Certifying Action Over Hopes & Dreams with Austin Whitman (The Change Climate Project) artwork

Certifying Action Over Hopes & Dreams Why The Change Climate Project Certifies Spending, Not Pledges

Austin Whitman, CEO & Co-Founder, The Change Climate Project

· 48 min

Summary

Austin Whitman, CEO and co-founder of The Change Climate Project, the nonprofit behind The Climate Label, explained why it certifies companies on money they have already spent on decarbonization rather than on climate pledges for 2050.

Each company multiplies its emissions by a carbon price, $15 per ton this year, and must show it has already spent at least that much; in the first year, certified companies averaged $22 per ton.

The Climate Label's results show that a hard, comparable number reveals who is following through, in a way a pledge cannot.

Watch the episode

Questions answered

How do you measure whether a company is following through on its climate commitments?

Measure the money a company has already spent, said Austin Whitman, CEO and co-founder of The Change Climate Project. To earn The Climate Label, a company must show it has spent at least a set price per ton of its emissions on decarbonization. The company measures its emissions across its operations and value chain and multiplies them by the standard's carbon price, $15 per ton this year, to get what the organization calls a climate transition budget. Qualifying spending can include carbon credits, low-carbon ingredients or inputs, and renewable energy. The test is simply whether the money has gone out the door.

Most climate claims center on targets instead. The organization does not certify hopes and dreams, and Whitman pointed out that many companies promising results by 2050 may not exist in their current form by then. Dollars per ton is a useful yardstick, both within the label's community and for comparing other companies' stated climate investment with their emissions. Asked what he wished he could measure, he named every company's funding for climate solutions, because companies say a lot about climate and he wants to see what they are doing.

Why have carbon neutral claims lost credibility?

Neutrality claims lost value because many companies made them using low-quality carbon credits or by counting only a small fraction of their emissions, and governments began to regulate or restrict them. The Change Climate Project, founded in 2019 as Climate Neutral, had spent 2019 to 2023 setting higher rules for neutrality claims. Other companies' weaker claims watered down the value of the claim, which in turn reduced the value of the certification even for companies that met the higher standard.

The second reason came from inside certified companies. One example is a company that spends $300,000 on carbon credits one year and $320,000 the next, until its CFO asks whether that money could be reinvested in ways that measurably cut the company's own emissions. The team spent the better part of two years talking with hundreds of people in its partner and stakeholder networks before landing on a simpler mechanism: a price on every ton of a company's footprint, which the company can spend on internal projects as well as carbon credits.

How do you set a measurement standard that is demanding but still achievable?

Setting the standard is an art more than a science, so The Change Climate Project reviews it every year and debates it one requirement at a time rather than looking for one rule that settles everything. One example is whether a company must spend a minimum of 10% or 20% of its budget on projects in its own value chain, so that out of $100,000, at least $10,000 or $20,000 goes to decarbonizing its own operations. The team weighs different viewpoints and what will grow the community rather than restrict it. In Whitman's view, the climate movement is still overweighted on complexity and short on action.

The $15 per ton price came out of days of deliberation. In the first year, certified companies funded an average of $22 per ton of climate projects, about 50% above the threshold, though some struggled to reach $15. Being able to show that the community beat its own metric by about 50% was meaningful, and the same number lets the organization see which companies are reaching $30, $40 or $50 per ton.

How should brands talk about climate action to mainstream consumers?

Brands should keep talking about climate, but through specific actions, because mainstream shoppers give it very little attention. The Change Climate Project uses the archetype of Sally in Peoria, who might give climate 45 seconds to a minute a week. The Climate Label's job is to tell her, in a split second on a shelf or a website, that the product is better for the climate. The detailed data still matters for media, NGOs and regulators. The certification was recently assessed against the EU's Empowering Consumers for the Green Transition rules, and only a few small gaps had to be closed.

The research the organization draws on shows consumers do not want to hear about a climate crisis, or a platitude that the company has it covered. They respond to concrete actions, such as buying clean energy for 100% of the energy used to make products, and to how projects benefit them and their families. Brands can focus on the roughly 75% of Americans who see climate change as a real issue rather than trying to convince the rest. To help, the organization launched the free Climate Claims Checker, which rates text or a URL on how risky and how effective its climate language is.

Why does sustainability work get lost before it reaches marketing?

What gets lost is opportunity, Whitman said: sustainability teams often struggle to get their work onto the marketing calendar or to find climate expertise on the marketing team. Sustainability began as a PR and marketing function and has since moved into product, design and innovation. Some brands' sustainability teams do excellent work yet quote two-to-three-year roadmaps before The Climate Label can be featured to consumers, because product merchandisers and marketers must first agree it helps the brand. Neil argued that marketing can be one of sustainability's biggest amplifiers, and that brands often see stronger engagement when they speak up.

Key takeaways

  • To earn The Climate Label, a company measures its emissions across its operations and value chain and multiplies them by the standard's carbon price, $15 per ton this year. The result is its climate transition budget, and it must show it has already spent at least that much on decarbonization.
  • In the first year of the dollars-per-ton standard, certified companies funded an average of $22 per ton of climate projects, about 50% above the $15 threshold, though some companies struggled to reach $15.
  • The organization, founded in 2019 as Climate Neutral, moved away from carbon neutrality claims in 2023 after low-quality neutrality claims elsewhere led governments to restrict them, and after certified companies' CFOs questioned paying for carbon credits year after year instead of cutting their own emissions.
  • Qualifying spending can include carbon credits, low-carbon ingredients or inputs, and renewable energy. Each year the standard is reviewed requirement by requirement, for example whether a minimum of 10% or 20% of the budget must go to projects in a company's own value chain.
  • The Change Climate Project's archetype of the mainstream shopper, Sally in Peoria, gives climate perhaps 45 seconds to a minute a week, so the label has to signal 'better for the climate' in a split second while the detailed data serves media, NGOs and regulators.
  • Consumers do not want to hear about a climate crisis or a company saying it has climate covered, according to the research The Change Climate Project draws on. They respond to specific actions, such as buying clean energy for 100% of the energy used to make products, and the organization's free Climate Claims Checker rates climate language on risk and effectiveness.
  • Some brands' sustainability teams do excellent work but quote two-to-three-year roadmaps before their certification can be featured to consumers, because merchandisers and marketers first have to agree it will help the brand.

