ROI of Protecting Nature with Paul Hendricks (The Conservation Alliance) artwork

ROI of Protecting Nature The Conservation Alliance on the Business Value of Protected Land

Paul Hendricks, Executive Director, The Conservation Alliance

· 38 min

Summary

Paul Hendricks, Executive Director of The Conservation Alliance, a coalition of more than 270 businesses that fund and advocate for wild places, said the value of protected land shows up on the bottom lines of the companies that depend on it.

The outdoor industry is a trillion-dollar economy that is easy to miss when land is valued for the timber, oil and minerals it holds, but it shows up on the balance sheets of brands such as Patagonia, REI and New Belgium Brewing.

The Conservation Alliance's case shows that the value of protecting nature can be found in the business results of the companies that rely on it, not only in counts of acres and river miles.

Questions answered

How do you put a business value on protecting nature?

The value of protected land is found on the balance sheets of the businesses that depend on it, said Paul Hendricks, Executive Director of The Conservation Alliance. Land has long been valued for what can be extracted from it: the timber, the oil and the minerals. What was missed is the value land provides in its protected state, both to gateway communities that border national parks and monuments and to companies such as Patagonia, REI and New Belgium Brewing that make products for people to use in those places.

The outdoor industry is a trillion-dollar economy and one of the top five in the United States, and that value often gets lost because it does not appear on an annual balance sheet the way extracted resources do. The Alliance's work with decision makers and the public is to show that protected land and water has an economic value that sustains itself over time and can be the backbone of communities and businesses.

Should mission-driven companies talk about the ROI of their impact work?

Mission-driven companies should talk about it more, since they sometimes talk about impact too much and economics not enough. A company investing in getting voters out or giving employee time to volunteer should talk about the numbers behind it and what they mean for its ROI, because the movement of sustainable business will not scale, or reach large public companies, unless it proves the business value. Hendricks recalled Yvon Chouinard telling Patagonia town halls that doing the right thing for the planet had made the company more money.

The Conservation Alliance's founders took an altruistic view, and the Alliance now needs to show the ROI of investing in nature, of membership and of speaking out. It makes that case through customer retention and acquisition and employee retention and acquisition, noting how much younger generations care about the issue. Neil Callanan added that attracting better talent is part of the return.

What happens when a brand goes quiet on its values?

Customers notice, Hendricks said. A brand that pulls back from messaging it believes in because of a moment in the zeitgeist, such as stepping back from DEI or from talking about nature, will be seen to have stepped back when it returns. The Alliance's brand members that kept to their values and charged forward are the ones whose bottom lines he has seen move forward.

Some of the hesitancy may come from misaligned timelines, Paul suggested: a sustainability team works toward long-term goals while a public company answers to quarterly returns. Neil Callanan said that in his experience being bold has generally been a good business decision when a brand can stand behind it, and that the test is whether the company can explain how it is acting on the value it talks about.

How do you measure whether impact stories are working?

The Conservation Alliance measures how stories perform on its own channels and has found that certain types of stories resonate more than others. In its experience, numbers show impact and value, but people eventually forget them, while they never forget a compelling story. The Alliance relies on its brand partners' audiences and voices to tell the stories of the landscapes they helped protect and the tribal-led efforts they support.

After a brand partner publishes a story, the Alliance works with it on the messaging, the audience and the tactics for getting the story out. This raises a larger question the Alliance is still working on: how to show a brand the value of speaking up. The stories help partners' customers and employees see that the brand is acting on what it says.

Key takeaways

  • The Conservation Alliance reports tangible totals, including more than 120 million acres and 5,000 river miles protected since it was founded in 1989. It sees its less tangible but larger role as reframing the narrative around the value of nature.
  • Land has long been valued by the timber, oil and minerals that can be extracted from it, while the value of protected land to gateway communities and to brands such as Patagonia, REI and New Belgium Brewing was missed. The outdoor industry is a trillion-dollar economy and one of the top five in the United States.
  • As the Alliance grew beyond the core outdoor industry, it had to show the ROI of investing in nature, of Alliance membership and of speaking out, and it makes that case through customer retention and acquisition and employee retention and acquisition.
  • Paul Hendricks argued that mission-driven companies sometimes talk too much about impact and not enough about economics, and that sustainable business will not scale to large public companies unless it proves its business value.
  • The Alliance measures which stories resonate on its own channels, and after brand partners publish a story it works with them on the messaging, audience and tactics. In its experience, people forget numbers but never forget a compelling story.
  • Customers notice when a brand pulls back from messaging it believes in because of a political moment, and remember it when the brand returns. The Alliance members that kept going are the ones the Alliance has seen move their bottom lines forward.
  • Companies should talk more about collective impact than individual impact, because real change on public lands policy takes 10, 20 or 200 companies moving in the same direction.

Quotes

We always talk about the outdoor industry being a trillion dollar economy, a top 5 economy in the United States. And I think that often gets lost because sometimes it doesn't show up on an annual balance sheet ... but it shows up on the balance sheets of all of these businesses.

Paul Hendricks

Yvon always said at our town halls at Patagonia... every time I've done the right thing for the planet, I've made more money.

