Green-Fueled & Gluten-Free with Adam Hiner (Pacha) artwork

Green-Fueled & Gluten-Free Pacha's Adam Hiner on Purpose, Stakeholders and the Purpose Pledge

Adam Hiner, Co-Founder & CEO, Pacha

· 43 min

Summary

Adam Hiner, co-founder and CEO of Pacha, an organic gluten-free bakery, argued that a business should share the value it creates across all of its stakeholders, not mostly with investors, and raised Pacha's money from its own customers and community.

Working through the Purpose Pledge's 10 commitments gave Pacha a strategic plan of goals and KPIs, with someone on its team owning each commitment.

Pacha's case shows that impact becomes measurable once a company agrees what it is committing to and gives each commitment an owner.

Watch the episode

Questions answered

How should a company balance investor returns with its other stakeholders?

A company should name all of its stakeholders and then ask how the value it creates is shared among them, not only with its investors, said Adam Hiner, co-founder and CEO of Pacha. Pacha lists its stakeholders as customers, team, capital providers, farmers and suppliers, the earth and its community. Most businesses, he argued, skew their decisions toward returns for capital providers and forget the rest. If a company shares 99% of the value it creates with investors and leaves 1% for everyone else, it is not a sustainable long-term business. The question for Pacha is how to spread that value across all of its stakeholders, and how to build a framework that makes sure it happens.

The answer starts with who funds the company. Pacha has raised about $4.5 million to $5 million, around $1.7 million of it through Wefunder equity crowdfunding and the rest from direct investors in its network, without venture capital, so its customers and community are also its capital providers. Founders should look for capital aligned with both their values and their timeline. Investors who want a return in two to four years can force tough decisions that do not serve a company's other stakeholders, so patient, time-aligned capital matters.

How do you turn values commitments into goals a team can measure?

Working through the Purpose Pledge's 10 commitments turned Pacha's values into a strategic plan of goals, KPIs and OKRs, with an owner on the team for each commitment. The Pledge was formed by the CEO collaborative One Step Closer, Dr. Bronner's and other companies that wanted a framework covering every aspect of impact and purpose. All 10 commitments must be met, unlike a points-based certification where a company can excel in one area and ignore another. Pacha's founders felt short on bandwidth but joined anyway, and Pacha launched as a founding company at Expo West.

The process turned out to be strategic planning. It gave Hiner more bandwidth, not less, because he could tell each person on his team which commitment they owned and how the company was moving forward. He would not join for marketing reasons, since shoppers do not know what the Pledge is. The bigger value so far is the community: access to teams at companies such as Dr. Bronner's for operating help, purpose capital in development, and the hope that member companies can one day ask retailers together for shelf space and promotions.

Can investing in your own supply chain replace a giving pledge?

For Pacha it did: the company left 1% for the Planet because its regenerative work with farmers already did what the 1% commitment was meant to do. When Pacha formed, it wrote 1% for the Planet membership and a future B Corp certification into its operating agreement. Hiner had taken Boochcraft through the B Corp process and liked having a framework to lean against to measure impact and progress. After Pacha earned regenerative verification, it was supporting farmers in its supply chain to adopt regenerative practices through the Soil Carbon Initiative program, so the separate 1% membership no longer felt necessary.

Which sustainability claims do shoppers actually respond to?

Pacha's customer research found that simple ingredients land most, while regenerative agriculture does not yet drive purchases. Pacha is two ingredients, organic, certified regenerative, in compostable packaging, with minimal waste and a starting wage above minimum wage, and it cannot fit all of that on the package. So the team ran case studies, questionnaires and surveys with customers. Beyond the gluten-free threshold that matters to people with celiac disease and other sensitivities, customers cared most that they could understand everything on the label, so the two-ingredient sourdough has become Pacha's lead message.

Shoppers across brands are not yet choosing products because they are regenerative, Hiner said, though if they did, more farms would switch and the transition would happen faster. Pacha keeps offering the message anyway, the way a parent keeps offering a child a new food, expecting that shoppers will eventually notice that the brands they like have this in common. The direct channel helps Pacha keep listening: it once did about $200,000 a month in direct-to-consumer sales and still has about 70,000 past customers on its email list, which it uses for surveys, feedback and monthly special releases.

Is it worth staying purpose-led when brands are told to say less?

Without purpose, Hiner would not have made it through Pacha's hardest moments. Asked what he would tell founders who hear pressure to take fewer stances, he said starting any business is hard, and described times he was not sure Pacha could make payroll or pay its vendors. In those moments, remembering that the work matters and that the world needs it kept him going. He called purpose the fire in the business, and said that without it a company is only there for the capital return, which leads back to ignoring its other stakeholders. Neil agreed that if building a business is hard either way, it may as well be one you are proud of.

Key takeaways

  • Pacha names its stakeholders as customers, team, capital providers, farmers and suppliers, the earth and its community. In Pacha's view, a business sharing 99% of the value it creates with capital providers and 1% with everyone else is not sustainable long term.
  • Pacha has raised about $4.5 million to $5 million, around $1.7 million of it through Wefunder equity crowdfunding and the rest from direct investors in its network, without venture capital.
  • Founders should look for time-aligned capital: investors who expect a return in two to four years can force decisions that shortchange a company's other stakeholders.
  • Customer case studies, questionnaires and surveys showed Pacha that its two-ingredient sourdough, with no binders, fillers or gums, is the message that lands most. Regenerative agriculture does not yet drive purchase decisions, so Pacha keeps mentioning it patiently instead of leading with it.
  • At its direct-to-consumer peak Pacha did about $200,000 a month in online sales while spending $50,000 to $100,000 a month on Facebook and Instagram ads. It has since cut performance ads to focus on retail, but still uses an email list of about 70,000 past customers for surveys, feedback and monthly special releases.
  • The Purpose Pledge requires companies to meet all 10 of its commitments. Working through them gave Pacha a strategic plan with goals, KPIs and OKRs, and an owner on the team for each commitment.
  • Shoppers do not know what the Purpose Pledge is, so it is not a reason to join for marketing. For Pacha, its main value so far is a peer network of purpose-led companies, such as Dr. Bronner's, whose teams help each other solve operating problems.