Quotes

To get certified, a company has to show us that they have already spent money on decarbonization projects at least equal to that climate transition budget.

Austin Whitman

We're still way overweighted on complexity across the movement and there's not enough action.

Austin Whitman

Consumers don't want to be told by a company that there's this climate crisis, but don't worry, we got it covered.

Austin Whitman

I'd love ... for every company out there to be disclosing ... what money they're putting into decarbonization. They're saying a lot. What are they doing?

Austin Whitman

Frequently asked questions

What is a carbon credit?

A carbon credit works like paying for electricity: you pay a utility for each kilowatt hour, and with a carbon credit you pay a company that is reducing, avoiding or removing emissions for each ton. Those companies run projects ranging from reforestation to energy efficiency and clean energy.

Do shoppers understand carbon numbers on products?

The Change Climate Project does not expect them to. It does not expect consumers to judge whether $15 per ton or 3.6 kilograms of carbon per shirt is meaningful, or carbon content to become like nutrition facts. A label's job is to tell a shopper in a split second that a product is better for the climate.

Should a brand try to convince people who doubt climate change?

No, in Austin Whitman's view. He put people who do not see climate change as a threat at about 25% of the US population, and said companies should aim their marketing at the 75% who see a real issue, many of whom swing depending on how the issue is presented to them.

What is The Climate Label?

The Climate Label is a certification run by the nonprofit The Change Climate Project. It shows that a company has measured its emissions and already spent at least a set price per ton of those emissions, its climate transition budget, on decarbonization, rather than only pledging future reductions.

What does The Change Climate Project do?

The Change Climate Project is a nonprofit, co-founded by Austin Whitman in 2019 as Climate Neutral, whose mission is to decarbonize the world by accelerating the climate initiatives of consumer brands. It runs The Climate Label certification and offers training, tools such as the free Climate Claims Checker, community and a volunteer network to help companies decarbonize.

About the guest

Austin Whitman is CEO and co-founder of The Change Climate Project, the nonprofit behind The Climate Label. He co-founded it in 2019 as Climate Neutral, with Jonathan Cedar of BioLite and Peter Dering of Peak Design, and led its move from Climate Neutral Certified to The Climate Label. He has spent more than two decades building markets for clean energy, energy efficiency, carbon credits and ecosystem services, including as a vice president at Climate Change Capital and at M.J. Bradley & Associates. He holds a joint MBA and Master of Environmental Management from Yale and a BA in English from Dartmouth.

About this episode

For our 2nd episode of Season 2, Neil is joined by Austin Whitman, CEO and co-founder of The Change Climate Project, the nonprofit behind The Climate Label and the Business Emissions Evaluator.

Austin has spent more than two decades building markets for clean energy and carbon, including a stint selling carbon credits to spring breakers in grad school. He co-founded the organization in 2019 as Climate Neutral, alongside Jonathan Cedar of BioLite and Peter Dering of Peak Design (who joined us in Season 1). They dive into why Austin’s team doesn’t certify “hopes and dreams,” and what it means to measure money already spent instead of a pledge for 2050.

Take a listen to learn what most brands get wrong when marketing their climate impact, plus what gets lost between a sustainability team doing excellent work and a marketing team that never hears about it.

Transcript

Read the full transcript

Neil Callanan

Today on Measured Impact, we are joined by Austin Whitman, CEO and co-founder of the Change Climate Project, the nonprofit behind the climate label and the business emissions evaluator. Austin spent more than two decades building markets for clean energy and carbon. In 2019, he co-founded what was then called climate neutral with Jonathan Cedar of BioLight and Peter Dering of Peak Design. Shout out, Peter, joined us in season one. When 2023 studies showed that consumers were losing faith in carbon neutral claims, Austin and his team didn't defend the old model. Rather, they rebuilt it around corporate funding with a low carbon transmission rather than carbon neutrality. Today we're talking with Austin about measuring follow-through instead of promises. Why putting a price tag on every ton changes how companies behave and how to keep climate claims credible while many brands go quiet. Let's dive in. Austin, welcome man.

Austin Whitman

Thanks, Neil. It's great to be with you.

Neil Callanan

So I like to start with an easy one, which is who are you? Where do you live and who do you work with?

Austin Whitman

I'm Austin, as you just provided in the introduction. I'm a girl dad, live in Boston, and I work for a small nonprofit, which I've been with since the beginning and continue to try to drive this movement forward.

Neil Callanan

Are you a Bostonite originally or where are you from?

Austin Whitman

not originally. Yeah. I thought you were just gonna end the question with, Are you a Bostonite? And I was gonna say that's a very, very difficult question and complex question.

Neil Callanan

Yeah.

Austin Whitman

I grew up in Philadelphia. I don't consider myself a Philly guy. I live in Boston and I've lived here for more than twenty years. I don't consider myself a Boston guy. I don't really know where I consider myself to be from. but I do love New England.

Neil Callanan

Yeah, the Bostonites, the New Englanders, they're very welcoming, but they're not quick to call you one of their own. You're gonna you're gonna need another 50 or a 100 years before they

Austin Whitman

No, people are nice around here. That's for sure. That's for sure. and I think people who visit Boston love the history and love the scenery and certain times of the year they love the weather, but they don't love the people.