Paul Hendricks

We can't just rely on altruism anymore as much as that pains me to say that. We've got to create a business case for this.

Paul Hendricks

That shows impact, that shows value. But eventually people forget those. But people never forget a really compelling story.

Paul Hendricks

Frequently asked questions

Why have mission-driven companies been reluctant to put a dollar value on nature?

The hesitancy was stronger 10 to 20 years ago, when Yvon Chouinard, one of the Alliance’s founders, and Doug Tompkins of The North Face and Esprit were deep ecologists who held that nature has value in and of itself and should not be priced. Pressure on public lands has since pushed businesses to talk more about jobs, communities and economics, because that is what decision makers respond to.

How can conservation groups reach people who don't spend much time outdoors?

The work has to protect places and build the number of advocates at the same time. The Conservation Alliance has done that by bridging groups that have not always seen themselves in the same camp, pulling together outdoor brands and hunting and fishing companies, including Duct Tape Then Beer, MeatEater, First Lite and REI, around their shared use of public lands.

Why should companies talk about collective impact?

Real change happens when 10, 20 or 200 companies move in the same direction, and a shared narrative carries more weight with policymakers. Paul Hendricks of The Conservation Alliance said decision makers see the extractive industries' message as unified and the conservation message as divided.

What does The Conservation Alliance do?

The Conservation Alliance is a coalition of more than 270 businesses, from outdoor brands to brewers to banks, that pool their money and their voices to protect wild places across North America. Since 1989 it has helped protect more than 120 million acres and, through its members, granted nearly $35 million to community-led groups.

Who is Paul Hendricks?

Paul Hendricks is the Executive Director of The Conservation Alliance. He spent eight years leading social and environmental impact work at Patagonia, then built advocacy and philanthropic programs at Rivian, where he brought the company into the Alliance as a member before he took the role leading it.

About the guest

Paul Hendricks is the Executive Director of The Conservation Alliance, a coalition of more than 270 businesses that fund and advocate for the protection of wild places across North America. He has worked in conservation and corporate sustainability for more than 15 years. He spent eight years leading social and environmental impact work at Patagonia, including responsible business practices, advocacy and philanthropy, and taught in the University of Colorado’s Masters of the Environment Program. He joined the Alliance from Rivian, where he was Director of Community Sustainability and helped build its climate, responsible sourcing, environmental advocacy and philanthropic programs.

About this episode

Where does corporate hesitancy to speak up about environmental values actually come from?

In this episode, we sit down with Paul Hendricks, Executive Director of The Conservation Alliance, a coalition of more than 270 businesses, from outdoor brands to brewers to banks, that pool their money and their voices to protect wild places across North America. Paul knows the work from both sides of the table, spending eight years leading social and environmental impact at Patagonia, then building advocacy and philanthropic programs at Rivian, where he brought the company into the Alliance as a member before stepping in to lead it.

Neil and Paul get into why the outdoor economy rarely shows up on a balance sheet, even though it shows up on the balance sheets of every brand that depends on public lands.

Dive into the episode to hear Paul make the case that mission-driven companies talk too much about impact and not enough about economics, and explain why brands that go quiet on their values during a political moment pay for it later.

Transcript

Read the full transcript

Neil Callanan

Today on Measured Impact, we are joined by Paul Hendricks, the Executive Director at the Conservation Alliance, a coalition of more than 270 from outdoor brands to brewers to banks. They pool their money and their voices to protect wild places across North America. Since 1989, the Alliance has helped protect more than 125 million acres and through its members granted nearly 35 million to community-led groups. Paul knows the alliance for both sides of the table. He spent more than 15 years in conservation and corporate sustainability, including 8 years leading social and environmental impact work at Patagonia and building advocacy and philanthropic programs at Rivian, where he helped bring Rivian into the Alliance as a member. He's also taught at the University of Colorado's Masters of Environmental Program and leads the Alliance from his home in Golden, Colorado. Paul, welcome to the show.

Paul Hendricks

Thanks for having me, Neil. You did your research. That was my full bio there.

Neil Callanan

Yeah, well yeah, we're we're thorough around here. so I like to start out with an easy one, who are you? where do you live and what kind of work do you do?

Paul Hendricks

Yeah. I as you mentioned I live in Golden Colorado with my wife and my two kids, five and seven year old. And we're very fortunate to be right at the the start of the Rockies here. and so we've got a great playground of trails and rivers and all that fun stuff. and you'll probably hear me you talk about my kids a lot 'cause that's kind of the big pull on why I do this work. So as you mentioned, I'm the executive director at the Conservation Alliance. it's nice to connect, you caught me right between some some races and some training, which is always kind of the good pull to get outside and remember why we protect these things too. So, thanks again for having me.

Neil Callanan

Well now I gotta know 'cause this is why I do these things. What are the races and what are you training for?

Paul Hendricks

Good one. so we actually just put on a race. my friends and I did a mountain bike race up here in Frisco. And so we were we trained a lot for that. but right now I've just got a couple fun runs up in the Rockies with some friends, the Pawnee Buchanan Loop, which is in the Indian Peaks National Forest or Wilderness Area. and then my neighbor and I are gonna try to do the Grand Traverse Triple Crown next year, which is ski, bike, run, between Crested Butte and Aspen. I've got two little kids, so my training it it takes a little longer to ramp it all up these days. So I kinda have to plan. Yeah. Yeah.