Quotes

If we're sharing 99% of the value that we've created as a business with our capital providers and only 1% is left for those other stakeholders, it's not a sustainable long-term business.

Adam Hiner

Right now the consumer, they're not gonna make a purchasing decision because a brand is regenerative or not. It's just not happening right now.

Adam Hiner

Dr. Bronner's... they're just always doing the thing that no one thought that anyone could ever do and be successful at it.

Adam Hiner

And so the purpose is our fire in the business. And I think that without it, we're just here for the money.

Adam Hiner

Frequently asked questions

Do customers care whether a brand has signed a purpose pledge or certification?

Not yet, in Adam Hiner's view. Shoppers do not know what the Purpose Pledge is and probably will not care for a long time, so he would not join it for marketing reasons; for Pacha, its value has been a network of purpose-led companies that help each other solve operating problems.

How can a brand that sells mostly through grocery stores get direct customer feedback?

Through a direct email list: Pacha started largely as a direct-to-consumer brand and still has about 70,000 past customers on its list. It uses that list for surveys, feedback and new product ideas, and keeps those customers engaged with monthly special releases and a subscription, even though it has cut its performance ads.

How should a founder test a new product idea?

Adam Hiner usually starts by solving his own problem, then checks whether friends and family want it too. He pointed to Seth Godin's book This Is Strategy and its idea of a minimal viable audience: find ten people who resonate deeply with what you make, and see whether they share it.

What is Pacha?

Pacha is an organic, gluten-free bakery with its facility in Vista, California that makes bread, English muffins and tortillas from two ingredients: sprouted buckwheat and sea salt. Adam Hiner started it in 2020 with his wife, Maddie, and the founders of Trilogy Sanctuary, and it is sold at Whole Foods, Sprouts, Natural Grocers and independent grocery stores.

What is the Purpose Pledge?

The Purpose Pledge is a framework formed by the One Step Closer collaborative, Dr. Bronner's and other purpose-led companies. Companies must meet all 10 of its commitments, and Pacha was one of the founding companies that launched with it at Expo West.

About the guest

Adam Hiner is co-founder and CEO of Pacha, which makes gluten-free sourdough bread, English muffins and tortillas from sprouted buckwheat and sea salt. He has worked in organic food and beverage since 2007. He started Southern California's first organic catering company, Eco Caters, and the farm-to-table restaurant Local Habit, then in 2016 launched Boochcraft, the first hard kombucha brand, which he grew to $15 million in revenue before leaving its operations to start Pacha. He remains on Boochcraft's board and sits on the board of The Ecology Center, a regenerative nonprofit farm in Southern California.

About this episode

We’re diving into season 2 with guest Adam Hiner, CEO and co-founder of Pacha, an organic, gluten-free bakery making bread and tortillas from just two simple ingredients: sprouted buckwheat and sea salt. Adam takes us through his unique serial entrepreneurship journey across San Diego's food scene—from pioneering organic catering and farm-to-table dining to founding Boochcraft, California’s first hard kombucha brand.

Neil and Adam get into the realities of modern brand building, discussing how to balance various stakeholders without sacrificing mission or commercial growth. Adam also shares how Pacha utilizes the Purpose Pledge framework to operationalize company-wide strategy, and why purpose serves as the ultimate internal fire that sustains an entrepreneur through the darkest challenges of business.

Transcript

Read the full transcript

Neil Callanan

Today I measured impact. We are joined by Adam Hiner, the co-founder and CEO of PACHA, the brand making gluten-free sourdough bread and tortillas from just two ingredients: sprouted buckwheat and sea salt. Adam took an unusual route into food. He started in Southern California's first organic catering company, Eco Caters, followed by a farm of the table restaurant, Local Habit, and built strong ties into the food scene in San Diego. In 2016, Adam launched the first ever hard kombucha brand, Boochcraft, and created a whole new category of adult beverages with a sustainable approach. He grew that company into $15 million in revenue before leaving the operations to start Pacha and remains on the board guiding strategic decisions. So welcome. Thanks for joining us. Here at Measured Impact, I like to just start with a little bit about who you are, where you live, and what Pacha is all about.

Adam Hiner

Sure. well, I'm Adam, as you know from the introduction, CEO, co-founder of Pacha, and I live in San Diego. I actually live in two places. I go back and forth between the desert, about an hour east of San Diego in a little town called Boulevard, California in the high desert. And then our Pacha facility is up in Vista, California. So I commute for about two or three days a week into town and live in Encinitas, California while while I'm in town.

Neil Callanan

So tell us a little bit about what Pacha is and how it came about.