Neil Callanan

So, tell us a little bit, high-level, about the Change Climate Project. You know, kind of just give us the 30,000 foot view before we dive in too deep.

Austin Whitman

Yeah, we are a small nonprofit organization that has a mission to decarbonize the world by accelerating the climate initiatives of consumer brands. And we do that by administering a certification. You can think of it kind of like an organic label, but for carbon. A certification lives on products and in companies marketing, and it's The symbol that a company has been through our certification process, which I'm sure we'll dig into. and then in the course of kind of setting up the certification, we realized that most companies, especially small and medium-sized companies, we're talking companies, let's say less than two billion in revenues, have this idea that they're supposed to be doing something good for the climate with their business. They should be decarbonizing somehow, but so many companies don't know how to do that. And so in the course of running the certification, we've discovered that there are a lot of other opportunities to accelerate progress just by providing knowledge and training and tools and community. we have an incredible volunteer network that works with companies. so basically to try to make the whole thing easier for companies, because without that, we would be a lot, lot I guess I'll say we wouldn't be anywhere near as as far along as we are.

Neil Callanan

So I hear, via our research team, that back in grad school you were selling carbon credits to students who were heading to spring break abroad. tell me about that and how and why a grad student would go down that route?

Austin Whitman

Yeah, that's a real throwback. we actually did a few different things. We did we did the spring break carbon credit program. We also did a carbon neutral graduation program. So everybody whose families came into town, you know, could buy carbon credits. It was honestly this is we're talking 2005, 2006, and it was really pretty early on in the formation of what we know now as carbon markets and carbon offsetting and carbon credits. But, the instruments that were being created at that time and and continue to exist are really just kind of a different flavor of a type of system and type of mechanism that had been created in the 1990's under federal policy. That was back when the federal government cared about the environment. Those were the good days, and so, when we sort of had this opportunity to try to mitigate some of the impact of folks traveling around the world, it seemed like a no-brainer to everybody. And it actually felt a little bit like a transformational moment that people more broadly were going to start to see that there are efficient ways to drive money into good things happening in the world that are going to reduce emissions. so yeah, that was a fun little Fun little project that we did for a couple of years and I sort of got out of carbon markets, let's say in 2010 or 2011. And to come back to it eight years later was a little bit like Twilight Zone because so many of the same things that we were dealing with in 2005 were actually still big issues in 2018.

Neil Callanan

I imagine you were very popular with the other spring breakers who were like, I'm just trying to get to Cabo, man,

Austin Whitman

I I went to a business school that had lots of very thoughtful people. I also went to a forestry school where of course everybody cared about the environment. So believe it or not, we were actually seen as kind of the cool people on campus

Neil Callanan

Awesome. That's such a cool story. I think it would be helpful for the context of this conversation because, You know, I think that general idea of carbon credits and carbon, markets, I'd guess there's a large portion of the audience who doesn't really understand what that even means. So at a really high level, How do you describe it to somebody who is new to the concept of like what exactly is the mechanism as you guys think about sort of decarbonization?

Austin Whitman

Sure. I'll start with something that people do know, which is when you want power to come into your home, you have a company. It's generally called a utility, sometimes it's called an energy provider, and you sign a contract with them and they send electricity to your house, and then you pay them for that electricity. And you pay them for this unit that you probably don't understand, which is called a kilowatt hour. Carbon credits at some level are no different than that. There's a company somewhere doing something that you don't really understand or know about, and they sell you this thing denominated in a in the case of a carbon credit, it's it's a ton rather than a kilowatt hour. And you you pay them for that service. So the carbon markets generally have formed around the understanding that there are many entities out there in the world that are working on ways to decarbonize the global economy and also to to remove carbon from the atmosphere. And those entities are often disconnected, i.e., not integrated with, you know, disconnected from people and companies that are trying to decarbonize or want to use their money to decarbonize in some way. And the market brings those two together. So it can be a union of a company that has made a neutrality claim or a net zero claim and they're looking for projects to support. It can be an individual who wants to pay a monthly subscription fee to somehow offset their carbon. But fundamentally, what the companies out in the ether are doing runs the gamut from reforestation to energy efficiency to clean energy, project development, and on and on and on. There's lots of different ways to create a carbon credit, but these are companies who are doing something that is either reducing or avoiding a ton of carbon emissions and then selling that benefit on to somebody who wants to buy.

Neil Callanan

Thanks for breaking it down for us in a one-on-one sense. I note that you guys sort of started as literally climate neutral and then moved away from the "neutral" as a claim. So obviously that was intentional. and you know, in this show we talk a lot about what is measured that can help make decisions. So more than just what was behind that thinking, I'm curious as to what you measured or what feedback you got, data you saw, information that was in the you know, the insights that were coming in that helped you make that decision to evolve?