Neil Callanan

It looks different. Very, very different. I just finished Chicago last weekend and

Paul Hendricks

nice.

Neil Callanan

happy to be in a place where I don't have five hours of running homework on every Saturday. That's that's good.

Paul Hendricks

Yep. Yeah.

Neil Callanan

well, you know, spent years on the member side at Patagonian and Rivian and now you lead the alliance, So I guess my first question to you is What looks different from the seat that you're in now and what sort of made you switch over in that direction rather than being on the member side?

Paul Hendricks

Yeah, yeah. good question. So I think, maybe the to pull back a little bit is, I've always found myself working and thinking probably way too much about the intersection of business and impact. right? your whole podcast is based off of, but it's like, what does it mean for a business to have a net positive impact on the world? and I think I got into this by working initially from for a nonprofit that we did a lot of work with communities down in South America, in Africa, and a lot of like the developing world, where they were having to fight for their water quality, for their natural resources because of the bad actors out there in the corporate space, you know, mining, gas, all that type of stuff. And so I spent a good amount of time working in that ecosystem at the end of the tailpipe and then, I just thought hey, why not why not get up upstream a little bit more? What does it look like to actually be in an organization? many of the ones that you've had on on your podcast, and really think about business as a force for good, instead of kind of a negative actor out of the world. And so I was very fortunate to have landed a job at Patagonia, which, you know, I think all of us could kind of say is the shining star or one of the shining stars in this world. I have way too many college degrees, but I always think my best education was just being at Patagonia for eight years, where I got to learn from Yvon Chouinard and Rick Ridgeway, these legends in terms of sustainable business. get in on the ground and think through how how you do things and really a crash course and what does it mean to be a whole different vision for what a corporation can do. and I will say from the inside, they they don't just talk the talk, they walk the walk. and that was really cool to be a part of. And then a bunch of my friends kind of migrated over to Rivian, who is also a very incredibly mission-driven company trying to electrify our transportation system and went over there and did a lot of work on, you know, supply chain decarbonization and all that. And then I was in a conversation with RJ Scaringe, the founder, and he said, Hey, what is Patagonia doing that we're not doing? And without missing a beat, I said, we at Rivian have amazing potential to get involved in kind of public lands policy right now and advocacy and really speaking up for these natural places. And so I pivoted a lot of focus there and we became members of the conservation alliance who I've always looked at as being really that focal point for businesses who really want to invest in nature, who want to get active in nature, who want to engage their employees and their customers. and so kind of got into that, into that world at Rivian. And then an opportunity came up to kind of to help drive the ship here at the Conservation Alliance. And I just, you know, I loved the exposure and the impact that I could have by being in touch with 200 businesses now, instead of just one and really, really helping everyone create not just a mission, but think through how nature is part of their core business strategy and how there is an ROI in terms of when you speak up and you invest in protecting our public lands and waters.

Neil Callanan

Then unfortunately you guys solved the issue and there's been nothing to protect over the last few years and everything's going the right direction. So nailed that done, checked, checked done. I just for those of you not

Paul Hendricks

We nailed it. We're just kinda just hanging out right now. Yeah, I just had coffee this morning.

Neil Callanan

you know, day to day in the the public lands discussions, you know, there's I would say over the last few years have been probably the most tenuous as it comes to the threats to large, important public lands, especially in the United States. and so I think that work is probably more important than ever, especially over the next few years. so, my question for you is, the Alliance obviously has a huge track record, and the mission is something that sort of feels very genuine to who you are and your your career sort of aligns right with that. when you're Looking at or you're talking to alliance members, What do you personally look to, or what do you tell your member companies to look to to know that it's working, right? Like what are you actually looking at in terms of measurement of the impact that the work that you or the alliance or or the brands within the alliance are are doing. how do you think about sort of bringing some tangibility to that?