Adam Hiner

So Pacha is an organic gluten free bakery. We make bread, English muffins, and tortillas with just two ingredients, buckwheat and sea salt. And the origin of Pacha, well, I'll tell a little story that'll kind of lead us to the origin of Pacha. So, rewind back to about 2018 and I was not eating any gluten at the time, and I also couldn't find any like good gluten-free bread on the market. Everything was chucked full of binders and fillers and gums and weird ingredients that I didn't recognize. And so I just wasn't really eating bread. And I went on a spiritual retreat out to Mount Shasta with a good friend of mine who was leaving the retreat. And we were on this retreat, we're in Mount Shasta and it's so beautiful. It was a meditation retreat. So we were doing a lot of meditating. We were, you know, just enjoying the the beauty. of all of the nature and the incredible water. And one of our friends on the retreat brought this bread and he busted it out. And he was like, this is some, you know, seed bread that I make with buckwheat and flax and sunflower. It was a different recipe at that time. and he shared it with us. And I ate the bread and I don't know if it was because I was on a spiritual retreat and the bread was really good, but like it was literally the best thing I'd ever put in my mouth. And I think

Neil Callanan

Yeah.

Adam Hiner

I pretty much just ate that bread. along with whatever dips and spreads and things were there, probably ate like 50% of the bread he brought. I was just like eating it constantly. I was so happy. And I came back and, I eventually got some more bread from him and he was making—him and his his girlfriend were making it at home like a little cottage kind of style business. And I was getting bread from them and I would get like a loaf or two every week and I would share with people And then they went traveling, they left town and they weren't making the bread anymore. And was like, hey guys, not cool. I need that bread. And so they sent me the recipe on this like little chicken scratch piece of paper. It was just like buckwheat, flax, soak, blend, bake, or something. It was just like there was no instructions. And I was like, okay, I'm a chef, I can figure this out. So I took the chicken scratch recipe and I started playing with it. And I, you know, made or rendition of it and then I just kept iterating it and sharing it with friends and you know, over the course of a couple years of making it and sharing it with people, it really became clear that this was something that needed to be in the world. And then, the guy who actually brought me on that spiritual retreat, Joe Caldera, he owned a business called Trilogy Sanctuary and they were looking for an organic gluten-free bread and couldn't find one anywhere. And they came to me and said, Hey, we need an organic gluten-free bread. We know you're making this bread, like can you make it for us? And I was kind of blown away, like, no, there must be an organic gluten-free bread out there on the market. And I looked out and found there wasn't one. And so then it was just like the light bulb right then was just, okay, we need to do this. So we actually partnered up, Joe and I, the Trilogy Sanctuary, and my wife, Maddie, jumped on board and all the other kind of founders of Trilogy Sanctuary were there and we started Pacha. And that was in 2020.

Neil Callanan

That's quite the origin story, you know. makes you hungry just talking about it. Talk to me a little bit about, you know, your background prior to Pacha. I understand that Boochcraft was another product you were heavily involved in the launch and the spearheading of. Sort of feels like there's this intersection for you of progressive brands and entrepreneurship. And I'm just curious kind of what do you think? Where did that come from for you and and how did you get started, both in the entrepreneurial sense, but also just thinking about it through the the lens of values and, you know, leaving the world a better place?

Adam Hiner

Well, I think entrepreneurship is probably in my DNA a little bit. My dad was an entrepreneur. He started a construction business building custom homes, him and his brother and my my mom is a psychologist and owns her own business as well with a partner and so kind of grew up surrounded by entrepreneurs and just I guess knew that that was something I could do. You know, it was just like something that was possible, was just always there for me. And then I moved to California after college and initially I got into the mortgage business and I did a short stint in the mortgage business and I learned a lot about marketing and running a business and I kind of quickly moved to the top of the— I was helping the owner manage his business for him and I helped him launch an online mortgage company and I hired a sales team and I learned about building a website and online marketing and and then there was the mortgage crash in 2007 and at that point I kind of just had this epiphany that I didn't want to do that. Like, I could have stayed in the business and that company is actually still around, they're still doing mortgages and I could have kept doing it and I just had this kind of gut feeling of this isn't actually my path. And so I decided to part ways at that time. And I very quickly afterwards started consulting with a buddy of mine who was a chef in in LA and he wanted to kind of launch a bigger catering company and I decided to partner with him. And before all that though, in my time in the mortgage industry, I had really become interested in organic food. And I was going to the farmers market. My sister, Rachel, had gotten a job with a nutritionist and We were living together. And every single day she would come home with either a new thing that we had to eat or another thing that we couldn't eat anymore. I was like,

Neil Callanan

Mm-hmm.

Adam Hiner

You're not allowed to eat bread anymore. You have to eat sprouted bread. And we were eating Ezekiel. And she was like, You can't eat regular nuts. You have like soak and sprout them and then put them in the oven for 24 hours and dry them out and they have to still be alive. And just like all these new concepts that I just had no, I had no awareness of. and so I got really, really interested in organic food and even growing food. And then fast forward to starting that catering company with Nick, it was like, okay, let's do this, but if we're gonna do this, it has to be all organic. And Nick was on board for that. He was already shopping at the farmers markets for all of his, you know, clients that he cooked for up in LA. And he was a a chef that made everything from scratch. So that was something that was imbued into the DNA of what we did, was making everything from scratch. And that was probably the greatest education I've ever had, was just starting that company with Nick and learning how to cook. I got to spend all of my time with Nick who was a chef from New Orleans. He worked at some of the top restaurants in LA. He was a personal chef for J Lo when he moved to LA. He did a lot of personal chef work for, you know, really high-end families and kind of private dinners and things. And so I got to cook with him and learn all about French cuisine and making food from scratch. And I was just soaking it all up. I was just like drinking from the fire hose and learning all about food and then bringing my values of organic food and organic farming to the table and learning more about that as well. And so that was kind of the genesis of my food, business side of things. And then at some point we launched a restaurant. It was called Local Habit. It was farm the table, everything made from scratch. And it was really challenging. We were there all the time working constantly. We were still running the catering company. Nick left LA and moved to San Diego to be the head chef of the catering of the restaurant. And then so we, you know, had a team up in LA and I was going back and forth between San Diego and LA, managing the catering company and running the kitchen in San Diego, and also managing the front of house of the restaurant. We were strapped really thin. And at that time I was making kombucha and I put my kombucha on tap. At the restaurant and people started coming in from all over San Diego and just filling drawers of kombucha and leaving. And that was a little bit of a light bulb moment. Like, kombucha. Okay, this could be I thought that was just a hippie drink that I was really stoked about, but this was there was something there. And so we sold the restaurant after two years to get back to the catering, and we were really feeling like we wanted to focus on the catering company. And at that time, I started kicking around this idea with a friend about the kombucha brewery. And again, just really quickly that went from an idea to a business and we started, Boochcraft, you know, within months of that.