Austin Whitman

Yeah, we we started as climate neutral, which was essentially a decision to put ourselves at the head of a kind of an amorphous movement that really has existed for or had existed for decades, where as soon as people realized that there was a desire to kind of balance the ledger, so I have emissions and I wanna offset them, the result would be neutrality. And that concept became, the word movement is maybe overstating what it actually became, but people people became more familiar with the concept of neutralizing or neutrality. And so when we started the organization, we made a deliberate decision to sort of be there creating better rules and a higher standard for the neutrality movement. And that is what we did from 2019 through 2023. But what started to happen in 2023 was two things. One, we continued to see many companies out in the world make neutrality promises or neutrality claims that frankly didn't go anywhere near as far as they should, often because the way that they're achieving neutrality was through really low quality carbon credits, Or they were only counting a certain small fraction of their emissions. And so those companies were continuing to make these claims, which watered down the value of that claim, which meant, you know, and they and they weren't doing our certification, but it meant that our certification had less value because neutrality was seen as not a very good thing. And because it was seen as not a very good thing, a lot of governments really started to pay attention to those types of claims and in some cases actually pass regulation. That would restrict or prevent companies from making those claims. So that was the first thing, it was a policy shift. The second thing was that companies in the course of getting our certification would increase their budgets for decarbonization. So I'm a company that, you know, that in 2020 never did anything on climate. In 2021, I got climate neutral certified And I spent $300,000 on carbon credits. In 2022, I spent $320,000 on carbon credits because my emissions increased a little bit, or because the price of carbon credits increased a little bit. In 2023 or 2024, my CFO came to me and said, Why are we spending $300,000 or $320,000 on carbon credits? Isn't there something else we can do with this money? And what we found is basically companies were really Interested in finding ways to use that money to reinvest back in the business in ways that would measurably reduce their own emissions, but wouldn't look like this year after year after year cash drain to the CFO. And so recognizing those two things, the regulatory shift and this real sort of shift in how companies were thinking about their climate strategy, we decided that we would go through what turned out to be a very, very long and intensive process that took the better part of two years talking to literally hundreds of people in our partner network and stakeholder network, trying to figure out a mechanism that would improve on what we had and capture new opportunities and respond to what we were hearing from companies. And ultimately we landed on something that's very simple, which is we have a certification now that puts a price on carbon emissions. So if you have a carbon inventory or a carbon footprint of 10,000 tons, we basically put a price on those 10,000 tons. Every ton gets a price, and then the total amount becomes what we call a climate transition budget. And that's an amount that you're required to spend, not on not just on carbon credits, but on internal projects as well.

Neil Callanan

So, Sounds like, one of the challenges in that, And we're we're talking with a lot of folks who are thinking about creative ways to measure their impact and, you know, decide on the data points that are gonna be most informative. So, When you guys were going through this process to to find this mechanism, how do you balance complexity with measurability and actionability and authenticity, right? It could get pretty complex very fast in terms of how you would choose to measure a footprint or measure activity that quantifies as as reducing that carbon footprint. So, how do you guys think about balancing creating a framework and a mechanism to do that, that is both comprehensive but also not so complex that it becomes more onerous than you can get people to buy into?

Austin Whitman

Yeah, yeah. it it's an art more than a science. we look at the standard, which is our set of rules for certification, every year, And every year we consider whether it needs changes. And we end up trying to answer the question that you just asked down at the level of individual requirements in the standard. So it's much easier to take your question and answer it if we're looking at something like, Should companies be required to spend a minimum of their funding requirement that's equal to 10% versus 20% going into projects within their value chain? That's one of the parameters that's in our standard. In other words, if I have $100,000 that I need to spend on climate solutions to get certified, should we, the certifier, require them to spend A minimum of 10,000 or 20,000 of that on value chain projects? And there's all kinds of reasons why that's significant, but long and short, we we do want companies investing in their own operations so that they can decarbonize. Not all companies find that particularly easy, so we want to sort of have this minimum threshold. It's always a debate. We always try to weigh different viewpoints, and take into account what we think is going to grow the community as opposed to restrict its growth. But, I think it's pretty rare for us to come across somebody who looks at our requirements and our standard and says, you guys aren't doing enough. It's not stringent enough. It's not complex enough. And I think the reason is that nobody can look out at the progress that companies are making on climate and say, it looks great.

Neil Callanan

We're done.

Austin Whitman

We're there. You know, we figured it all out. Basically, right now, if you look at the at the scale balance between complexity and action, we're still way overweighted on complexity across the movement and there's not enough action. And that's always been a conversation for us since the beginning is what is the right place to set the bar so that we can get more action, but also make sure that that action is meaningful? And like I said, it's an art, not a science, and it's always easier to take individual components of the standard as opposed to answering it with one that answers it all.

Neil Callanan

I've spoken with lot of folks in this space in the last year or so and in a world where I think there's some downward pressure on brands to kinda say a little bit less and, you know, generally rollback in ESG and rollback in DEI and you know, anything too progressive, right? There's there's that tendency for there to be a slight corporate rollback or a massive corporate rollback. I also think there has been some pushback in terms of the validity to some of the claims that have been expoused by any number of brands and potentially the people who are enabling those claims, right? Like, hey, we reduced our footprint by whatever, or we committed this, but know, the thing that comes to mind is the aspiration fallout with the Clippers and Kawhi Leonard and they were planting trees that didn't exist and Steve Ballmer claiming, giant reduction in waste for trees that didn't get planted and whatever, a whole thing. Each time consumers or policymakers experience something like that, I'm curious how much time you think about the macro state of all this stuff, and if you guys have a role to play in the trust and accountability and legitimacy, or it's sort of like we just have to keep doing our thing and doing it well and believe in our path. And there's always going to be people who who do it in a disingenuous way.

Austin Whitman

Yeah, none of this is is is easy. It's it's a lot more complicated than many markets and many movements and you know, we are sort of at the intersection of commerce and social movement and norm shifting and All kinds of really difficult things. We definitely feel ourselves part of the broader landscape when it comes to sort of public sentiment on carbon credits and climate action generally. I spent a lot of time in the first three, two, three years just talking to people about the carbon markets and having conversations about you know how should carbon credits be used by companies and what is a quality carbon credit versus a high quality carbon credit versus a low quality one? And just trying to explain to people what what carbon markets were. So in that sense, then I participated a lot in just like general shaping of people's opinions and attitudes toward carbon credits. So that's one piece of it. The other piece is of course what companies are doing with those credits and what kinds of claims that they're making. So we have also over the years spent a lot of time talking about what we think constitutes a high quality claim from a company. The climate movement, if that means anything to people, the collection of entities and media and all the swirl of discourse on what companies should be doing about climate, had agreed, that targets, like what you're gonna do in 30 years, is a really meaningful thing. And we've always disagreed with that notion, that it's important to have a long-term goal, but that's not indicative of what you're doing now. And so We've always really had a hard time with the claims that companies are making about what they're going to achieve by 2050. Because most of those companies are probably not going to be around, at least in their current form. So are they Which which is which