Paul Hendricks

Yeah, that's a great question. I think it could maybe I'll answer in a couple of different ways. One is, you know, what's the impact of our alliance? So what's the impact of the 200 businesses that are investing in nature? And I think you can look at, some tangible things like we've protected over 120 million acres of land, 5000 river miles, like those are the numbers that are always great and they add up over time and we're 38 Eight years old now. and so that's a that's a huge track record. but the one thing that I always think I come back to from an alliance perspective is it's a little less tangible in terms of measured, but I I think we're actually getting to a better place. It's thinking through what role do we play in terms of reframing the narrative around the value of nature? and so you know, I think if you look back and you know. I have a master's degree from University of Chicago where Milton Friedman was the, the the lead scholar who, always said the sole responsibility of businesses is to maximize shareholder profit. and so I always view my role as saying like actually the the responsibility of businesses is to maximize stakeholder value. And so what do we what does that mean in terms of the value that we're providing to all of our stakeholders, including nature? And how does that come back to providing value for those businesses and for their bottom lines? And so, with that construct, I think if you look back, it's easy to measure the value of public lands or any lands and waters by thinking through what's the timber that can be extracted, the value on that, what's the oil, what's the minerals that can be pulled out of the ground, how do you quantify that and what's that in terms of a balance sheet? but I think what we've missed for a long time, and we're we're getting better at it, is saying, well, what's the other value that land provides in its protected state? And what does that mean for businesses who either are directly on the border of a national monument or a national park in these gateway communities? What's their economics and how is that related to protected land? But also, what's the bottom line impact of protected lands on Patagonia, on REI, on New Belgium Brewery? These companies who are making products for people to go out and enjoy at the places. And so I think there's it's not maybe not always direct math in terms of a direct line through the value and and kind of the origin of the value. But it is there. And so we always talk about the outdoor industry being a trillion dollar economy, a top 5 economy in the United States. And I think that often gets lost because sometimes it doesn't show up on an annual balance sheet through, the the oil and gas agency or whatever. but it shows up on the balance sheets of all of these businesses. And so what we're really trying to do is work with decision makers, work for the public and say, there is economic value to protected land and water. And actually it It's one that sustains itself over time. It can provide the backbone for communities, for businesses. and how do we start to measure that impact? And that number is starting to grow if you look at numbers about the the value of the outdoor industry, right? It it continues to grow every year. And I think the core driver of that is our lands and waters. So that's kind of how we think about it at the macro level.

Neil Callanan

Yeah, it's really interesting to of talk about the downstream impacts of what recreation opportunities can provide other than just themselves. I guess it leads me to ask, are are you finding that your member organizations or just generally in the industry, people are almost hesitant to talk dollars and cents in terms of the economic impact? sort of like, no, we're here to save the planet. We're not here to make money. is that as pervasive as it might seem?

Paul Hendricks

That's a really good question, Neil. I think if you went back 10, 15, 20 years, I think the hesitancy to talk about dollars and cents of nature there was a greater hesitancy there. I think, you know, especially if you think through the founding of the conservation alliance, it was, you know, Yvon Chouinard and a handful of other CEOs and Yvon, I think he and Doug Tompkins from North Face and Esprit, They're called deep ecologists, which is saying, like, hey, nature has its value because of its value in and of itself. And it shouldn't be tried to be quantified in terms of dollars and cents. and so I think that came about for a long time, And I think there was always a hesitancy to put dollars on land and water. but like the reality, you know, you mentioned this, like this has been the hardest year and a half for nature that we've ever experienced. you know, I think the administration alone has taken over 500 actions to remove protections for public lands and waters. And so we have we have to talk differently. We have to think about a new narrative. And what we've continued to say is like, hey, you know, decision makers in DC, they care about jobs, they care about community development, and they care about economics. So how do we start to bring that into there? And I think people understand that. it may not be the reason people always act, there's so many altruistic folks out there, but that need to reframe how we talk about nature, I think has caused businesses to think about it a little bit more. and maybe flex into a little bit more talking about the dollars and cents.

Neil Callanan

Yeah, I think, we're at kind of a weird inflection point, right? Where there's like, kind of green hushing from one direction and then simultaneously it's more important than ever. And I think even with some of the folks that we've interviewed, I'm not sure the folks that we work with day to day, there's still is often some hesitancy to tie anything to the bottom line and especially when it comes to things as important as protecting, you know, public lands. my argument is typically, but the other guys are, right? You know, the other guys are saying, yes,

Paul Hendricks

Yeah.

Neil Callanan

we can extract this many dollars worth of oil from that space, right? So I think one of the questions that it drives me to is, When you talk about public lands, there is a set of people, I don't know what portion of people, you probably know the number, will ever experience them, right? in a meaningful way, in the way that that you or I have, right? In a way that is like so blatantly obvious what the reasons that you would protect these things are. The people who are experiencing these lands on a day-to-day basis they feel almost too distant from people who have not. And these people

Paul Hendricks

Yeah.

Neil Callanan

are going, I've never been to Zion or, a national park generally. So what do I care about adding another one? Right. So I'm interested in how you think about the approachability of these messages and if there are ways as an industry, the outdoor industry, can do a better job speaking to maybe people who aren't gonna do a grand traverse or they're not gonna go do a three day, you know, backcountry thing. how do we speak to those people?