Neil Callanan

I'm curious a little bit it strikes me as multiple times in your journey, the idea of starting a business feels very natural to you, it's clear, right? Like, you know, you see a problem, you see a thing, and a light bulb goes off in your head. And I think for a lot of folks, that's not necessarily the case, right? Like where they they have these light bulb moments, but there's a barrier or just a lack of awareness that like, well, that those are the moments when somebody goes in and starts, they find a market and they start a business. I think a lot of folks just don't see it as a viable route, but it's clear that you've thought of it as a viable route from a pretty early age. So What do you think folks miss or get wrong about sort of executing and taking that first step?

Adam Hiner

For me, first of all, is I'm always solving my own problem typically with these businesses and thinking about what is something that I want, and what is something that I'm missing in the market. Cause that's always a good like test case of like if if I can't find it and if I need something better or something different that's in the market then other people probably do too. So I'm typically scratching my own itch in the beginning. And then You know, I have had businesses where I had the light bulb and it's like, let's do this and we fund an account, we go do it. But I've also had businesses where, like Pacha, where I just started making the bread for myself. And then other people were asking for it and I started, you know, sharing it with people. And so There can be a slow evolution. Like I think if someone's really interested in starting a business and they identify a problem and they're solving it for themselves, then the next step is maybe see if they can if other people like their friends and family resonate, you know, and that they are solving it for their friends and family as well. And kind of like take one step. Like the minimal viable audience is really important, I think. Seth Godin has a book called "This Is Strategy", and he talks about, like Find ten people that resonate really deeply with the thing that you're trying to do and share it with those people. And if those people all go out and share it with 10 people, then you've got something successful and you should you should follow that. And if those people don't share it, then reevaluate either the thing that you're sharing or the people that you chose to be those 10 people. So I think that's a good first step. It's just start sharing it with people.

Neil Callanan

Yeah, it seems like in in at least in the Boochcraft and Pacha you had sort of a an indicator that people were willing to pay for the thing, or that there was demand for a thing. And then it was taking that opportunity and thinking about how you could turn that into a more full fledged, business. You know, when I look through the Pacha story, you guys have had a fairly values-forward journey to launching the brand and how you have been involved with, everything from the the sustainability of the product itself, but also just sort of B Corp standards around California's minimum wage and 1% for the planet involvement in the early days. So, talk to me about how you think about values broadly or whatever you want to refer to as everything outside of just making a profit and how you see that as you're building a business and when you start to think about that.

Adam Hiner

Yeah, this is something that's been evolving for me. And lately I've been thinking about, like every business has stakeholders and people talk about that and they say, oh stakeholder engagement. But are what are we really doing to engage with our stakeholders and are we really identifying all of our stakeholders? And so at Pacha, we we've identified our stakeholders as our customers, our team, our capital providers, our like farmers, suppliers, and the earth and our community. And so I think most businesses, they really focus on generating a return for their capital providers. So they really like skew their efforts and decision making towards generating a return for their capital providers. And in lieu of that, they kind of forget about the other stakeholders and their decision making. And so in other words, a business is here to create value. You know, we're we're creating value as a business. And if that value is then shared back out disproportionately, like if we're sharing 99% of the value that we've created as a business with our capital providers and only 1% is left for those other stakeholders, it's not a sustainable long-term business. And so I when I think about impact and values, I'm really thinking about like how can we spread that value that we create as a business across all of our stakeholders and what does that look like? And, you know, how can we build a kind of a framework too to make sure that we're doing that?

Neil Callanan

Okay, So the natural question that follows that is where are you finding or how do you think about your relationship with those capital providers who generally would like to be first in line and be the highest percentage of that breakdown of return? So, how are your relationships with your your funding providers? and how do you think about sort of communicating and engaging them in a way that helps them sort of believe in this as a mission versus, you know, just the Line item of a return?

Adam Hiner

Yeah. so we've been lucky enough to have all of our capital be provided by our community and our customers. So two of our stakeholders are our capital providers really. we've done a few different friends and family capital raises where we've raised money directly from individuals that are in our networks and in their networks that believe in what we're doing. And we've done a few rounds of WeFunder equity crowdfunding where we've generated most of that money that we've raised through our customers. which has been about, you know, in total we've raised about $4.5M - $5M and about $1.7M from equity crowdfunding and the remainder from direct investors. So we've been lucky enough not to bring in money from let's say a VC that's main goal is to get paid out in three to five years and wants to generate, you know, really big returns. And so I think part of that for for anyone that's looking to bring in capital is trying to find the right aligned capital with the values in the mission. from you know from a values perspective but also from a time perspective. Like time-aligned capital is really important. if you're gonna bring in money and them and the money wants to get their return in 2-3-4 years then you might have to make a lot of tough decisions to get them a return that might not be, you know, valuing your other stakeholders in the way that you want to. So finding time-aligned capital that's a longer timeline is really important too.