Neil Callanan

That's what they can make whatever claim they want, man. you just

Austin Whitman

is precisely right. And and that I think so so then I'm gonna to go to the go to the next thing which you said, which is how does all of this affect us? And do we feel like we need to continue to stand up for what high integrity looks like? And yes, we do, but unfortunately, I think that one of the many, many factors that has contributed to the downswing in climate politics is the fact that people got disillusioned really quickly. In part because there's so much bad acting out there or disingenuous acting that if someone comes along and says, climate's a problem, You'll say, okay, I agree with that. We need to find solutions. Okay, I agree with that. I found solutions and I'm going to enact them in the next 30 years. Then you're you start to get a little bit skeptical. And the more you see of that, the less you end up believing that there's really anything that we can do about this whole challenge. And I think that, along with many, many, many other complex political things, has changed how people think about the climate space. so markedly from when we launched and even from 2022, 2023, that I could show you a dozen indicators if you want to talk about measuring impact, a dozen indicators from the broader trends and demographic data and sentiment data that shows just how much the climate space has has lost political momentum in the last 3-4 years.

Neil Callanan

My favorite line we found from your your team says that you guys don't certify hopes and dreams. so talk a little bit about the disparity or the differences between measuring follow-through versus measuring a pledge to do a thing.

Austin Whitman

Yeah, this has been something that we've we've had as part of our standard ever since the beginning. and but it's it's really easy to describe in the context of the certification and the standard the way it is today, because it's a $1 per ton standard. And so, when we certify a company, we have them measure their carbon emissions across their operations and then in their value chain. And the number that comes out of that gets multiplied by our Carbon price, which we have in our standard, which this year is $15 per ton. And as I said before, the resulting amount, you know, the emissions x the carbon price, equals what we call a climate transition budget. To get certified, a company has to show us that they have already spent money on decarbonization projects at least equal to that climate transition budget. So, there's kind of nothing more direct and immediate than is the money getting spent, has it has it gone out the door? And that is where we think we sort of depart very sharply from targets and pledges because what we're asking companies to do is just demonstrate that they have spent money to fund projects that will reduce emissions or already have reduced emissions. And those projects can include carbon credits. They can also include the purchase of low carbon ingredients or inputs into their products. They can include the purchase of renewable energy. there's a whole long list of things that is on our website, and I won't go through all of it right now, but there's a lot of stuff that companies can do to decarbonize. But the purpose of this mechanism of $ per ton is for us to really be able to say, did you spend that much money to decarbonize or not? And what was interesting is, this gets a little bit to your question of what is what's a what's a bar that's too high that people won't meet it versus too low that it's not meaningful? is we set the number at $15 per ton with days and days of deliberation, but ultimately felt like that was the right number. And in the first year found that companies on average had funded $22 per ton of climate projects. So they within our community, We're actually investing above the threshold that we set. Wasn't true for everybody. Some were struggling to hit the 15. But it was really nice to see that companies on average were reaching $22 per ton. But even just having that ability to say, all right, our metric is 15 and you've exceeded it by about 50%. That's really meaningful. And then we can we can even sort of go further and say which companies are doing $30 or $40 or $50 per ton. And then outside of our community, what do other companies look like on that same metric? Right? So if I looked at Microsoft and Google and what their climate programs look like in terms of the money that they say that they're investing in decarbonization versus their emissions, what do their $ per ton numbers look like? So, it's a very, very useful yardstick. And We've found it to be a great indicator of sort of what's happening now versus the hopes and dreams that companies say that they're going to achieve in the next 50 years.

Neil Callanan

We talk a lot about glamour metrics a lot of times from a data sense. but it strikes me as the hopes and dreams and the pledges are sort of the glamour metrics of like, yes, you can all pledge to do a bunch of things, but if you can't turn that into action and then quantify that action, it doesn't really mean a whole lot. I wanna shift a little bit to communication and to narratives and kind of the storytelling of it all, 'cause that's what a lot of folks in our audience spend a lot of their time thinking about in terms of impact. So last year, I note you guys certified brands invested $22M in climate action in 2025, Can the everyday consumer understand those metrics in a way that they can connect to, or you know, is there a narrative or a way that you guys think about making that impact approachable to the everyday consumer, who's trying to make a buying decision about this versus that and maybe this is a very small factor in that decision?

Austin Whitman

Yeah. we don't ever expect consumers to understand whether $15 per ton is meaningful or whether 3.6 kilograms of carbon per shirt that they buy is a meaningful number. We don't ever expect that carbon content will become like nutrition facts. And that's a view that we've held since the beginning. And I continue to see that, all the data that's consumers are busy, they're just not going to care. We have had this archetype of Sally and Peoria. and Sally and Peoria is like the average consumer, right? There may be somebody who's deep down diehard green, living in Boulder, who we'll spend enough time to get skilled on the ways of, figuring out what an appropriate carbon content would be for a certain thing that they buy. But Sally and Peoria is never gonna care. So so if we're talking about the mainstream consumer, let's think about what Sally thinks about. and the answer is that even if she cares about the climate, the most that we can probably expect from her is 45 seconds a week, maybe maybe a minute per week. and that is just like the split-second decision when she's reaching for something on a shelf or shopping at a website, that if something is stamped with or branded with the climate label, we want her to say that's a positive thing for the climate. And because of that, that product is better aligned with my values and the things that I want to support. So I'm gonna buy that product and not this other product here. we we do know that it's important to have all the data behind the scenes. So there are other stakeholders. Maybe Sally, you know, goes to school one day and decides to become an expert in carbon accounting. Seems unlikely. But if she does, we want her to come be able to come to our website and understand all the things that went into the certification that is behind that stamp that's on that product. but there are other stakeholders, Whether it's media or other NGOs or regulators who increasingly are demanding more of companies, and we want them to feel confident in our certification. So we just went through a process to achieve compliance against a new law in the EU, which is called Empowering Consumers for the Green Transition. They're light years ahead on the regulatory side of where we are in the US. But they have all these new rules about what companies can and cannot do to market their environmental performance. Then we had to go through a process of determining whether our certification is compliant with ECGT. and it was actually pretty easy because we're so great and we've done our homework and we've been working for years on all the things that they care about. and yeah, I do mean to boast. I mean, we've we've really spent a lot of time being thoughtful about what goes into the standard and how we present it to the outside world and how transparent it is and all those things. So it was really nice to see just a few small gaps that we needed to close in order to achieve that. and that I think is, you know, it's important for consumers to feel like the the things that they see out there in the world are not just arbitrary, but they're actually well designed.