Paul Hendricks

yeah, I think, people have always said you're gonna protect what you love. And if we don't have the majority of Americans out there enjoying and loving nature, then your question is very poignant. And I think that's the reality is that especially right now, you're looking at participation in outdoor recreation opportunities and some sectors and some age divisions are going up, but especially like teenage boys. I've saw a recent study that said like teenage boys aren't getting out there anymore. Like they're playing video games, they're doing all these things. So I think I think we've got a huge challenge in front of us in terms of our public lands, but also what is the future of that look like. And it's kind of like A simultaneous set of actions that have to happen, which is one is we need to protect these places so that they're there to enjoy in the future. And then we also need to build the amount of advocates who are going to be out there protecting those places, right? I don't think you can get one too far ahead of the other because otherwise, you know, it's gonna fall off and we're gonna end up kind of in a place where we are right now. You know, I think our responsibility is to rethink who those people are and how we can start to in the short term build bridges across all public lands users who may not have always seen themselves in the same camp as each other. and one example is this past fall, we worked with folks at Duct Tape Then beer, which is the dirtbag diaries podcast, MeatEater, First Lite REI, we pulled together this amazing coalition of what you would call the typical outdoor industry and the hunting and fishing industry. And we said, hey, you know what? We may typically have sided different politically. We may have differences on the particulars, but ultimately we are fighting for the same thing because we all use public lands and waters in some way, shape, or form. It might be because you rock climb, or you might hunt. It might fish or you might kayak, but ultimately we need these places. And so I think that's a huge challenge right in front of us right now is to pull the current disparate advocates together into a unified narrative because right now decision makers in DC don't see our narrative as being unified, but they do see the narrative of extractive industries being unified. And so that's why we're losing some of that fight. long term is a huge challenge in terms of continuing to bring that together, but also make sure that the number of people who are out there experiencing nature grows and they're out there advocating for things.

Neil Callanan

This is a total tangent, but I wonder if you guys do any take a politician out to nature things, I

Paul Hendricks

Yeah.

Neil Callanan

I know that like a lot of countries, like literal countries where you're trying to, you know, influence policy-level decisions will like bring congressional staffers over to wherever

Paul Hendricks

Special snappers over to

Neil Callanan

to show them around slash get them on their side, right? has there been any efforts that you know of that are sort of like, trying to get these folks who maybe are DC politicians to experience it and let that experience kinda do the talking?

Paul Hendricks

Yeah. Yeah. there's a big movement to do that, and especially now, I think we need to get beyond the the choir just saying get them out there right, and which is always the challenge, and then to get them to to act on something. I talked to a New York Times journalist a couple months ago who wrote a piece about, you know, his theory was that the reason that politicians aren't standing up for public lands and waters right now is because they're on golf courses versus out in the forest. and if you look back at Teddy Roosevelt and that whole heritage of how a lot of our public lands system got established, it was very different from what you probably see from a lot of politicians right today. so I think to your point, we can do a better job at that for sure. And I think it's a huge, it's a huge push to get people out there. out of DC, out of their state offices and onto the landscapes.

Neil Callanan

How do you think about storytelling and how important is it to your job?

Paul Hendricks

So, I think in terms of communicating the value of what we're trying to do here, there's always a number of different avenues you can you can approach. And we always lead with a lot of numbers sometimes, which those are great, right? That shows impact, that shows value. but eventually people forget those. but people never forget a really compelling story. I think we could all go back to, the time spent around a fire or even listening to someone in a conference hall who just pulled you forward and pulled you into a landscape or a place or an experience and you never forget that. and so we're trying to do that through our brands. We know that our brands have amazing storytelling capacity. They have a huge audience and they have a huge voice. And so what we do on a regular basis is try to work with a lot of our partners to tell the stories of, what are the landscapes in their backyard that they, through the conservation alliance, protected? what are the things, what are the areas, what are the the tribal led efforts that they're supporting and how do we get those stories out there? and so we do that through the megaphone of our brand partners a lot. And, hopefully that provides value for them as well because their customers and their employees can see that they're actually speaking up in their they're walking the walk a little bit.

Neil Callanan

And are you guys at a place today where you can measure how successful each of those stories are? at more than just the impact that is being told, right? But the the actual the reach of the story, the engagement, the depth of interaction, and video consumption, content consumption. are you guys able to put numbers behind those that helps let you look and see which stories are are resonating with the audience most?

Paul Hendricks

Yeah, yeah. if it's on our own channels, we certainly do that. And we we've found that certain types of stories definitely resonate more and better with others. And so we measure that. And then we often work with brand partners after they put something out there to think about that and think about the messaging, think about the audience and the tactics to get that story out there. you know, I think it kind of begs a kind of a leveled up question of like How do you show value to a brand for speaking up and doing this work? And I think that's something we're continuing to evolve on. You know, I think if you look— 1989 when the conservation alliance started, it was very altruistic. It was saying, like, hey, we got a few brands that want to get together, we want to do the right thing, we want to get out there. but as we start to expand beyond the core outdoor industry, which maybe has a direct line into protecting nature, We found we need to really create what's the what's the roi on investing in nature? What's the roi investing membership in the conservation alliance or giving money to other nonprofits? What's the roi of speaking out from an advocacy perspective? and so we try to quantify that we talk about that through you know customer retention, customer acquisition, employee retention, employee acquisition. we know that Gen Z, Gen Alpha, I forget what generation we're on right now, those are the people who really care about this, and so we we try to lean on that and pull those numbers forward we can't just rely on altruism anymore as much as that pains me to say that. we've got to create a business case for this. And so that's what we're trying to do through a lot of those metrics.

Neil Callanan

Yeah, I think my general hypothesis and belief from all the folks we talked to on this show and then the other folks that we work with on an ongoing basis is like, there's often this hesitancy to even look that direction. And part of it is capability, right? Like could we even figure it out? How does our advocacy impact our bottom line? But there's also just like an inherent hesitancy that no, those two things are different. When we're talking about saving the world, we're not we're not talking about selling more fleeces, right? the more I talk to brands who are getting further down that funnel, it really opens up some avenues to being more bold and consistent with with advocacy or values or mission-driven stuff when you can go, hey, and look, we we sell we actually sell more ice cream the next day. And

Paul Hendricks

Yeah.