Neil Callanan

As you guys are building the brand and it's seems like distribution's going the right direction and Whole Foods and Sprouts and a lot of different places. how are you thinking about the narrative and the storytelling aspect. you guys clearly are committed to all things sustainability when it comes to the product, both from the product itself, but also sort of how you position it. But I'm interested in how you guys think about communicating that story to your customers or to your prospects and how you bring people along from a almost a marketing perspective, like how important is the totality of your mission to the story that you tell to the audience?

Adam Hiner

Yeah, that's a that's a good question. It's something that is changing and we're hoping to to be able to tell more of the story and for it to resonate with more people. You know, we're we're one of those brands that just checks all the boxes. It's like we're two ingredients, we're organic, we're certified regenerative, we use compostable packaging, we minimize our waste, we pay our employees, you know, like a certain percentage above minimum wage as a starting wage. Like there's so many things that we're doing, and we can't communicate all of it, like all of it can't just be on the front of our package, right? Like the consumer is only interested in so much. And we've been trying to understand what resonates with the consumer. So we've been doing a lot of case studies and questionnaires and surveys with our customers trying to learn like okay well what do they actually care about because we've been communicating a lot of these things and some of them land and some of them don't land so much. And what we found is that the one that lands the most is the two ingredient Sourdough. That they really care about the minimal simple ingredients. and you know, I think that I would say a subside of that, obviously that it's gluten-free for especially for the celiac and the people with you know dietary restrictions that are sensitive. But once we move kind of beyond that first threshold where they wouldn't even be able to eat it if it wasn't gluten-free, the fact that it's two ingredients that we use simple ingredients is really important to our customers. So that is becoming kind of the beacon of what we're communicating to our customers is just simple ingredients. Like you can understand everything on the label. There's no binders, fillers, gums. that's like the most important. And then we want to kind of pepper in some of the other things. We really want the consumer to start to understand more what regenerative agriculture is and why it's so important. But the consumer in general across all brands and all the customers is just not there yet. They don't understand regenerative and a lot of brands are doing a lot of work to try to bring that forward, but right now the consumer, they're not gonna make a purchasing decision because a brand is regenerative or not. It's just not happening right now.

Neil Callanan

you know, I think one of the balances that's hard for brands who check as many boxes as you do, is that like balancing the consumer interest in those elements can can be tough, especially as you grow into bigger and bigger markets, right? Then the natural size of a market who understands regenerative agriculture, is probably quite a bit smaller than potentially maybe where you guys want to be just from a pure revenue standpoint. So if I'm a consumer of your product solely 'cause it's gluten free or solely 'cause I like two ingredients, like does it matter if I know about all the other stuff?

Adam Hiner

No, not really. I mean, so I'd say yes and no. It doesn't really matter because if you're buying the product and you're supporting our mission and then we're in turn supporting regenerative agriculture, then the work is being done. But if let's say you did Care that it was regenerative and you knew, and then you started kind of making purchase decisions based on that. We would see more and more brands and more and more farms switching over to regenerative, and we would build the demand from the consumer level in a bigger way, and then we'd get that transition to regenerative agriculture happening faster. So I think it does matter, but we need to be patient, just like the capital that we're looking for. We need to be patient with the customer and the consumer and just keep it there on the radar and keep talking about it. It's like a kid, you know, with our daughter, we're just like, if we give her something and she doesn't like it, we just keep offering it to her. You know, just like maybe it's gonna take 10 times, and then one day she's gonna try it and she's gonna be like, I actually like this, and then she'll she'll eat it. So just keep it there, keep offering the regenerative piece to people, and then eventually they're gonna be like, wow, wait a minute, I'm noticing a pattern. All these brands that I really love and that I resonate with, they're all regenerative. okay. Maybe that's something that's important. So I think that over time that'll that'll sink in.

Neil Callanan

How do you guys think about your relationship with your customers? It seems like the majority of your sales are going through retail outlet, right? Through a grocery store or or elsewhere. But what relationship do you have with your customers in terms of your ability to get direct feedback from them or communicate with them directly about a specific mission or a update or a thing? Are you able to capture a fair amount of them in a marketing sense or in a in a means where you guys can keep in touch with them on in a more regular basis? Like, what what does your relationship look like today with the bulk of your customers?

Adam Hiner

Today, the bulk of our customers are buying from retail stores, Whole Foods, Sprouts, Natural Grocers, you know, independent grocery stores. So we don't really have a direct relationship with those customers, with most of them. Although we can go into a store and do a demo and you know have some customer interaction if we want. But we do it when we need to talk to the customer. But we also started most primarily as a D2C brand. We didn't think that would be the case when we started, but that's just something that happened. And we launched a really big D2C revenue stream we were doing you know 200,000 a month in D2C revenue at one point, and we were spending another 50,000-100,000 a month in Facebook and Instagram ads. So, We do have a large customer base. We have like maybe 70,000 in our email list. And those are all past customers, like every single one of those people have bought bread from us. So we can use that channel for direct feedback, we can use it for innovation, we can send out surveys, and we can get a lot of feedback in that way. but you know, some of those people might just buy from us directly and not buy at the store and some of them might be like a hybrid customer and we might have lost a lot of those people to the store. but there's a lot of people also shopping in the stores that probably have never bought from us directly. So we can't reach everybody in that way.

Neil Callanan

Yeah. And how from a marketing standpoint is the your like today, are you guys actively in the, you know, D2C customer acquisition phase? or is it sort of once the retail engine gets up and running, that's that's become where your your focus is? How much direct outreach are you doing to try to pick up new D2C customers?

