994 was like they wanted to make the world a better place through beer, right? I mean, you could literally not make it up that there was this other Brewgooder albeit not in a, know, wrapped in the same business model, but ultimately existed for the exact same reason. And if we could get a platform for them or anybody where there could be this little fraction of solidarity being shared over a beer or through beer, Yeah, mean, online sales were the highest they were ever were, right? I mean, it was the equivalent of a Christmas over lockdown where that's just like a totally skewed, you know, picture because that was the main method for lots of people with buying craft beer. there was millions of eyeballs on the campaign for sure. And then there was inbounds from 16 different countries Saying, like, we don't have enough beer in our supply chain, I guess, to even meet that demand, right? Like we were kind of caught off guard and we were prepared for the absolute worst. We were prepared for people to say, sorry guys, you made such a political statement here, even though it wasn't. I mean, check it out. Like it was all about humanity, solidarity. the tolerance for failure or existential threat that that thing did was significant, but also be like, well, if we can't make an impact through that type of campaign, not that this was designed in order to make that impact. But then there was absolutely no chance that the Brewgooder concept could work in the beer industry. You know, we almost had to put the sort of like edge case way, way out there.

James Hughes

I guess so far we know it's successful in as much as that campaign, that initiative raised a significant sum in the immediate term for Taybeh and the chosen charities, which was the primary purpose for doing it. Beyond Alan and I's personal values and saying that that was the right thing to do, we saw a immediate outcome there that was positive for those people ultimately. I think going back to Alan's point around, we would die on this decision. You know, it was almost that getting off the fence moment, I think, for us. You we've done a lot of positive things. We've given a lot of money away to various charities, both on a global and a local level. But I think this one was quite defining in terms of that particular issue. and a lot of people, a lot of businesses have stayed very quiet, you know, despite the fact ⁓ maybe they are built in a similar way to us or have particular values. I was quite alarmed by just how much silence there was out there. ⁓ And I think, you know, going back to Alan saying in five years time, looking at ourselves and saying, you know, would we be proud of the fact if we were also stayed silent or not? I think it was that decision to get off the fence and commit and Truthfully, we did not know what the repercussions of that were going to be, particularly on a commercial level. As much as we think we connect with consumers that align to us, there's a lot of people that just buy our beer because it's on deal or they like the look of it that potentially don't align with that, whether you see it morally or politically or otherwise. ⁓ And ⁓ there could have potentially been negative implications of that. We might still see that play out in years to come if that story and campaign continues to bubble out there.

Peter Dering

And so the line item that shows up on an actual balance sheet is called goodwill. And that is what we have been developing over the past 16 years. Now, that's not entirely the environmental story or the incredible employee retention that we have here. It is also just found in the how do people feel about the company. You describe yourself as a fanboy. And if I had a nickel for every time, I kind of see someone in the airport with a peak bag. I just like, hey, how do you like your backpack? And they just get profusely into how much they like their backpack. But not only that, like the brand. And then about half the people go like, hey, do I recognize you? And of course I get that little dopamine hit there. I'm like, yes, we made a cool brand where there are fanboys

Neil Callanan

Ha ha.

Peter Dering

and here's one out here in the wild. And I still, I get such satisfaction out of that because it's people who like have really connected with a company in a way that's unique. And I have that connection with only a few companies myself, you know? And I know that Peak Design is one of those brands that's capable of that. And I can't tell you precisely what component of that is our willingness to stand up for what we believe in and our willingness to put a good amount of our money toward environmental causes, but it ain't nothing. That's for sure.