Neil Callanan

and look, we we actually we sold out of those fleeces that were designed just specifically to whatever, right? Like I think there's a hesitancy to connect those things, but when you see the brands who are able to connect those dots, it's so powerful because then it's so measurable that you can say, Not only are we saving in the planet, but when we save the planet, we actually sell more shit. And when we sell more shit, we can save more of the planet. And it's a cycle that has an opportunity to be exponential over time, right? but I think there's a little bit of puritanical thinking sometimes that that maybe prevents that from being a path people want to go down.

Paul Hendricks

Yeah. Can I ask you a question on that? 'cause I think it's always interesting to think about what do you think the hesitancy where does that come from? 'Cause I always think about like risk and reward when we're trying to get people to take action. and I'm curious from your side, working with a lot of those brands, is the hesitancy to kind of speak up and do something, is it because they're afraid of being called out as hypocrites or is it the green hushing stuff that's going on or Where's the root cause of that?

Neil Callanan

Yeah, I would say there's definitely especially more with our corporate customers, like on the the business to business side, you know, there's there's a shift away from progressive sentiment at all, right? Talking about DEI, talking about any of that stuff. And I would say that comes from just, say nothing and it's easier. But I would say on the brands who are more consistently progressive and have been advocating of things for a long time, it actually comes down to a fairly systemic structural thing. And maybe you saw this at Rivian, even though they're very progressive. the marketers and the folks on the impact side are not always talking, right? you know, so it's interesting on this show, we talked to both folks who are kind of heads of Philanthropy or impact or whatever, and also people who are running marketing.

Paul Hendricks

Yeah.

Neil Callanan

at very progressive companies, right? And I think the short answer to that question is the hesitancy comes from they think of their objectives as different, right?

Paul Hendricks

Yeah.

Neil Callanan

And the marketer's job is to keep attention and grow their audience and sell some shit, and the impact or the missions person is more pure mission-driven, pure, we're trying to do these things. And it becomes really hard for those two to talk in ways that you think that they would, because their day-to-day portions of their jobs are a little bit different. So it's like, the marketers thinking about all the mission-driven stuff as like content opportunities, more than opportunities for impact, ways to increase our ROI, whatever, right? And then on the Impact side of the philanthropy side or the value side, it's sort of like, no, we're changing the planet. Like you guys figure out how talk about it, right? Like it's

Paul Hendricks

Yeah.

Neil Callanan

that's your job. You talk about it, right? And I think it's like literally just those people don't talk as much as you would think. They're more siloed than you would think, especially at the bigger the companies, right? They could come

Paul Hendricks

Yeah.

Neil Callanan

from the space where we're like, assumption that of course the head of sustainability is talking to the CMO but Maybe not at all, right? They might not have any collaborative work that they do other than like, yeah, we pushed out our impact report. Marketers, can you please get some eyeballs on this thing, right? It's like folks don't know how more than that they are scared to. And if you don't know how, then you're a little bit more likely to just not do the thing.

Paul Hendricks

Yeah, yeah. one thought on that too is I wonder if sometimes the timeline of goals and objectives of different departments at a company are misaligned. you know, in thinking through what's the long-term goal of a sustainability department or whatever, and the short term goal in terms of especially in public companies, of quarterly returns. and I think those sometimes are misaligned. what I would say to a lot of that in terms of businesses speaking up right now is, if you're pulling back from messaging that you believe in because of a moment in the zeitgeist, right? Pulling back from DEI, pulling back from talking about nature, your customers are gonna see that, right? And then when that moment comes back and you jump back into it, like they're gonna know that you responded and that you didn't stick to the values. And I think that's where We've seen a lot of our brand members who haven't done that, right? Who they just say this is what we do and this is what we're doing. And they're they're charging forward. I think they're the ones who I've seen, in the news, their bottom line is going forward because people appreciate that.

Neil Callanan

Yeah, and I would say Without diving into any specifics, right? Universally, over the last year, if you were to look at our clients on the agency side and even the folks I talk to on this podcast, bold is generally a good business decision if you can

Paul Hendricks

Yeah.

Neil Callanan

stand behind it. you know, of the first things we look for when we do client engagement is to see if there's any halo effect. And basically the halo effect is this idea of when you talk about your values, How does that impact the follow-on content that maybe has nothing to do with that, right? So if Ben and Jerry's talks about Getting everybody registered to vote or systemic racism. Okay, well, what happens the next post where they're talking about a new flavor launch or whatever? And almost universally, we have seen that the impact is positive on brands' reach, on their engagement, on their fans, and it it sort of gives opportunities to have those conversations. And I'll wrap my soliloquy on what I tell our clients is if they can answer a question about how they are doing a thing then they should be talking about it and there is some rightful pushback on everybody posting about their corporate values on Black History Month and interracial high five in the boardroom and then pictures of the team on Earth Day doing a thing, right? And what I generally ask of our clients if they care to hear me say is like, as long as you can tell me how, right? You're committed to expanding opportunities for African Americans in your workforce. How? You're committed to saving the Planet from more refuse. Okay, how? And if you can answer that question, then I generally think it's worth talking about. And if you can't, then I think it's a pretty quick indicator that you're virtue signaling, right? Like if you won't have a

Paul Hendricks

Yeah.