Adam Hiner

We're not doing really any direct acquisition work right now. We're focusing everything on supporting retail. We cut out all of our ads, performance ads. but we are engaging with the with that audience still. We still we do a monthly special release where it's kind of a new product every month and something they can't get in the stores to keep them engaged and We have a subscription people buy from us and so we are like nurturing the channel in a way that we can continue to get feedback and to launch new innovation items. but we're not trying actively to bring in new customers in that channel. We're really pushing people towards like towards grocery stores.

Neil Callanan

it's a really cool switch to to have that initial bucket, I think, of those D2C customers to be able to communicate with, even if you're not actively trying to sell them that hard, just like having that audience I think it's pretty unique for brands that are so grocery dependent or retail dependent, it's really neat that you guys still have that at your fingertips when you need it. you know, when I look through your your content, there's a 1% for the planet angle, there's matching some B Corp standards, and now on to the announcement that you guys were gonna be part of the purpose pledge. So, tell me about what that journey has looked like for you guys in terms of how you think about operating the business and what the different elements are that have kind of brought you to where you are now and in the Purpose Pledge?

Adam Hiner

Well, when we launched the business early on when we formed the LLC, we put it in the operating agreement. Like we are going to be a 1% for the planet company and we will become a B Corp, you know, when the time is right, when we're re when we're ready. So that was something we were really clear about. I had taken Boochcraft through the B Corp process and I really liked having a framework that we could lean against to see how we were doing to measure our impact and to kind of measure our progress in that in that world. I think we started off as 1% for the planet, but then we left 1% for the planet because we got the regenerative verification and through the work of the regenerative verification we were supporting farmers in in our supply chain. And so we felt like the 1% wasn't really necessary because we were kind of still doing the 1% we were doing in in the sense of supporting farmers to implement regenerative systems. And through that SCI (soil carbon initiative) program, we were giving back to farmers And then The purpose budge came along and quite honestly, we were just bandwidth constrained at the time. And we're a part of a group called One Step Closer. And One Step Closer is a collaborative, it's like a CEO mastermind group, but there's other facets to it. There's like a packaging collaborative and there's a Jedi collaborative, and there's all these different groups within OSC, but the the core of it is the CEO leadership group. And so we have a bunch of other companies at our fingertips that we meet with on a regular basis that we get to talk about challenges and workshop ideas and problem solve and then there's and there's two tiers there's the rising stars and there's a higher tier called the core and the core is like companies like Dr. Bronner's and Guayakí and Numi who have been through it and have grown and are there to support us and we can have a mentor come down from one of those companies and help mentor us. Which I have Ahmed he's the founder of Numi he's my mentor and he stayed with me beyond the initial kind of like six months Mentorship, he's still been mentoring me for a couple years now. And being part of that group has given us so much in the way of like support. And then, Purpose Pledge came along, and it was formed by OSC by One Step Closer and by Dr. Bronners and a couple other companies that were really passionate about wanting to build a framework that was really covering all aspects of of impact and purpose. And the feeling was that you could be a B Corp, but you could be really good in this one area and you could be completely ignoring this other area, but as long as you had the points that you needed to be a B Corp, you were a B Corp. So in that framework, you you could just be completely forgetting about some of your stakeholders and ignoring them completely and still achieve that status. And within the purpose pledge, there's 10 commitments and you have to achieve all 10 commitments. And so I really liked that that framework. And but at the same time when we were presented with it, we were like, oh my gosh, we want to be a part of this. The companies that are doing it are the companies that we love dearly. We wanna learn from them. So we kind of sat on it, we slept on it, Maddie and I, and the next day we were meeting with Les from Broner's who's leading the Purpose Pledge initiative and both of us were kind of just like, Yeah, we we wanna do it. Like we don't feel like we have the bandwidth to do it, but we think that like it's gonna be worth it. So we decided to jump in and we became one of the founding kind of companies that that launched with the purpose pledge at at Expo West this past year. And what we found though is like going through the process was actually like building a strategic plan. We actually built a strategic plan through that process and we built a strategic plan of how we're going to go from you know A to Z with all of these different initiatives to honor all these commitments and all these stakeholders. And at the end of that process, we had a strategic plan of goals and KPIs. And we went through like an OKR, you know, objectives and key results. And it was really helpful. It really gave us a clear like directive and I could go to my team and say, okay, this is This is what we're doing in this area, and this is what we're doing in this bucket, and you're gonna own this commitment, and you're gonna own this commitment, and this is how we're moving forward as a company. And so the process actually in some ways like feels like it gave me a lot of clarity and rather than being bandwidth sucking, it's actually given me more bandwidth to be able to give clearer directive to our team. And feel like the team is kind of on board for the purpose now in a bigger way.

Neil Callanan

Yeah, it sounds like, any of these sort of really firm values commitments, whether that's you know, going B Corp or, any number of programs depending on your industry. How do you think about it as a catalyst in the business as a whole? Right. Like it sounds like there was a lot of strategy that came out of your purpose pledge side, but I guess I'm I'm asking you to speak to the folks who are sort of saying, like, yeah, I don't have time for any of this stuff. Like we're we're doing pretty good and we think we're trying to treat people pretty well. And you know, we don't we can't go through another certification or a framework or a commitment. Talk about what you think it does for your business and your team to sort of have some structure to it.