Neil Callanan

I guess my follow on to that is you're working with brands and these brands are making a commitment, or demonstrating a commitment rather, towards a specific set of criteria to meet this label. When you guys are speaking to those partners, should a brand be communicating this climate pledge as part of their ongoing marketing efforts and how regularly should they think about talking to that audience, even if that audience might be mostly Sally's and Peoria?

Austin Whitman

Yeah. there is a lot of really good research on what people want to hear and don't want to hear about the climate these days. it's not research that we've done because we don't have that capacity, but a lot of really interesting data that's looked at what voters think about the climate and then also just what individuals who are buying things, who are choosing what companies to support. And Ultimately, I won't try to summarize every last bit of it, but ultimately what we what we know is that even Sally is about 70-75% likely to care about the climate. And even Sally wants to understand at a pretty specific level what a company is doing about its carbon emissions. And from there, What you say to her is really important, and how you say it is really important. And so I guess I'll answer your question: should companies be talking about climate? Absolutely, yes, but only if they're doing it in the right way, in a way that is both clear and has integrity, and also is effective with their audience. Because what we know is that consumers don't want to be told by A company that there's this climate crisis, but don't worry, we got it covered. That's problematic in two ways. One, consumers don't want to hear about a climate crisis. We know that from the research. And two, consumers don't want to see this platitude from a company. Hey, we got it covered. So both sides of that statement are wrong. what consumers do want to know about is the very specific things, the ways in which companies are transitioning their business for this world that we all want to live in, which is low carbon and where things are made without destroying the planet. And so the more a company can get down to the granular details and say in 2025 or 2026, we bought clean energy for 100% of the energy that's used in making our products. That's actually pretty meaningful to consumers. they also want to be told how the projects that companies are doing are benefiting them directly. and benefiting their families. So, there are lots of great research studies that are up to date on how people are feeling in this moment as opposed to three or four years ago. and what we try to get companies to do is to take all of that into account. I would say how that gets translated once it's once it's taken from the sustainability person through to the marketing person and the comms person. it usually falls apart. And so there aren't very many companies who do a great job of climate marketing because of course climate is just a tiny piece of what companies are trying to market overall. But this is one reason why this week, literally Tuesday this week, we launched a new tool we call the Climate Claims Checker. And it allows a company to put text or a URL into a tool and have the tool spit back to you its assessment of how risky that language is and also how effective it is. on a two axis evaluation. And and the point of this is to show companies that a lot of what they're saying may not be connected to the things that they're actually doing. And that's that's wrong. And then a lot of the messaging might be too general and not specific enough and that's ineffective. And so, we put that tool out there. it's free as on our website. people can use it to check out how they're doing. But our goal is to is to make it still okay to talk about the climate. We don't want people to stop talking about the climate, but we want them to talk about the climate and their own work in a very specific way.

Neil Callanan

So we speak with a lot of brands both on this podcast and also, in our our agency work where, I would say it's oftentimes downward pressure, from a board or from an executive, to say less, right? And so in a lot of the ways you've just been describing this, there is a few assumptions that are contained in there, meaning like we can all agree that there's a climate emergency or that there's a problem and climate and carbon is an aspect of that. Where do you think about the folks who don't agree with that principally as a whole, and whether brands that you are working with should spend energy communicating about the climate crisis or about The sort of urgency or about the the state of things today, versus saying, the people who we're targeting and the Sally's of the world, there's a Sally who believes climate change is real, and there's a Sally who believes that the earth is getting warmer. There's a Sally who doesn't. do you think that your brands are speaking to both? Or is is at this point we are sort of saying our impact is going to come from enabling the brands and the folks who support those brands who are already in this understanding that there's a a problem to be solved?

Austin Whitman

Yeah. Well we don't we don't need to worry about folks who don't believe in climate change and don't think that climate change is a threat. because they're 25% of the total population in the US and certainly less globally. there's enough of a market opportunity focusing on the folks who do care. So let's look at the other 75% of those, not all of them are going to respond to the kind of messaging that you and I might respond to, which is like, we're all in, you know, we believe this down to our core. They're going to be a lot more, they're swing voters, right? I mean, literally and figuratively. And in this particular issue, they're going to swing back and forth between, yeah, I'm I I I'm going to do something about this issue or I'm not. And whether they're feeling like they're going to do something or not. largely has to do with how the issue is presented to them. and if it's if it's presented in a way that either offends their politics or just doesn't resonate with them, then then they're not going to feel particularly motivated. So I think companies companies know better than anybody how to market and message to their audiences. I don't think any company's job is to convince people that climate change is real. like I said, I think that, you know, focus on the 75% who believe that it's real. I think company's jobs is to like to use the full power of their marketing capacity. I mean, the incredible amount of money that goes into marketing and the incredibly talented people who do do corporate marketing and figure out a way to get these messages across in ways that resonate with the share of the 75% for whom it's not a slam dunk, but who do believe that there's a real issue.