Neil Callanan

very easy path to you are doing something, maybe it's not perfect, maybe it's not everything, but if you're doing a thing, then you're putting energy into it, you might as well be talking about it. I think to your point, one of the understated Place on the ROI discussion is we're all competing for the best talent. we all want the best team members. Team members want work with companies who don't suck, who believe in the things that they believe in, right? And so, like, this idea of the ROI, maybe it's on the bottom line if you sell more stuff, but it also just might mean you can attract better talent and that is demonstrably profitable, right? You attract better talent talent.

Paul Hendricks

Yeah. Yeah.

Neil Callanan

You get better work.

Paul Hendricks

Yeah. And product people will tell you there's a whole lot of differentiation between ice cream A and ice cream B and down jacket and down jacket B. It's like it's pretty minimal. the people are gonna work and buy that stuff because of the broader values that they stand behind.

Neil Callanan

So I guess when I'm thinking about mission-driven leadership, what metrics or numbers do you think get too much attention and which do you think deserve a little bit more when you're talking to, you know, leaders in whether that's in the nonprofit space or in the brand side, like what do you think we're talking about too much as a measurement of success? And what are we talking about too little?

Paul Hendricks

Yeah. This might sound counterintuitive, but sometimes we talk about impact maybe too much, and we don't talk about the economics enough to the point we we were just talking about. Like, if you are being bold and you're doing the right thing, you're investing 11 million dollars in getting voters out or you're, contributing a ton of money or your employee time to go, volunteer. talk about it. That's great. But talk about the numbers that lie behind that and what that means for your ROI. Cause I think that's the biggest thing. I think we always been like, let's not talk about the numbers enough. But this movement of sustainable businesses, conscious capitalism, whatever, it's not going to scale unless we prove the business value behind it. we're not going to get the big companies, the public companies to do it if they don't see that there is actually an ROI on it. So I don't think you should be afraid to to talk about it. Yvon always said in at our town halls of Patagonia is like "every time I've done the right thing for the planet, I've been made more money." So talk about that. And that's okay. Don't be ashamed of that. and I know that sounds like a ruthless capitalists and I'm not, I'm pretty pretty farther than the other side of things. But like if we're gonna make this thing move and actually have a bigger impact, let's take a playbook from other other industries and let's talk about how this is good business.

Neil Callanan

Yeah, I think the industry as a whole has had a little bit of a, by the industry I just basically mean any mission or or impact-driven, you know, planet-first messaging. We're fighting against, you guys are fighting against, everybody's fighting a little bit against the glamour metrics of nature, right? and were very pervasive, I would say, 7 or 8 years ago, maybe little bit more, right? this movement of plant billion trees and look how

Paul Hendricks

Yeah.

Neil Callanan

and I think those numbers all started to really lose value. And, you know, it for the reason of A, they weren't necessarily always told in the best manner, but B, some were just bullshit, right? There's like we have to acknowledge there was a lot of like, green washing that was happening. So I think instead of saying, well, we should say nothing, the the challenge is how do you get people to think about, well, what can we say? And what do we say that talks about our real story and our real impact in ways that are tangible, not like shipped a thousand extra pairs of shoes to wherever, right? okay,

Paul Hendricks

Yeah. Yeah.

Neil Callanan

and then what, right? and how is that different from the other four companies who say they did that?

Paul Hendricks

Yeah. the other metric, that I realize this runs against a marketer's goals and objectives, but sometimes I wish we would just talk about our collective impact versus our individual impact a little bit more. you know, everyone wants to talk about their contribution to X, Y, or Z and this is what this company did. But real change only happens when we have 10 companies. 20 companies, 200 companies moving in the same direction. And we shouldn't be afraid to own that collective impact or communicate that. And I again, I know there's there's businesses, need to talk about how their business is different, but I think it'd be fascinating to talk about collective impact a little bit more and how we're all marching together because then that narrative, that broader communication construct, that's gonna make real change when we talk about policy or we talk about. informing what's gonna happen for investments in public lands or in the National Park Service.

Neil Callanan

Yeah, I think that if we were to just take lessons from the opposition, if we stick to the public lands argument, right? it feels pretty unified on the opposition. It's like, well, we can get more money and these people aren't doing anything with this land anyway. Who are they gonna save it for the whoever's, right? And yet, on the other side of the argument, It doesn't feel as much like a movement, right? And you know, it sounds like some of the conversations you guys are trying to enable with different stakeholders and you know are are in that direction, but I do think there is like a lack of consistency in message. how do you bring these people together? And think that's the thing that still needs a lot of work is just getting this generalized community to feel like a group that people can identify with. It can help people understand that this collective impact has a big, big opportunity to continue to, put up a fight against petrochemical.