Adam Hiner

Yeah, that's a big question. And we're figuring that out. Like I was I was just at a purpose pledge strategy meeting and we were sitting in the room with all of the purpose pledge companies, but also companies that were kind of on the fence of I don't know if this is right for me, but we're interested and investors because there's a whole purpose capital piece being launched and worked on right now. So and that's a big question. Like, what is this gonna do for me? Is it just another certification that I'm gonna put on my package and my customer's not gonna care about it? And to some extent, yes, like the customer doesn't know what this is, they're not gonna care about it, and they're not gonna care about it for a really long time, probably. So I wouldn't do this from a marketing perspective right now. But, What I found is the community of companies that are a part of Purpose Pledge, like the ability to go over to Dr. Bronner's and have access to anyone on their team, for anyone on my team, like you know, someone in HR or someone in ops, and we're having a problem, like, how do we solve this thing? How do we scale to the next level? What are we going to do? what equipment do we need? Now we have access to all of these other purpose pledge companies, and some of them are much bigger than us, and some of them are similar size. And it's a team of people that are all like, it's like family. You know, I would drop anything I'm doing at any time if someone from my family was sick and they needed me. And I feel the same with the Purpose Pledge group, that anything we need, they're gonna help us out. They're gonna jump in. And so, that's really tough to find out there in the world of entrepreneurship. I mean, you can go be like an EO group and You know, one of these groups where you have a CEO mindshare and is like, yeah, they're gonna like help you with some strategy here and there, but at the end of the day, they're focused on their business and you're focused on yours. And no one from their team is really available to anyone on your team. But it really feels like an ecosystem at purpose pledge. And that feels like the biggest piece right now. and down the road, I think purpose capital is gonna be something that will be a huge benefit to purpose pledge companies being able to access patient capital. And hopefully at some point we will be able to leverage our group to make a difference in the market to really shift the system, you know, to be able to go to our retailer and say, Hey retailer, you say you care about companies that were doing regenerative organic and all the and there are purpose-led companies, but what are you doing to support these companies? Can you give us, you know, an end cap where you're highlighting purpose pledge companies? Can you give us like a discount on promotions in the store? Can you bring in purpose pledge companies? Can you like focus and talk to more purpose pledge companies give us shelf space? Like I think there could be a point in time in which that becomes possible as well.

Neil Callanan

I guess the last question I have before we hit our quick fires is in the world today, there's a lot of I would say headwinds for being super aggressive and values-driven, at least on the surface, right? From the political side of things to just the you know, kind of a swing back the other way, on some of the progressive DEI stuff. what would you say to a company or a brand who's getting started, help talk to the folks who are hearing a lot whether from their funding sources or from just the pure market, like, no, actually say less, take less stances, put less energy into being committed to the planet or the thing, sell the thing and get out. how do you think about that today and and how core that is to your business?

Adam Hiner

First off, starting a business whether it's purpose led or not is really, really hard. I mean that's just the the nature of it. It's like this is it's hard work. I've come across some of the biggest challenges of my life many times over in the business. Like I can't tell you many times that I wasn't sure if we were gonna be able to make payroll or, you know, pay our vendors and And been just at the end of my rope many times, just like, what am I gonna do? How am I gonna figure this out? And those challenges are real. I don't know what percentage of businesses that start/fail, but it's a high percentage. And especially when we're taking money from friends and family or, you know, investing our own capital or our life savings, like that could be, you know, that can be really, really tough. And so I just say first off, like Kudos to anyone that's jumping into this in entrepreneurship and willing to risk their time and their money and their livelihood on starting a business. It's it's tough. And you know, really at the end of the day for me, I don't think I would have made it through those challenges if I wasn't doing this based on purpose. Like, when I was in the deepest, darkest places of like running out of money or you know, making tough decisions in the business like having to weigh between one thing or another that really felt like both were needed. I don't think I could have like figured out how to move forward if I wasn't able to like remember, Oh we're doing this for a reason. This matters. Like I can't just walk away from this. I need to do this. The world needs this. And so for me, the like the purpose piece of the business is like the fire. you know, it's like the fire that's in all of us. We all have a fire burning and we can always come back to that. No matter how dark it gets, we can come back to our flame and like we can remember, we can meditate, we can choose to be alive and we can then like spark that fire and and grow again. And so the purpose is our fire in the business. And I think that without it, We're just here for the money. We're just here for the capital return at that point. So back to that business where we're just trying to return capital and we're not thinking about the other stakeholders and then what's the point? So that's how I feel about it.

Neil Callanan

Running a business is really hard. Starting a business is really hard. So you might as well make it like purpose-driven and valuable because it's gonna be hard even if you're not, right? Like there's no easy way to start a thing. That's not real. So like having a motivator that can tie you to get you through the hard parts versus a business that you don't feel passionate about or that you're not super you know committed to or proud of you know those lows get get pretty low and if you don't have the fire as you said the pull yourself through it's like that seems way harder just to go do it and not have any any driver that you're proud of. All right. Well I want to hit some quick fires and then we'll get you out of here. first question what brand do you look up to? And the answer cannot be pedagonia.

Adam Hiner

Well I I'm gonna say Dr. Bronner's because they're just always doing the thing that no one thought that anyone could ever do and be successful at it and they're leading with their their purpose on their sleeve and they're creating like a world where we can all do that together. So, super powerful.

Neil Callanan

We're big fans ourselves over here. What do you wish that you could measure?

Adam Hiner

The first thing that popped into my mind was like was feelings. Like I wish I could measure feelings and you know, words don't really don't do it justice. And I don't think

Neil Callanan

Give me an example.

Adam Hiner

If I asked someone, if they're like, I'm so excited about this, and I'm like, Well, tell me how excited you are and they're like, I'm so excited, but it's like I can feel their feeling, but I I can't measure it in a way that I can put a number to it and maybe it's better that I can't do that, that I have to be able to feel that feeling from them. And that can resonate with me and I can get that excitement, you know, in person. But I can't really I can't really put a number to it. It wouldn't do it justice.