Neil Callanan

Yeah. Yeah, I love the way that you frame that. And I think, you know, the reality is from a pure business standpoint, I actually think there's a lot of folks who do feel like they have to talk to 100% of people because that's the biggest market share, right? And I think there's a lot of brands who Everybody on the team believes in the legitimacy and maybe everybody who wants to market the things believe in the legitimacy, but there's somebody somewhere who's saying, Yeah, but we can't be exclusive of this this group. And you know, my take is always like you kind of can because your 75% of people are plenty of people to to help you run a profitable business and a sustainable business. I think one of the things that you hit on that I'm hoping you can expand on it a little bit, there's a little bit of a siloed nature, right? Meaning maybe there's a sustainability team or maybe there's a team above that team whose job it is to focus on all the macro sense of impact. And then there might be three or four silos before it gets to marketers who message that to the consumer. And I think there's a lot of things that can get lost in the mix. Maybe the value of it in either direction or or even the understanding of it. My goal has always been to help the sustainability folks realize that marketing can be one of their biggest tools to amplify the energy that they're creating around these these causes. But I'm interested in hearing what drives you to think that those silos happen and if you have any examples of sort of like how does that actually play itself out in the wild where maybe you guys are working with a sustainability focused team and There's not any marketers or communicators who are part of your whole process from their side. What what's lost in those those steps?

Austin Whitman

Opportunity. Opportunity to get the full value of certification to be realized. it's ironic because sustainability was created as a marketing function back in the day. It was created as a PR and marketing function, and it's fortunately become increasingly integrated within product and design and innovation, as opposed to just being a a mouthpiece. but I say ironic because now we do see a lot of cases where sustainability struggles to get the support and kind of the struggles to get on the marketing calendar, struggles to get the support from the marketing team, the comprehension from the marketing team, which doesn't always have anything close to the technical expertise on climate that we'd like them to. and and where we've seen this play out, I won't name brand names specifically, but cases where the sustainability teams are doing absolutely amazing work. And we ask them about how we can get them to put the certification forward more directly to their consumer, we're given like 2-3 year roadmaps. Because That's how long it'll take for them to get the product merchandisers and the marketing teams and everyone else aligned around the idea that the brand identity or the product marketing will benefit from having the climate attributes and the and the climate projects more directly featured. And again, feels like a big missed opportunity to me because We do know that consumers want to hear about what companies are doing about the climate. And yet there's this resistance and this friction internally connecting from the best sustainability work, all the way down through the consumer.

Neil Callanan

Yeah. Yeah, we spend a lot of time on LooseGrip on the agency side helping brands with this discussion and the process. And I would say you know, the thing from my standpoint that gets folks over that hump is the quick connection to the sustainability messaging and content and creative. And if you have a sophisticated marketing attribution or insights program, we generally actually see that there's not a nice to have, there's a direct line to like people are more engaged with the brands when they speak up and they speak out loud, right? And you know, we can say on the surface, in reality, when Ben & Jerry's posts about systemic racism, they actually also sell more Ice cream the next day, right? those things

Austin Whitman

Mm. Yeah.

Neil Callanan

are not mutually exclusive. And so, before we jump to our speed round, I just wanna kinda double click on that and say my take is that most brands will have more impact if they talk about their impact on their bottom line. and whether that's sustainability or some progressive advocacy, I think most consumers really want to like be engaged with brands who you know, we we speak with our dollars, right? we talked about Sally and Peoria. I think Sally also wants to feel like the items she's purchasing are representing who she wants to be, right? She's making purchases, decisions that speak to her consciousness about a specific thing. And maybe that's not a huge ask. That doesn't mean she's bought an EV and stopped flying, but it can mean that she's taking a small step. And I think that that can be a really powerful sort of brand attribute that a lot of time that disconnect between The sustainability folks don't want to talk about it in terms of what it can drive for profits and the marketers don't want to talk about profits and how they're tied to sustainability. And there's there's just a think a natural tendency to keep those things separate that is not always beneficial for either side, honestly.

Austin Whitman

Yeah, I think that's right. we haven't talked about how old Sally is and it's possible that Sally might be 60 or 65 or 70 and her spending is really, trending down. Sally could also be 20 And if Sally's 20 she definitely cares about the personality, the people behind the brand that she's supporting. And I think you you mentioned, Peak Design. And just to give them a shout out, and Samsonite, which also makes similar, categorically products, luggage and luggage, right? Suitcases and bags and carry gear. Samsonite isn't a very exciting company. Peak Design is a very exciting company. They've got a personality behind their brand and they've done an amazing job of really putting their values forward on on all sorts of issues through all all sorts of channels. and I think that's paid dividends for them.

Neil Callanan

Yeah, I think there's also the relationship that the consumer has with Peak and any number of brands in that space, the sustainability and the messaging about caring is tied to how close of a relationship they have with their consumers. And, you know, Peter and the Peak team are having ongoing back and forth dialogue with their consumers all the time. And I think that closeness is amplified by their commitment to any number of things, whether it's on the values front, but like the idea of having a shared commitment to a value or sustainability or to advocacy, I think really brings consumers and brands closer together and gives them a reason to exist more than just a transaction. And I think people buy into the Peak ecosystem and they are fanboys all day, myself included. okay, we have a couple quick fires and then we will get you out of here. in the first, and I'm gonna tell you you can't use Peak or Patagonia, what brand or organization do you look up to?

Austin Whitman

man, I wish I'd been able to think about this ahead of time. I'm not a brand groupie, so I don't have any quick answers to that.