Paul Hendricks

Yeah. Yeah. there's a greater narrative of "we" that we can all work harder at establishing to find people who come from different parts of the country, different ages, different demographics that they all identify with being a public land user, at its core in that you then protect it. So I think you're I think you're right. I think there's a lot of work we're a little siloed and we can keep doing a better job at that. Yeah.

Neil Callanan

Yeah. All right. I'm gonna hit some quick fires and then we will get you out of here. First one is what brand or organization do you look up to?

Paul Hendricks

yeah. so I'm gonna I'm gonna go really hyperlocal. I'm from northern Michigan and there's this great company up there called Cherry Republic, which is they make products from the cherry fields in northern Michigan. and they do so much work investing in their local community, investing in the local land conservancy, investing in local nature and everything and that. the founder up there I know I used to, run up around northern Michigan with a little bit and he's just an amazing person. So I always kinda look up to them as being, small company, but they just have such a outsize impact and they're using their voice and their dollars in the right way.

Neil Callanan

And are the products like, consumables or what are we we're talking about? Yeah.

Paul Hendricks

Yeah. It's like cherry salsa, cherry jams. Yeah. I worked up there one summer at the they have a cherry winery, which is just no offense, but it's like Kool-Aid. And you dig at these wine snobs who would come in here and wanna, taste the dry things. I was like, guys, this is fruit

Neil Callanan

Yeah.

Paul Hendricks

punch. It's okay. Just call it that. Don't try to impress anybody with your wine snobbery. Yeah.

Neil Callanan

Yeah, no, you gotta let it be what it be. what do you wish you could measure?

Paul Hendricks

I wish I could measure the joy on my kids' faces when we are out in the woods. I can certainly, see it. I can certainly I guess I can measure the width of their smile, but I wish I could quantify that. and I wish I could tell everyone what that means and multiply that across every kid in this nation, to show how amazing nature is.

Neil Callanan

I think I know the answer to this next one. How do you refill your tank?

Paul Hendricks

I get outside it's running. we live on the the some trail systems right here. so it's just getting out, even though right now it's often in the dark by myself, but that's still okay. I just movement in nature is how I refill my tank.

Neil Callanan

What book or podcast do you find yourself recommending most others?

Paul Hendricks

Hmm. what book? I'm gonna say River of Doubt is a phenomenal one about Teddy Roosevelt. and just talks about just I think, you know, we always hear about, his work that happened, as a presidency, but I think that gives a really good picture of what he was as a person and just the tenacity that he brought to life. and I think it's a really good kind of metaphor for what we're what we're facing right now and how we gotta We gotta dig in deep right now. so I always reference River of Doubt as a good book. Yeah.

Neil Callanan

Yeah, it's a very it's a very good read and it'll make you I'm sure there's plenty of reasons to not lionize any previous president, but It I'm envious of a time of just somebody who spent some time outside as a regular part of their life and how that

Paul Hendricks

Yeah. Totally.

Neil Callanan

could help their decision making, but also just who they are, right?

Paul Hendricks

yeah, we shouldn't, you know, put on a pedestal that isn't deserved. everyone has their flaws, but I think there's some some things you could pull forward there in terms of just the value of getting out there, the value of just exploration, the value of working hard and not giving up on things. So yeah, I love that book.

Neil Callanan

If I were coming to Golden or Denver Broadly, where would you send me to get the best sandwich?

Paul Hendricks

Ooh, so I'm gonna pivot. If I don't have to do a sandwich, can I say a burrito? because there's a maze.

Neil Callanan

if you want to call burrito a sandwich, we won't tell you there's any rules here. So

Paul Hendricks

It's all the same stuff, right? It's carbs and filling. You just wrap it up differently. So there's a great place called Bonfire Burritos here in Golden, which has just phenomenal burritos and it's kind of my go to whenever I have bring someone out here. it's

Neil Callanan

And what's your what's your order, I said.

Paul Hendricks

the the chicken burrito with the mixed salsa. So they've got a really hot one and a mild one, but they'll also combine them for those of us who can't take too much heat.

Neil Callanan

Nice. where can people follow your work personally or go to learn more about the Conservation Alliance?

Paul Hendricks

Yeah. we've got all the the social medias @ the Conservation Alliance. follow our our Instagram, our LinkedIn, all that. and definitely if you're interested in learning more, go to our website, sign up for our newsletter and we can plug you in different ways.

Neil Callanan

Paul Hendricks is the executive director of the Conservation Alliance. He has worked in conservation and corporate sustainability for more than 15 years. Before the alliance, he helped build the climate responsible sourcing, environmental advocacy, and philanthropic programs at Rivian and Patagonia. Before Rivian, he taught at the University of Colorado's Masters of Environmental Program and spent 8 years leading Patagonia's social and environmental impact work. Paul, thanks for being here, man.

Paul Hendricks

Thank you. This is a great conversation. Thanks for all that you're doing to pull us all forward.

Get your sandwich

Picked by Paul Hendricks

Chicken burrito with the mixed salsa

Bonfire Burritos

2221 Ford Street, Golden, CO

A burrito in place of a sandwich. The mixed salsa combines the hot and the mild.