Neil Callanan

Yeah, it's like trying to, quantify something that's inherently unquantifiable, but like the idea of one of the things we do on the agency side is we like went on this exact sort of mission to like have a KPI that was like a feeling driven thing, right? But it's like hard to have that as a business objective. And and basically what we landed at was quantifying the number of "Fuck yeahs" that we have that's just like purely, how many times did we have this feeling of like, fuck yeah, that meeting was great, or that project launched and it was awesome, or we just hired this new person and like we try to have a certain number of those per quarter as our as a measurable. And it's like a very unquantifiable, not scientific thing that would give a, you know, strategic business advisor a panic attack when I said it was one of our KPIs. But I think it works well

Adam Hiner

Ha.

Neil Callanan

in terms of just like it's You know it when you feel it, right? Like you know you're you're creating these emotional moments that you feel and they can be really, really powerful as a as a thing to to try to measure in some form. What do you do to refill your tank when you're gassed and you're in the lows of the entrepreneurial journey? What's do you do to fill yourself back up?

Adam Hiner

I have a few things. I spend time with my little four year old daughter and my wife. I go surfing. I meditate and I do breathwork. Those are probably my top. I play music also. I play guitar and sing.

Neil Callanan

I feel like you just get to s hang out in this current office space that you're in and your temperature's already gonna lower a little bit. You've got very very calm seeming office space, so you're already going in there.

Adam Hiner

Yeah, put a guitar in my hand and I'm happy.

Neil Callanan

Yeah man. what book or podcast do you find yourself recommending most to others?

Adam Hiner

What put the podcast? Well, for me it's always like what's the most recent one that I've been recommending to people because I'm not like

Neil Callanan

That works too.

Adam Hiner

I'm always on the journey. And the most recent book that I've read, which is one of the most powerful books I've ever read, is called The Future is Peace. And it's written by Aziz Abu-Sarah and Maoz Inon, I can't remember his last name. Aziz is Palestinian and Maoz is Israeli and they both lost people in the conflict and they came together and decided to fight for peace instead of fighting for retaliation. And their their book is like a New York Times bestseller. And I cried probably four or five times while reading it and it's just really beautiful and I think that it really shows the path. It feels like to me, I'm I'm actually 50% Palestinian and I do a peace dinner every year at the Ecology Center where I used to be on the board of directors. And I cook that dinner with a brother of mine named Neiv, who is Israeli and so it's like a Palestinian chef and an Israeli chef coming together. And so yeah, reading this book just really felt Like everything aside from that dinner has really felt I felt hopeless in the face of that conflict. And really in the face of all wars that are happening, I've just felt like what what can we do about this? It doesn't feel like we can make a big difference. And so I started doing that dinner because it felt like the only thing I really could do. And then reading this book, it just felt like there's there is hope and that there is a pathway to peace. And we just have to start, you know, one one conversation at a time.

Neil Callanan

yeah. Yeah, as you're speaking there, last season we had the guys at Brewgooder on. Do you Brewgooder at all? They're like a UK brewery. but they are modeling themselves as sort of the Ben & Jerry's of beer but their biggest impact has been in doing a a collab with this Palestinian brewery. and you know sourcing the ingredients from this specific war torn area of sub-Saharan Africa and it's like it's been a real unlock for them in terms of like taking this small little step of like, hey, how can we do our thing? We make beer, how could we make beer that could possibly do anything, you know, impactful? And they were able to sort of find a way to shoehorn their their impact and it's that's really, really neat. okay, this is the most important question. If I were coming to visit in San Diego, where would you send me to get the best sandwich?

Adam Hiner

Best sandwich, oof. Again, I'm always like, what am I where's my spot recently? I right now I'm living in Encinitas when I go into town, so that's where that's where my world is. And there's a place called the GOODONYA Cafe, which is just for me, I'm all about eating good quality sourced food. And so the food is sourced in just incredibly well. No seed oils and everything's made from scratch and their food is really, really tasty and it's, you know, organic and sourced really well and it's made with love. So that place is my go to spot for for food right now when I go out to eat.

Neil Callanan

and what's your order? What's the what's the sandwich to get?

Adam Hiner

Well, actually the burger is what I order typically. Yeah. I don't know what there's sandwich like I'm calling I'm calling it a

Neil Callanan

It's a sandwich. You can qualify that burger can be.

Adam Hiner

sandwich. Yeah, it's the burger for sure.

Neil Callanan

Awesome. Where can people find more about Pacha and follow the work that you guys are doing?

Adam Hiner

So you can go to our website, livepacha.com We have lots of stuff there. You can join our email list. You can get all sorts of fun new special releases that we're, you know, sending out all the time through our email list. And you can follow us on Instagram and you know, Facebook and all those places. That's not my world, but we're definitely on Instagram and Facebook and and other social media outlets as well.

Neil Callanan

Awesome. All right, Adam Hiner is the CEO and co-founder of Pacha. Pacha has been committed to sustainability from the beginning. And its buckwheat comes from Midwest Farms, a partnership that focuses on regenerative agriculture. Pacha's core products are made from sprouted organic buckwheat and sea salt. And you can find them at Sprouts, Whole Foods, and any number of natural food grocery stores. Adam, thanks for joining us, man.

Adam Hiner

Thanks so much for having me. It was a real pleasure.

Get your sandwich

Picked by Adam Hiner

The burger

GOODONYA

1051 S Coast Highway 101, Encinitas, CA