Neil Callanan

Could be a non profit, could be somebody you met at Climate Week last week.

Austin Whitman

I'm gonna, I'm gonna reveal just the hugely nerdy side of me which is I'm gonna go with Festool, which is a maker of tools. they're I think a German company and they make the most incredibly good looking and functional tools. You know, circular saws and stuff like that right that people who like that kind of stuff really really groove into but they're used in the trades so they're used by home contractors and they're used by hobbyists and I think what's amazing about their products is they've they've built this kind of hybrid brand that's both attractive to individuals as well as with proven durability. And that I think the durability factor is such an important thing that a lot of brands have lost sight of. I really want to be purchasing things that are gonna last for a long time. Lodge cast iron. There's another one for you. I've been a cast iron aficionado for the last 30 years, and cast iron is really trendy now.

Neil Callanan

well, as a fanboy of Lodge and as someone who grew up in a family of contractors, I very much understand the idea of a tool and the sort of feeling, like the literal feeling one has in its hands that when it's like not a you know Harbor Freight, whatever junk piece, it's just like

Austin Whitman

Yeah, totally.

Neil Callanan

it feels different and it changes your relationship with it, meaning like Honestly, if the crappy circular saw from Harbor Freight whatever breaks, I'm not gonna spend any time trying to fix that. It's gonna get thrown away and somebody's gonna buy another one for $79 or whatever, right? I think it creates relationships that are a little bit more lasting and that helps the brand become more of a part of how somebody identifies, So quality gives it a longevity.

Austin Whitman

Totally. thanks for making sense of my idea. Yeah. Appreciate that.

Neil Callanan

Thanks for dropping tool analogy. That doesn't happen much here. what do you wish you could measure?

Austin Whitman

I would like to measure every company's funding for climate solutions. That's what we're trying to do, but we would love to be doing it at a 10,000 X scale. I'd love to love for every company out there to be disclosing what they're what money they're putting into decarbonization. They're saying a lot. What are they doing?

Neil Callanan

Sounds like that's the start of the hope behind the tool that can allow people to at least pressure test themselves. this work is hard and draining. What do you do to refill your tank? scrub your cast iron pan,

Austin Whitman

scrub yeah, you don't really scrub it. You gotta just you—you—

Neil Callanan

I'm sorry for my poor.

Austin Whitman

baby it and then you season it. we have we have cast iron pans, I'm not kidding you, they're over a hundred years old. So take that. That's

Neil Callanan

Sounds that's that's how you're refilling your tank.

Austin Whitman

yeah, I'm a consummate dilettant. I have so many different hobbies and I can just dive into any one of my hobbies, whether it's writing or sourdough bread baking, which I was doing long before COVID. woodworking. I'm a cyclist and a hiker and trying to get my kids into all these things as well. And sailor and so any one of those things will be good enough for me. I'm actually starting to become a birder, even though I grew up birding and then and hated it for the first 40 of my life. but it's coming back.

Neil Callanan

And you're you're checking a lot of the boxes for the middle aged guys. you gotta get into birding or woodworking or cycling. It's like one of the things. Triathlons

Austin Whitman

Well, I guess that

Neil Callanan

and marathons, you know, you're yeah, just add it to the list.

Austin Whitman

I I've I've done all these things since last century.

Neil Callanan

I like their phrasing of that, last century. That's a good way to make it seem like a very long time ago, which it is. what podcast or book do you find yourself recommending most to others?

Austin Whitman

I've recommended the book The Light Eaters a lot to people recently. it's a book that I read this year, although it was published in 2024. amazing, totally mind-blowing write-up of when it comes to botany and how people understand what plants are capable of doing. I Think it's just amazing. And then podcast wise, you're talking to the wrong person when you if you want a fun and engaging recommendation. So I'm gonna give you my not fun and engaging recommendation, which is Shift Key Heatmap's podcast. I think Robinson Meyer is incredible. And if you want to learn anything about where clean tech is going and climate tech, listen to Shift key Yeah.

Neil Callanan

our most important question. If Sarah and I were coming to visit you in Boston, where would you send us to get the best sandwich? And what would your order be?

Austin Whitman

The best sandwich would have to be, you know, I forgot that I was supposed to figure out an answer to this question. The Parish

Neil Callanan

Mm-hmm.

Austin Whitman

parish cafe is is my answer to this question. my order would be probably be seasonally dependent. but if there's some good tomatoes, then it would definitely have some good fresh tomatoes in it.

Neil Callanan

And where is Parish Cafe? Where in Boston?

Austin Whitman

on Newbury Street.

Neil Callanan

Where can people follow your work and learn more about the Changed Climate Project?

Austin Whitman

Yeah, probably our most active social media presence is on LinkedIn. Second most active would be on Instagram. we have a newsletter, which we send out monthly. There's one version for consumers and one version for companies. and then we have a website, of course, and a blog that gets updated pretty frequently there. So those are the places people can always get in touch with me personally, Austin@changeclimate.org. Our website is changeclimate.org.

Neil Callanan

We'll put all that in the show notes. Austin Whitman is the CEO and co-founder of the Change Climate Project. For more than two decades, he's worked to build markets for clean energy, energy efficiency and carbon credits. Before co-founding the organization in 2019, his work spanned finance, consulting, and regulatory policy. At the Change Climate Project, he helps lead the transition from a climate neutral certified to the climate label, evolving both the certification requirements and how participating companies communicate their climate action. You'll find Austin somewhere in Boston looking for a bird or cleaning a Lodge pan. Thanks for being here, man.

Austin Whitman

Thanks, Neil. Great, great chat.

Get your sandwich

Picked by Austin Whitman

Whatever’s in season, with fresh tomatoes

Parish Café

361 Boylston Street, Back Bay, Boston, MA